/> ED I T O R S C H O I C E IN N O V A T IO N A W A R D
X

CNET's New York TV test lab revealed (photos)

Take a photo tour of CNET's Manhattan TV testing lab with your hosts, David Katzmaier and Ty Pendlebury.

David_Katzmaier.jpg
Ty_Pendlebury.jpg
David Katzmaier, Ty Pendlebury
CNET_TV_LAB_09.jpg
1 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Welcome to the lab!

Oh, hello, we didn't see you there.

Welcome to the lab, where your friendly, experienced, and above all hard-working CNET reviewers, David Katzmaier (left) and Ty Pendlebury, test televisions. If you think our hard work involves mainly just sitting around on incredibly comfortable brown leather couches watching TV all day, you're only half right. We have plenty of comfy chairs, too.

(These captions were updated in February 2013, as was our How We Test TVs article.)

CNET_TV_LAB_01.jpg
2 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Let's get to 'work'

In addition to lots of sitting, a typical day in the lab also involves hefting big-screen televisions (thank you, thin LED!), plugging in cables, calibrating, shooting video, and, oh yeah, writing.

Luckily, both Ty and David can move at superspeed when needed (pictured).

CNET_TV_LAB_08.jpg
3 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

The lineup

To the left you see David seated in the sweet spot at the nexus of "the lineup." At CNET we compare every TV we review directly with other competing models side-by-side, and in our reviews, explicitly call out the differences we see. If this was a real lineup, the TVs pictured would be better matches for one another and their placement equalized for height and seating distance.

Meanwhile, Ty occupies a second testing area that we're building out this year to allow another lineup.

CNET_TV_LAB_21.jpg
4 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Behind the curtain

Curtains can divide the room neatly in half to create those two independent, light-controlled testing areas.
CNET_TV_LAB_11.jpg
5 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Going dark

Most of our TV tests are done in a completely darkened environment, achieved by blackout shades drawn down over the windows. For testing purposes, David likes color bars, whereas Ty prefers wildlife that reminds him of home.
CNET_TV_LAB_14.jpg
6 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Couch potato

If this were a real test, the PC would be controlling the signal generator to fill the screen of the TV being calibrated with a white, gray, or occasionally colored rectangle. All of the other TVs would be turned off, with the lights out and curtains drawn, to assure the accuracy of the measurements and to allow David to nap.
CNET_TV_LAB_29.jpg
7 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

The calibration setup

Did we mention calibration?

At CNET we calibrate every TV we review to both establish a level playing field for comparison and to enable us to publish our popular picture settings. They enable users to easily set up their own TVs' picture controls to replicate as closely as possible the picture we see in the lab.

Last year CNET transitioned to using CalMan software by Spectrcal to both help calibrate the TV and to generate reports that capture many of the TVs' characteristics. In 2013 we have begin using version 5 of the software. We publish those reports with every TV review.

In 2012 we will began using a new signal generator, the VideoForge by AVFoundry (left, above the mouse) to generate the test patterns for our calibrations. In 2013 we switched to using the Quantum Data 780 (not pictured) as our primary generator.

CNET_TV_LAB_28.jpg
8 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Spectroradiometer

A "Spek-tra-ray-dee-ah-meter" measures the color and luminance of light six ways from Sunday. This particular model is the Konica Minolta CS-2000, the most expensive device in our lab (about $30,000) and capable of accurately measuring the color and brightness of "black" down to 0.003 cd/m2--darker than many TVs can display. OLED's "absolute" black might kick its butt, however.
CNET_TV_LAB_26.jpg
9 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

KM at work

The spectroradiometer connects via USB to the PC and feeds its data directly into the CalMan software.
CNET_TV_LAB_18.jpg
10 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

The human eye

In addition to sophisticated inorganic measuring equipment, CNET's reviews make heavy use of the most accurate instrument on the planet: our eyes. Here, Ty notes the characteristics of a hockey game on a 60-inch Sharp Elite--notoriously difficult material on a notoriously expensive and excellent television.
CNET_TV_LAB_36.jpg
11 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Reference Elites

CNET's comparisons usually include a "reference" TV in the lineup against which all of the others are measured. On the left there's the 2008 50-inch Pioneer Elite Kuro, and on the right the 2011 Sharp Elite, the best TV of last year. Both will be kept for different reference situations this year, along with a Panasonic TC-P65VT50 and a Panasonic TC-P55ST50--our favorite high-end and mid-tier (respectively) TVs from 2012.
CNET_TV_LAB_22.jpg
12 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

HDMI distribution

To compare between TVs, we use a distribution amplifier and switch combination, both from Key Digital. This setup allows us to feed four different sources to as many as eight displays without any signal degradation. We use primarily Monoprice cables and have for years to help demonstrate that all HDMI cables are the same.
CNET_TV_LAB_25.jpg
13 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Rat's nest

Every self-respecting AV setup hides a warren of cabling, and our lab is no different.
CNET_TV_LAB_33.jpg
14 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

The stacks

Testing TVs isn't all lineups of TVs. Our shelves are literally bulging with accessories, sources, cables, media, and more. Can anybody spot the DirecTiVo straddling the D-VHS deck? What about the first-gen HD DVD player? Good times.
CNET_TV_LAB_32.jpg
15 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Cable bins

Plenty of cables are available for different hookups. We also keep old remotes, manuals, and other gear just in case they come back into style.
CNET_TV_LAB_30.jpg
16 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Blu-ray library

We have hundreds of Blu-ray discs on-hand, and we're taking volunteers to organize them all by tier.
CNET_TV_LAB_46.jpg
17 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Long-term testing

Last year we took over a couple of shelves from CNET's PC test lab for the seven plasma TVs we're running 24/6 as part of a long-term plasma test. The Illuminati has taken an interest in the results. As a result we have decided to scuttle long-term testing in 2013.
CNET_TV_LAB_41.jpg
18 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

Inventory...

We currently have 25 TVs we're keeping for comparison purposes or long-term testing, a few queued for return to the manufacturer, and a few more we bought and plan to give away to readers. Stay tuned for more on that.
CNET_TV_LAB_37.jpg
19 of 19 Sarah Tew/CNET

...managed.

Just to reiterate, we work hard in the CNET TV labs and rarely have fun, because we're working too hard. We've got our work cut out this year, so we'll see you on the Internet.

--Ty and Dave, signing off.

More Galleries

The best games on Nintendo Switch

More Galleries

The best games on Nintendo Switch

41 Photos
Global 2022 Ford Ranger gets stronger styling, more infotainment tech

More Galleries

Global 2022 Ford Ranger gets stronger styling, more infotainment tech

7 Photos
The new Kia Niro crossover has a lot more style

More Galleries

The new Kia Niro crossover has a lot more style

8 Photos
Movies coming in 2021 and 2022 from Netflix, Marvel, HBO and more

More Galleries

Movies coming in 2021 and 2022 from Netflix, Marvel, HBO and more

67 Photos
2021 best new TV shows to watch, stream, obsess about

More Galleries

2021 best new TV shows to watch, stream, obsess about

65 Photos
The 2022 Kia Stinger 2.5T is a lovely liftback

More Galleries

The 2022 Kia Stinger 2.5T is a lovely liftback

40 Photos
The 51 best VR games

More Galleries

The 51 best VR games

53 Photos