Apple faces off with DOJ in e-books trial
3:34

Apple faces off with DOJ in e-books trial

Tech Industry
-Hello and welcome to Inside Scoop. I'm Sumi Das and joining me is Josh Lowensohn, senior writer for CNET. Josh, thanks for being with us. -Great to be here. -Okay. So, Apple's corporate legal team is getting a workout last year. It was the patent trial of the century, which they won. This year, it's a slightly different set of players. It's Apple versus the DOJ. What is the case? What are the charges? -Sure. So, last year, the Department of Justice basically sued Apple along with a bunch of book publishers, the major book publishers, accusing them of fixing prices on e-books. So, their basic argument was that, when Apple came along, prices for e-books went from $10 up to $12, $13, $14, $15. So, the DOJ is really trying to figure out whether they all worked together to make that happen and how that really affected the e-books market. -And so far, it's just been day one of opening arguments, right? -Yeah, this thing basically just started. It's said to last about three weeks, so both sides kind of opened up today and they were gonna see witnesses from both sides including Apple's Eddy Cue who runs-- -Uh-huh. -the iBookstore and runs iTunes and iCloud along with some of the CEOs from the major publishers. -Apple was offered a settlement. They've said that they turned it down. They're the only ones, right? I mean, everybody else settled out of court? -Yup. And a lot of the legal experts we talked to before the trial started said that Apple is actually gonna settle. It's almost guaranteed. But then last week, Tim Cook, during an interview, said, "You know what, they offered us a settlement. We said we wouldn't sign it because-- -Right. -it basically said that we're wrong and we are making bad decisions." And they said they didn't wanna do that. -They didn't wanna make that admission. -Exactly. But at the same time, you know, the judge in this case in a pre-trial hearing said, "You know what, I kind of-- I'm siding with the DOJ. It looks like Apple doesn't really have quite the case. So, that's what kind of makes this interesting. What does Apple really have up its sleeve? They kind of make something. They're gonna win it. -Do we have an idea of what their case might be? I mean, based on sort of the responses we've seen so far? -Yeah. You know, so far, they really say that this is similar to music. Before they came along, you know, it was kind of scattered. People weren't really making as much money. It was hard for consumers and then they came along with the iPad and the iBookstore, and all of a sudden, everything worked out again. I don't know if people are gonna buy that. -Uh-huh. -I think one of the key problems here is that, before they came on, books were a lot cheaper,-- -Right. -but Apple's argument so far has really been the publishers weren't really making a lot of money. So, if you look at something like music-- -They were doing the publishers a favor. -Exactly. If you look at something like music, it made sense that, maybe, people weren't getting paid 'cause of piracy. And Steve Jobs at that time argued that if you price this any lower, people are just gonna stop buying it. -Okay. So, why is this case significant? I mean, we are seeing huge increases in the amount of people who were reading e-books, right? -Yeah, it's not just about the product itself or the e-books. It's also about how much control a company can have over fixing these prices if that's indeed what happened. If you look at something like this, it's all about a clause. It says, one company has to get the same price as another company-- -Uh-huh. -as long as it's lower and that's kind of been on-- you know, it's kind of a semantic issue, but it also kind of takes that idea and says, "What else could this be applied to? Not just books but also movies, TV shows, anything like that." -Any precedent that it might set? -And if you look at a company like Apple or Amazon or anybody else, well, they have their hands in all these different markets. Something like this can have a very big impact. -Uh-huh. You're gonna be keeping an eye on this case? -Absolutely, we're gonna be there in the court everyday. -We're looking forward to that. -Sure. -Thank you, Josh. We will check in with you again. For Inside Scoop, I'm Sumi Das. Thanks for watching.

Up Next

Samsung Note 8 will try to win back burned Note 7 fans
jessica-1

Up Next

Samsung Note 8 will try to win back burned Note 7 fans

iPhone 7 breaks Apple's sales records
inside-scoop-cnet.jpg

iPhone 7 breaks Apple's sales records

Apple's all about the MacBook on October 27
ismacbookcnet.jpg

Apple's all about the MacBook on October 27

Apple set to focus on iPhone at September 7 event
isapple97.jpg

Apple set to focus on iPhone at September 7 event

What the Verizon-Yahoo deal means for users
yahooverizon.jpg

What the Verizon-Yahoo deal means for users

What to expect at Apple's WWDC 2016
16n0607insidescoopwwdc.jpg

What to expect at Apple's WWDC 2016

Inside Scoop: Tim Cook talks privacy at Apple's shareholder meeting
inside-scoop.jpg

Inside Scoop: Tim Cook talks privacy at Apple's shareholder meeting

Inside Scoop: What will be the hottest phone from Mobile World Congress?
insidescoop.jpg

Inside Scoop: What will be the hottest phone from Mobile World Congress?

Ripple Maker gives us a taste of our face
ces1681insidescooppart1still.jpg

Ripple Maker gives us a taste of our face

Tech Shows

The Apple Core
apple-core-w

The Apple Core

Alphabet City
alphabet-city-w

Alphabet City

CNET Top 5
cnet-top-5-w

CNET Top 5

The Daily Charge
dc-site-1color-logo.png

The Daily Charge

What the Future
what-the-future-w

What the Future

Tech Today
tech-today-w

Tech Today

Latest News All latest news

Baby Formula Shortage Explained: What You Can Do
formula-shortage-1

Baby Formula Shortage Explained: What You Can Do

Meta's Next VR Headset: Should You Get a Quest 2 or Wait?
meta-questsitethumb1

Meta's Next VR Headset: Should You Get a Quest 2 or Wait?

How to Buy a Budget Laptop in 2022
budgetlaptops-00-08-35-15-still001

How to Buy a Budget Laptop in 2022

Stopping Crop Extinction
crop-extinction-00-10-45-15-still001

Stopping Crop Extinction

How Will We Deal With a Mountain of Old EV Batteries?
ev-battery-recycling-00-06-10-03-still099

How Will We Deal With a Mountain of Old EV Batteries?

Elon Musk vs. Twitter Bots: How Big Is the Problem?
bots-spam-004

Elon Musk vs. Twitter Bots: How Big Is the Problem?

Most Popular All most popular

See the Navy Unveil New Video of UFOs/UAPs
uap-pic

See the Navy Unveil New Video of UFOs/UAPs

How to cut the cord: 7 questions you need to answer
7-allfinished.png

How to cut the cord: 7 questions you need to answer

Stopping Crop Extinction
crop-extinction-00-10-45-15-still001

Stopping Crop Extinction

The iPhone 14 Report
iphone14rumor-cnet

The iPhone 14 Report

Elon Musk vs. Twitter Bots: How Big Is the Problem?
bots-spam-004

Elon Musk vs. Twitter Bots: How Big Is the Problem?

Meta's Next VR Headset: Should You Get a Quest 2 or Wait?
meta-questsitethumb1

Meta's Next VR Headset: Should You Get a Quest 2 or Wait?

Latest Products All latest products

Moto G 5G Review: A $400 Phone That May Have Everything You Need
clip0001-00-00-25-15-still001

Moto G 5G Review: A $400 Phone That May Have Everything You Need

Hands-On: We Got to Try the Sony Xperia 1 IV and Its Zoom Lens
xperiafinalpicsite

Hands-On: We Got to Try the Sony Xperia 1 IV and Its Zoom Lens

Lenovo Legion 7 Gaming Laptops Combine Great Power With Simple, Slim Designs
lenovolegion-00-00-45-13-still003

Lenovo Legion 7 Gaming Laptops Combine Great Power With Simple, Slim Designs

Exploring Meta Store: Facebook Parent Meta's First Physical Retail Space
metastore

Exploring Meta Store: Facebook Parent Meta's First Physical Retail Space

Lenovo's Torrent of Slim-Series Laptops Has Almost Too Many Options
lenovoslim-00-00-03-10-still001.png

Lenovo's Torrent of Slim-Series Laptops Has Almost Too Many Options

Disney's New Wristband Brings Games to Theme Parks
magic-band-plus-1-copy

Disney's New Wristband Brings Games to Theme Parks

Latest How To All how to videos

How to Buy a Budget Laptop in 2022
budgetlaptops-00-08-35-15-still001

How to Buy a Budget Laptop in 2022

Google Pay: How to Set Up and Use
googlepay-inhand

Google Pay: How to Set Up and Use

Clean Your AirPods and EarPods Without Damaging Them
yt-howto-clean-airpods-v3

Clean Your AirPods and EarPods Without Damaging Them

How to Control Your Computer With Your Feet
yt-learn-guitar-foot-controls-v2

How to Control Your Computer With Your Feet

How to Download YouTube Videos
yt-howto-download-yt-videos-v3

How to Download YouTube Videos

Find Forgotten Wi-Fi Passwords for Previously Used Networks
how-to-find-a-wi-fi-password-on-any-network-1

Find Forgotten Wi-Fi Passwords for Previously Used Networks