Apple's WWDC keynote was like no other. Why that's a good thing
Commentary: Forget the lines. Apple put on a show that sets the stage for virtual events in a coronavirus world.
Connie GuglielmoSVP, AI Edit Strategy
Connie Guglielmo is a senior vice president focused on AI edit strategy for CNET, a Red Ventures company. Previously, she was editor in chief of CNET, overseeing an award-winning team of reporters, editors and photojournalists producing original content about what's new, different and worth your attention. A veteran business-tech journalist, she's worked at MacWeek, Wired, Upside, Interactive Week, Bloomberg News and Forbes covering Apple and the big tech companies. She covets her original nail from the HP garage, a Mac the Knife mug from MacWEEK, her pre-Version 1.0 iPod, a desk chair from Next Computer and a tie-dyed BMUG T-shirt. She believes facts matter.
ExpertiseI've been fortunate to work my entire career in Silicon Valley, from the early days of the Mac to the boom/bust dot-com era to the current age of the internet, and interviewed notable executives including Steve Jobs.Credentials
Member of the board, UCLA Daily Bruin Alumni Network; advisory board, Center for Ethical Leadership in the Media
If you've ever wondered how quickly 5,000 seats in a convention center auditorium can fill up,
Worldwide Developers Conference is a good gauge. I can say from personal experience that the running crowd of enthusiastic Apple fans, some of whom have literally knocked me down to the carpeted ground in their rush to get a seat up front near company executives and celebrity guests, has clocked in at five minutes -- or less.
Could Apple, whose slickly staged events have set a high bar for product unveilings, pull off a virtual keynote with the flourish and flair of its in-person extravaganzas and without the clapping crowds? Could Apple come up with a model for delivering product news that the rest of the industry might copy while we're in lockdown? Would reporters, investors and partners tune in and find something interesting to watch, without first being plied with gourmet pastries, vegan snacks and high-octane espressos brewed by Cafe Mac baristas?
The answer, judging by the reaction I've heard from developers, industry analysts, users and even many of us journalists who've also rushed for seats: Yep. And the virtual event may be the start of more to come.
It might not feel the same as being there in person. And don't get me wrong, there's value in having face-to-face time with executives and others. But Apple showed that we really don't need to travel to cover every big product event in person, particularly during a pandemic.
In a one hour, 48 minute show mostly filmed at the Steve Jobs Theater at the company's headquarters in Cupertino, California, Cook and a cadre of executives talked about updated versions of Apple's key software. They demoed the new iOS 14 mobile operating system that powers its money-making
, the latest iteration of the MacOS system software, dubbed Big Sur, and new software features for the
, including an app that monitors when you're washing your hands to let you know if you've scrubbed them for long enough. Apple plans to dig deeper into each topic in sessions that are now available to the public.
"This will probably be the most effective WWDC Apple has ever had since it allowed them to bring in more developers than the 5,000 they can squeeze into a physical event," said longtime analyst Tim Bajarin of Creative Strategies, who has attended hundreds of Apple events. "In that sense, it was a highly successful format that meets the needs of Apple developers."
Apple didn't tell me how many people tuned in for the keynote, but WWDC was a trending topic on social media during the event, and iOS 14 remained a top trending term throughout the day. Apple's shares were also up during the keynote and closed up 2.6 percent to $358.87 in regular trading on Monday, a sign that investors were happy with the software news and the company's decision to start making Mac computers with its own chips.
"It's about moving the platforms forward," said one Apple insider, who asked not to be named. "The world is counting on all of us -- Apple and our developer community -- to help move forward. That's why we felt it was incredibly important to hold the conference this year but to do it in an entirely new and unique way."
Apple isn't the first company to stage a big product rollout during the coronavirus. In April, OnePlus did an hour-long live keynote with a single presenter onstage addressing a "big empty room" to unveil its new handset. Executives around the world dropped in, Zoom-like, to add their thoughts amid the recorded marketing videos. (One of my colleagues described watching it as "brutal.")
Xbox team hosted a virtual event, announcing new games for its Xbox Series X console launching in the fall. But Microsoft's presentation, billed as a reveal of new games and what it'll look like playing them, was panned by fans who felt it didn't give them what they wanted, my colleague Ian Sherr reported. "Clearly we set some wrong expectations & that's on us," tweeted Aaron Greenberg, a general manager of Xbox games marketing.
In contrast, Apple took us many places, passing the screen back and forth between Cook and executives in other parts of the Apple Park headquarters, showing software chief Craig Federighi running around the Steve Jobs Theater and even cutting to an executive in an "undisclosed location" where its new silicon was developed, a nod to Apple's penchant for secrecy. The video quality was, as usual, pretty slick. "Apple excels in its video and graphics," said Bajarin.
He wasn't the only one who gave Apple high marks for its production.
Instead of hosting the keynote live, Apple recorded it in a way that struck the "right balance between being well produced but not overproduced," said Carolina Milanesi, another longtime tech analyst who's attended dozens of Apple events in person over the years.
"The advantage [with] everybody being digital is that we all get first-row seats, which really democratizes the event," she said. "Digital events might also bring a more inclusive lineup of speakers, and that is simply because you have access to people in different locations and the advantage of recording versus being live. And this morning did feel more inclusive than usual."
In addition to Cook, Apple had eight men and 11 women take us through the news -- probably the most women I've ever seen onstage at one of Apple's product events.
Milanesi also applauded Cook for kicking off the keynote by voicing his support for Black Lives Matter and acknowledging the civil unrest in the US after George Floyd, an unarmed Black man, was killed by Minneapolis police last month. Apple has pledged $100 million to fight for racial justice. Cook also thanked those on the front line battling the coronavirus. Apple closed the keynote with credits describing the health and safety precautions it put in place to produce the event, including daily health screenings and temperature checks, social distancing, having its executives wear masks except when talking on-camera and making sure production locations were sanitized.
"Many big companies were watching it for how it was created and delivered," said Bajarin. "I do think that we will see more events move to this model in the future. It is much cheaper than holding in-person events. And it also still gets the information to the people that count."
And it does all that without anyone getting trampled.