X

Highlights from Viacom vs. Google court docs (images)

Both companies on Thursday made hundreds of pages of court documents public in their copyright dispute over YouTube. We've excerpted some of the most interesting tidbits.

Declan_McCullagh2.jpg
Declan_McCullagh2.jpg
Declan McCullagh
1.jpg
1 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Viacom: Alleged early copyright infringements

Viacom and Google on Thursday made hundreds of pages of court documents public in their copyright dispute over YouTube. We've excerpted some of the most interesting tidbits.

This is a snippet from an 86-page document made public Thursday that Viacom claims represents facts that Google does not dispute. A federal judge eventually will decide which are true and relevant to the copyright lawsuit.

On this page, Viacom is hoping to demonstrate that in the early days of YouTube--before it was bought by Google--the company's founders allowed copyright infringements. These e-mail excerpts come from the first half of 2005, a few months after YouTube was founded.

2.jpg
2 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Viacom: More alleged infringement

These excerpts are from what Viacom claims are undisputed facts, representing the company's effort to show that YouTube's founders allowed users to infringe others' copyrights.

3.jpg
3 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Viacom: Short video clips

Here's another excerpt showing what Viacom claims are undisputed facts.

4.jpg
4 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Google: Secretly uploading videos

Google also filed a series of briefs on Thursday, which say that Viacom complained about copyright infringements while secretly uploading videos, using fake e-mail addresses, and sending employees to Kinko's to upload clips from computers that couldn't be traced to Viacom.

5.jpg
5 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Google: Permission given

Google says that Viacom included a list of allegedly infringing video clips in the current lawsuit for which -- whoops! -- Viacom actually had given permission to be uploaded.

6.jpg
6 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Viacom: Google e-mails on YouTube

Excerpts from Google e-mail messages in early 2006 appear in a Viacom brief made public on Thursday. Google bought YouTube for $1.7 billion in stock in October 2006.

7.jpg
7 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Brin questions what's Googley

In a conversation recounted in an excerpted e-mail message, Google co-founder Sergey Brin wondered whether allowing copyright infringements was "Googley?"

8.jpg
8 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Google brief

An excerpt from Google's brief filed Thursday. The lawsuit began in March 2007 and seeks over $1 billion in damages

9.jpg
9 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Another Google exerpt

Another excerpt from a document that Google filed Thursday.

10.jpg
10 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Aware of infringement

E-mail messages and instant messaging logs--did neither Google nor YouTube have a routine document destruction policy?--show that YouTube managers knew that copyright infringement was happening, Viacom claims.

11.jpg
11 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

YouTube purchase

CNET reported in November 2006 that in the YouTube purchase, "12.5 percent of the equity issued and issuable in the transaction will be subject to escrow for one year to secure certain indemnification obligations." The Viacom lawsuit was filed five months later.

12.jpg
12 of 12 Screenshot by Declan McCullagh/CNET

Google: YouTube used to promote content

"Plaintiffs' widespread use of YouTube to market and promote their content--uses that continued even in the midst of this litigation--defeats any notion that the presence of their material on YouTube creates a fact or circumstance from which infringing activity is apparent," a Google brief made public Thursday says.

Disclosure: The author of the captions is married to a Google employee who is not involved with YouTube.

More Galleries

Go Inside the Apple iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Pro: See How the New iPhones Look and Work
iphone 15 in different color from an angled view

Go Inside the Apple iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Pro: See How the New iPhones Look and Work

21 Photos
17 Hidden iOS 17 Features and Settings on Your iPhone
Invitation for the Apple September iPhone 15 event

17 Hidden iOS 17 Features and Settings on Your iPhone

18 Photos
Astronomy Photographer of the Year Winners Reveal Our Stunning Universe
andromeda

Astronomy Photographer of the Year Winners Reveal Our Stunning Universe

16 Photos
I Got an Early Look at Intel's Glass Packaging Tech for Faster Chips
Rahul Manepalli, right, Intel's module engineering leader, shows a glass substrate panel before it's sliced into the small rectangles that will be bonded to the undersides of hundreds of test processors. The technology, shown here at Intel's CH8 facility in Chandler, Arizona, stands to improve performance and power consumption of advanced processors arriving later this decade. Glass substrates should permit physically larger processors comprised of several small "chiplets" for AI and data center work, but Intel expects they'll trickle down to PCs, too.

I Got an Early Look at Intel's Glass Packaging Tech for Faster Chips

20 Photos
Check Out the iPhone 15's New Camera in Action
A photo of a silhouette of buildings on the water taken on the iPhone 15

Check Out the iPhone 15's New Camera in Action

12 Photos
Yamaha motorcycle and instrument designers trade jobs (pictures)
yamaha01.jpg

Yamaha motorcycle and instrument designers trade jobs (pictures)

16 Photos
CNET's 'Day of the Dead Devices' altar (pictures)
dia-de-los-muertos-3318-001.jpg

CNET's 'Day of the Dead Devices' altar (pictures)

9 Photos