X

Cameras compared: iPhone 4S vs. iPhone 4 (photos)

You've heard that the iPhone 4S offers a better camera than the iPhone 4's. In a series of photos, CNET shows you just how much better it is.

Kent_German.jpg
Kent_German.jpg

Kent German

See full bio

iPhone_4S_flowers.jpg
1 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Outside the CNET office: iPhone 4S

Though it doesn't have the hype of Siri, the iPhone 4S' camera is one of its best features. Now with a resolution of 8 megapixels, the iPhone 4's shooter offers huge improvements over the iPhone 4's. It has an f/2.4 aperture lens, a sensor that allows 73 percent more light than the iPhone 4 camera, a hybrid IR filter for better color accuracy, and improved auto white balance.


I know that's a lot of techno-babble, so to show just how the iPhone 4S is different, I shot a series of 10 photos using both phones. I then showed the photos to Lori Grunin, CNET's senior editor for digital imaging. She was quick to reply that the iPhone 4S is vastly superior to the iPhone 4 in several ways. White balance is much better and the memory colors (greens and blues) are far more accurate. She also said that the tonal range for the 4S is more open, which gives the images a lower contrast and shows more detail. That's the brief scoop, but I added more observations throughout the photo gallery.

Here you can see that colors in the iPhone 4S image are very sharp. There's also great detail and little image noise.


iPhone_4_flowers.jpg
2 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Outside the CNET office: iPhone 4

The iPhone 4 photo is good as well, but there's less color range and background objects are slightly blurry.
iPhone_4S_building_.jpg
3 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Hayes Valley corner: iPhone 4S

I shot this photo in the shade during the late morning on a bright, sunny day.
iPhone_4_building.jpg
4 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Hayes Valley corner: iPhone 4

The iPhone 4 also captures enough light, but the reds in the banner and the stoplight are faded and there's less detail in the clouds.
iPhone_4S_alley_1.jpg
5 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Linden Alley: iPhone 4S

As in the previous two photos, you really see the difference in how the phones capture clouds and the bright sky.
iPhone_4_alley_1.jpg
6 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Linden Alley: iPhone 4

With the iPhone 4, the sky isn't as blue and the cloudy areas are blown-out.
iPhone_4S_night.jpg
7 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Downtown at night: iPhone 4S

Lori said that these night shots are a mix. The 4S looks like it's using a slower shutter speed, so there's more shake than from the 4, but the color and exposure are better. Note that the individual light points are pretty distinct and that even the tall building in the background is adequately lit. On the downside, the whole image has a grayish tint.
iPhone_4_night.jpg
8 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Downtown at night: iPhone 4

The image shows how less successful the iPhone 4 is at capturing light. The light points are fuzzy and they have a yellowish and less-natural color. The tall building is too dark and the street signs are unreadable even though I didn't use a flash. Lori also added that the cameras may be metering slightly differently.
iPhone_4S_food.jpg
9 of 20 Kent German/CNET

My dinner: iPhone 4S

This was my heirloom-tomato-and-melon salad in a brightly lit restaurant with no flash. It tasted as good as it looks.
iPhone_4_food.jpg
10 of 20 Kent German/CNET

My dinner: iPhone 4

The iPhone 4's less detail in the tonal range is visible here. For example, the plate wasn't so blinding white.
iPhone_4S_flash.jpg
11 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Dim room with flash: iPhone 4S

Even with the iPhone 4's improved sensor, the iPhone 4S' flash can be too overpowering.
iPhone_4_flash.jpg
12 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Dim room with flash: iPhone 4

The iPhone 4's flash is bright as well, but there's less color accuracy.
iPhone_4S_statue_2.jpg
13 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Statue on the Green: iPhone 4S

In these images you can see again that the iPhone 4S is better at capturing smaller details like the clouds and the intricacies in the statue.
iPhone_4_statue_3.jpg
14 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Statue on the Green: iPhone 4

The iPhone 4 hardly does a bad job, but the image is darker and the building looks more green than white.
iPhone_4S_with_zoom.jpg
15 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Using the zoom: iPhone 4S

I shot these photos with the zoom about halfway in. Lori said it shows how the iPhone 4S is simply choosing a slightly brighter exposure in some cases. But even the iPhone 4S can't correct the increased image noise from using a digital zoom.
iPhone_4_zoom.jpg
16 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Using the zoom: iPhone 4

On the iPhone 4, the pixels are more visible. By the way, if you live in San Francisco, eat this pizza.
iPhone_4S_produce.jpg
17 of 20 Kent German/CNET

At the market: iPhone 4S

I did not use the flash here either. Lori pointed out this photo as the best example of how the 4S has better accuracy and exposure and is better at handling the saturated colors.
iPhone_4_produce.jpg
18 of 20 Kent German/CNET

At the market: iPhone 4

With the iPhone 4 the letters on the signs aren't as readable, and the colors, especially on the peaches and apples, look like they should be in a cartoon.
iPhone_4S_SS1.jpg
19 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Studio shot: iPhone 4S

In our standard studio shot, the colors on the iPhone 4S photo are far more accurate.
Apple_iPhone_4_SS1.jpg
20 of 20 Kent German/CNET

Studio shot: iPhone 4

With the iPhone 4, however, the wall has a sickly yellow color. Admittedly, the fuzzball on the extreme left is different.

More Galleries

2022's Best TV Shows You Can't Miss on Netflix, HBO, Disney Plus and More

More Galleries

2022's Best TV Shows You Can't Miss on Netflix, HBO, Disney Plus and More

93 Photos
The 40 Best Games on Nintendo Switch

More Galleries

The 40 Best Games on Nintendo Switch

41 Photos
Rolls-Royce's Second Boat Tail Is Brown and Beautiful

More Galleries

Rolls-Royce's Second Boat Tail Is Brown and Beautiful

62 Photos
2023 Toyota Camry Nightshade is a Bronzeworthy Family Sedan

More Galleries

2023 Toyota Camry Nightshade is a Bronzeworthy Family Sedan

13 Photos
2023 Genesis GV60 Is a Futuristic EV

More Galleries

2023 Genesis GV60 Is a Futuristic EV

53 Photos
Movies Coming in 2022 From Marvel, Netflix, DC and More

More Galleries

Movies Coming in 2022 From Marvel, Netflix, DC and More

80 Photos
'Stranger Things' Stars Now and Then: Wow, They've Really Grown Up

More Galleries

'Stranger Things' Stars Now and Then: Wow, They've Really Grown Up

40 Photos