Roma's 'invisible effects' are a sight to behold

That's right, Alfonso Cuaron's art house masterpiece is a treasure chest of CGI.

Jennifer Bisset
Jennifer Bisset
Jennifer Bisset
1 of 9 Photo by Carlos Somonte

Not so invisible now

A foreign language, black-and-white film is probably not the first thing that springs to mind when it comes to visual effects. But Alfonso Cuaron's Oscar-winning Roma is filled with them, from digital set extensions and environments to CG animals and human performances.

To help us lock onto those incredibly well-hidden effects -- there's a reason they're called "invisible" -- one of Roma's VFX supervisors, Aaron Weintraub, took us through how his team at visual effects company Mr. X augmented several scenes.

Mr. X also released a handy YouTube video breaking down those scenes, which you can watch here.

2 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Exterior cinema

"We replaced the entire façade and marquee of the cinema," Weintraub said via email. "Special attention was paid to the quality and texture of the stucco, and the painted quality of the signage."

3 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Interior cinema

"The original photography used multiple LED panels on the stage that projected the interactive light from the film onto the audience, so that their lighting would react with the changes in the light bouncing off the film screen," Weintraub said.

"Mr. X replaced the entire stage with a full-sized screen, added CG curtains that closed at the end of the film that warbled the image as it projected over them, and added atmosphere to illuminate the projection beam in the air and bounce light back into the environment. Special care was taken to preserve all the cigarette smoke and atmosphere from the original photography at it floated over top of the screen and through the beam."

4 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Driving to the hospital

"The backgrounds in these shots were completely replaced with street extensions, CG buildings, CG cars and trams, additional pedestrians, trolley tracks and wires, and all manner of period set dressing, TV antennas, water heaters, pipes, etc," Weintraub said.

5 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube


"This was shot at the actual location represented in the film, but over the years, the hospital building had undergone a complete facelift and now required restoration to its 1970's glory," Weintraub said. "Mr. X replaced the building based on reference photographs of the original location and extended additional architecture into the deep background."

6 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Taxidermied dogs

"The original photography had some great stuffed dog sculptures.  They helped establish the tone of the set and definitely set the scenes up for some of the best comedic moments in the film," Weintraub said. "Once photographed, however, Alfonso felt they were lacking some realism and that they didn't feel like actual dead dogs, so we replaced and augmented them with real dog elements."

7 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

New Year’s forest fire

"Mr. X added a burning falling CG tree, embers, additional ground fires and burning trees, cleaned up practical propane flame bars, and added fires wherever the kids were pouring water," Weintraub said.

8 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Chasing the lizard

"Not wanting to spend time to train an actual lizard to run and stop on cue, the plate was photographed with an actual lizard in the end position, waiting to be scooped up by the approaching hand," Weintraub said.

"Up until that point, the lizard was completely CG, modeled after the one in the shot and using additional reference photography to create the asset. The horned lizard was rigged and hand-animated to arrive into the position matching the original one, which was painted out of the plate and replaced to create a seamless pick-up event. It was integrated with lighting and shadows rolling over the rocky terrain to perfectly match the scene."

9 of 9 Mr. X via YouTube

Crossing the street

"One of the biggest shots in the film, the practical first-storey portion of the set was completely constructed from scratch on an empty lot," Weintraub said. "Concrete was poured and streetcar tracks were laid in so that they could bring in a practical trolley car, though because a historically accurate streetcar wasn't available, they painted a modern streetcar completely blue and ran that through the shot so that the actors and drivers had something physical to block their action.

"Mr. X digitally removed it and replaced it with a digital replica created using old photographs as reference. There was a bluescreen at the back of the set which allowed us to retain some of the foreground action without having to completely rotoscope the shot, but for anything that extended higher than the screen, roto was the only option. The street was digitally extended and populated with all manner of traffic, lamps, buildings, flashing signs, billboards, storefronts -- basically anything that filled up the frame and brought it to life in the way that Alfonso remembered it. The wet foreground concrete also had to be completely replaced, so that the puddles reflected all the digital additions to the architecture and traffic."

More Galleries

Go Inside the Apple iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Pro: See How the New iPhones Look and Work
iphone 15 in different color from an angled view

Go Inside the Apple iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Pro: See How the New iPhones Look and Work

21 Photos
17 Hidden iOS 17 Features and Settings on Your iPhone
Invitation for the Apple September iPhone 15 event

17 Hidden iOS 17 Features and Settings on Your iPhone

18 Photos
Astronomy Photographer of the Year Winners Reveal Our Stunning Universe

Astronomy Photographer of the Year Winners Reveal Our Stunning Universe

16 Photos
Check Out the iPhone 15's New Camera in Action
A photo of a silhouette of buildings on the water taken on the iPhone 15

Check Out the iPhone 15's New Camera in Action

12 Photos
I Got an Early Look at Intel's Glass Packaging Tech for Faster Chips
Rahul Manepalli, right, Intel's module engineering leader, shows a glass substrate panel before it's sliced into the small rectangles that will be bonded to the undersides of hundreds of test processors. The technology, shown here at Intel's CH8 facility in Chandler, Arizona, stands to improve performance and power consumption of advanced processors arriving later this decade. Glass substrates should permit physically larger processors comprised of several small "chiplets" for AI and data center work, but Intel expects they'll trickle down to PCs, too.

I Got an Early Look at Intel's Glass Packaging Tech for Faster Chips

20 Photos
Yamaha motorcycle and instrument designers trade jobs (pictures)

Yamaha motorcycle and instrument designers trade jobs (pictures)

16 Photos
CNET's 'Day of the Dead Devices' altar (pictures)

CNET's 'Day of the Dead Devices' altar (pictures)

9 Photos