PS5 and Xbox Series X are cool, but show me the games
Commentary: We're in the middle of the coronavirus pandemic. Can you just show us the games please?
Ian SherrContributor and Former Editor at Large / News
Ian Sherr (he/him/his) grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area, so he's always had a connection to the tech world. As an editor at large at CNET, he wrote about Apple, Microsoft, VR, video games and internet troubles. Aside from writing, he tinkers with tech at home, is a longtime fencer -- the kind with swords -- and began woodworking during the pandemic.
Schools around the world are shut down, as are many shops in large cities. The San Francisco Bay Area is on lockdown. Parks across the country are closed. Millions of people are stuck at home, anxious about the coronavirus pandemic, hungry for a proper distraction from grim reality.
So why are
spending so much time talking about the intricate specs of their upcoming PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X instead of showing us some exciting new games?
More than 650,000 people tuned into YouTube Wednesday to watch Sony's "The Road to PS5" presentation by Sony designer Mark Cerny. In it, he went deep into the minutiae of the specs for the company's upcoming PlayStation, which like the Xbox, is coming this fall.
He discussed things like "command buffers," "system memory," "CUs," "compression" and other terms unlikely to register with anyone other than the most hardcore fans. Instead, most people will only care about what Sony and Microsoft will likely say on the box: The new devices offer roughly twice the power of their predecessors.
"There will be lots of chances later on this year to look at the PlayStation 5 games," Cerny said when starting his presentation, suggesting he realized his audience may have been expecting more. "Today, I want to talk a bit about our goals for the PlayStation 5 hardware."
Sure, the talk had been planned for the Game Developers Conference, originally scheduled for this week until it was postponed amid fears of the coronavirus. So it's no surprise Cerny's talk would be in the weeds.
If we weren't in the middle of a pandemic, Cerny's presentation would have been perfectly appropriate and even expected. But instead, it came off as a miss considering that, in addition to developers, many gamers whose schools have closed are stuck working from home or are unable to work at all and were tuning in to find something to get excited about.
Many commenters watching along began complaining they were bored, typing "Zzzzzzzz," as Cerny talked through almost 20 sections of his presentation discussing storage technology and how files will be organized on the PS5's SSD (that's solid-state drive, for the uninitiated, which is where game files are often stored).
We've been hearing about Sony's PlayStation 5 and Microsoft's Xbox Series X for over a year now, but we've barely heard about any of the games. It's time for that to change.
With people stuck inside as governments battle the novel coronavirus spreading around the world, it's on entertainment companies like Sony and Microsoft to step up their game. And the easiest way to do that would be to stop talking about what these devices are, and instead to show off what they can do.
On top of that, Sony's and Microsoft's new consoles are coming at a time when players can access their games from a wide variety of places, not just the large plastic and metal PlayStation and Xbox devices they typically plug into their
are increasingly more powerful, attracting popular games like Fortnite, a free-to-download shooter that's become a cultural phenomenon.
All that means Sony and Microsoft have to work that much harder to convince people their devices will be worth buying. And in the end, that means they need to show off compelling games we can play. And only on those devices.
The last time Sony and Microsoft launched new game consoles, the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One both in 2013, they trotted out a small lineup of games to go with them. Among them were the so-so-rated fighting game Killer Instinct and shooting game Killzone: Shadow Fall.
There was also the even worse-received action title Ryse: Son of Rome, which was praised for its stunning visuals, but criticized for pretty much everything else. "Ryse is all sizzle and no steak, a stunning visage paired with a vapid personality," GameSpot's Mark Walton said in his 2013 review of the game.
This time, the companies are unlikely to repeat that kind of disappointment. Both Sony and Microsoft have promised their libraries of games made in the past eight years, and even some older ones, will work on the new devices out of the box.
But that doesn't mean Sony and Microsoft should hold back. In this unprecedented time, when we're all under quarantine or warned to stay away from each other for fear of spreading a nasty virus, it would be nice for the game companies to offer us a little more steak than sizzle.