CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again

Which floodlights keep color tones true?

If you're on the hunt for new floodlights, then you'll want to consider LEDs, which offer high efficiency and long-term energy savings. But which ones are best for vivid, eye-popping color quality? Click through for a full comparison of five top contenders.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
1
of 32

Philips EcoVantage BR30 Halogen

We'll start out by looking at the kind of baseline bulb you might be looking to replace -- a halogen floodlight from Philips.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
2
of 32

Philips EcoVantage BR30 Halogen

Halogen lights are just incandescents with a little bit of non-toxic gas trapped with the filament for a slight boost in efficiency. As such, they offer color quality that's close to the high standard put out by incandescents.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
3
of 32

Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED

The Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED is a floodlight that glows orange as you dim it down, for an interesting sunset-like effect. At full brightness, though, it's a yellowish 2,700K.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
4
of 32

Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED

It might be a touch too yellow for some tastes. The colors don't look bad, and the white of the bowl looks about right, but compare the wood grain of the tabletop with slide 3. It's a pretty noticeable difference.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
5
of 32

Philips SlimStyle BR30 LED

Next up is another option from Philips -- the flat-headed SlimStyle BR30 LED. This low-cost light offers a radically different design that eliminates the need for heat sinks.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
6
of 32

Philips SlimStyle BR30 LED

As you can see, it does a pretty nice job with color quality, too. For the most part, everything looks "right," and the tabletop isn't quite as yellowed out as it was under the Philips WarmGlow.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
7
of 32

Cree BR30 LED

Cree's 60W Replacement LED is one of our favorite values in the lighting aisle, and the company's TW Series bulbs offer exceptional color quality. So how does the Cree BR30 LED floodlight stack up?

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
8
of 32

Cree BR30 LED

As you can see, things look a lot more yellowed out than we saw with the SlimStyle -- the color quality is arguably worse than with the WarmGlow LED, too. It isn't terrible, and we're definitely nitpicking, but the difference is certainly noticeable.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
9
of 32

GE BR30 LED

Next up is the standard BR30 LED from GE.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
10
of 32

GE BR30 LED

Looks almost identical to what we saw with Cree. Not bad, but a bit too yellow.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
11
of 32

GE Reveal BR30 LED

The GE Reveal BR30 LED promises a dramatic uptick in color quality, with a CRI score about 10 points higher than the other competitors we're looking at have.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
12
of 32

GE Reveal BR30 LED

In our studio, that translated to pretty terrific color quality.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
13
of 32

Philips EcoVantage BR30 Halogen

Let's take a closer look at that candy. Here's the halogen baseline bulb, with fairly well-rounded color quality.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
14
of 32

Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED

And here's the Philips WarmGlow. Things look good, but tinted a bit orange.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
15
of 32

Philips SlimStyle BR30 LED

The SlimStyle shows some orangeness, too, along with a more focused beam of light that makes the bowl look a bit brighter.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
16
of 32

Cree BR30 LED

The Cree's floodlight washes things out in yellow light.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
17
of 32

GE BR30 LED

GE's standard LED again looks pretty close to the Cree, but up close, I'd say it's a touch better. The white of the bowl is the giveaway.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
18
of 32

GE Reveal BR30 LED

Finally, here's the GE Reveal. Again, among these five LEDs, it looks like the clear winner to me.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
19
of 32

Philips EcoVantage BR30 Halogen

Time for our citrus test, which left me craving a margarita. Here's the Philips EcoVantage halogen floodlight. With an even color rendering score, everything looks just about right. Keep an eye on that orange on the left, though.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
20
of 32

Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED

With the Philips WarmGlow LED, that orange looks a little bit lemony. That's because LEDs have a notoriously difficult time rendering red tones. Result, yellower oranges.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
21
of 32

Philips SlimStyle BR30 LED

The SlimStyle yellows things out, too, though I'd say it's a touch better than the WarmGlow.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
22
of 32

Cree BR30 LED

The Cree wasn't too bad in this test, either, which was a little surprising.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
23
of 32

GE BR30 LED

The GE LED, on the other hand, took a step backward.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
24
of 32

GE Reveal BR30 LED

The GE Reveal, however, nailed this test. The oranges look orange, the blue knife looks perfectly blue, the white cutting board looks white, and the skin tone on my hand looks more accurate than in the other shots.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
25
of 32

Philips EcoVantage BR30 Halogen

Our last test is another fruit challenge -- a bowl of berries. Here's how the halogen floodlight did.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
26
of 32

Philips WarmGlow BR30 LED

Here's the Philips WarmGlow LED...

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
27
of 32

Philips SlimStyle BR30 LED

...here's the Philips SlimStyle...

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
28
of 32

Cree BR30 LED

...the Cree BR30...

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
29
of 32

GE BR30 LED

...the standard GE BR30 LED...

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
30
of 32

GE Reveal BR30 LED

...and finally, the GE Reveal. Again, I'd say that it did the best job, making it a clear winner in our overall color quality tests.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
31
of 32

Review your options

Of course, there's a lot more than color quality to consider when upgrading your lighting. Be sure to check out our reviews and our light bulb buying guide to help inform your buying decision.

Published:Caption:Photo:Colin West McDonald/CNET
32
of 32
Up Next

Top 10 Black Friday smart home deals: Our favorite bargains of 2018