BlackBerry pleads for patience after brutal quarter
One analyst describes BlackBerry's results as a "complete disaster" as the company disappointed on virtually every single financial metric.
- SABEW Best in Business 2011 Award for Breaking News Coverage, Eddie Award in 2020 for 5G coverage, runner-up National Arts & Entertainment Journalism Award for culture analysis.
BlackBerry's "solid ground" just got shakier.
The company on Friday posted a loss in its fiscal first quarter, whereas analysts had projected at profit. Compounding the negativity was the eventual disclosure that it only sold 2.7 million BlackBerry 10 devices in the quarter and saw its subscriber base fall by 4 million to 72 million.
It was a bad day for BlackBerry all around. The surprising and disappointing numbers underscore the continued challenges the company faces as it continues its slow efforts for a recovery. But with losses expected to continue piling up, some are wondering if a comeback is even possible. With a market dominated by Apple and Samsung, BlackBerry may be badly outgunned.
What's worse is that the situation doesn't look like it will be improving for a while. BlackBerry warned it will post another loss in the current quarter and said it will continue to invest in products and services over the next three quarters, suggesting that the company will remain in the red for another year. Throughout it all, BlackBerry CEO Thorsten Heins asked for more time and a longer-term view from analysts and industry observers who seemed short on patience.
"It is a complete disaster," Pierre Ferragu, an analyst at Sanford Bernstein, said in an e-mail to CNET.
Wall Street agreed with his assessment. BlackBerry lost more than a quarter of its market value, falling 25.5 percent to $10.69 in early trading this morning.
The sentiment is far different from just a month ago, when Heins declared during its annual developer conference that the company had gotten back some of its groove.
"It hasn't been that easy, and there's still a lot of work to do, but man, have we reached solid ground with this company," Heins said during his keynote address at BlackBerry Live in May. At the time, he was met with thunderous applause from the BlackBerry faithful.
Today, Heins endured a string of painful questions ranging from his thoughts on the disappointing BlackBerry 10 sales to how much time the board had given him before he had to ditch his current plans.
In his response, Heins sought patience from the investment community, saying that the company wasn't done launching products and noted that they each required significant marketing investment to stand out in a competitive market. He said fiscal 2014 (its current fiscal year) marks a period of investment, which will set the company up for growth next year.
"It's a new experience, so this takes a bit of time, it takes some investment," he said.
Heins, however, demurred on many of the more pointed questions, such as his thoughts on what many regard as disappointing unit sales.
"We're in the middle of it, so it's really too early to say," he said. "You've got to be on your tippy toe all the time, and that's what we're doing."
The 2.7 million BlackBerry 10 devices shipped in the quarter only represented 40 percent of total device sales, which means its older BlackBerry 7 devices still outsold its newer, more profitable product line. The company also didn't break out how well the
The numbers, which represent the first full quarter of sales of its BlackBerry 10 devices, have some wondering whether the company can keep up the momentum and excitement it managed to generate after the launch. The stock has been choppy in recent months, but remain markedly above the January levels as investors took a wait-and-see approach and erred on the optimistic side.
But increasingly, some are concerned that enthusiasm and interest for the devices have waned. BlackBerry opted to launch first with the BlackBerry Z10 to prove that it could compete in the full-touch-screen category. But in doing so, it may have hurt the momentum it could have better sustained had it gone out with the Q10, which is what most BlackBerry fans had been clamoring for.
"It appears now very unlikely traction will come," Ferragu said.
Perhaps as a reaction to the disappointment, Heins re-emphasized BlackBerry's goal of moving beyond just being a simple device maker, touting the BB10 platform's potential, as well as its services and data network business.
But if the company's core BlackBerry 10 smartphones start to falter, those ambitious plans could just end up being pipe dreams.