Elon Musk says SEC oversight is 'broken' in wake of Tesla numbers tweet

The Tesla boss isn't happy with the agency's urge to see him held in contempt, and he's got until March 11 to explain himself.

Sean Keane Former Senior Writer
Sean knows far too much about Marvel, DC and Star Wars, and poured this knowledge into recaps and explainers on CNET. He also worked on breaking news, with a passion for tech, video game and culture.
Expertise Culture | Video Games | Breaking News
Sean Keane
2 min read
Mayor Rahm Emanuel Makes Announcement On Express Train Service To O'Hare Airport

Elon Musk isn't happy with the SEC.

Joshua Lott / Getty Images

Tesla  CEO  Elon Musk  used Twitter to push back against the Securities and Exchange Commission on Tuesday, a day after the agency chastised him for sharing company information on the social media platform.

On Monday, the SEC moved to have Musk held in contempt after he tweeted about Tesla's likely production volume in 2019, saying he'd violated the terms of an agreement. The agency had forbidden him from using Twitter or other social media to pass along information that could be considered material to investors or Tesla without prior approval.

The SEC's call for action prompted a selloff in Tesla shares, which sank as much as 4.6 percent in after-hours trading Monday. The stock downturn prompted a Twitter commenter to suggest that the SEC's filing moved markets, not Musk's tweets.

 "Exactly. This has now happened several times," Musk wrote, wrote on Twitter. "Something is broken with SEC oversight."

He responded with another "Exactly" when someone else noted that the information Musk tweeted had already been revealed in the company's fourth-quarter earnings call and a shareholder letter.

Musk has a Twitter minder, an experienced securities lawyer at Tesla who is tasked with vetting his communications. The minder is known as the Designated Securities Counsel, a position that was created after earlier SEC actions against the company and Musk.

Later Tuesday, US District Judge Alison Nathan ordered Musk to explain by March 11 why he shouldn't be held in contempt, Reuters reported.

Wall Street analysts weighed in on the clash Tuesday, offering both hope and hesitation for investors.

Maynard Um at Macquarie Capital pointed out that the SEC is likely looking for decisive action by Tesla's board. Even so, he wrote, the firm doesn't see a "material risk of a change to Mr. Musk's role at Tesla."

But that doesn't mean all's well.

"This new legal headache for both Elon Musk and Tesla," wrote Jeffrey Osborne at Cowen Equity Research, amounts to "a negative distraction for a company that needs to execute at this critical juncture." Cowen continues to see "major risks" given the company's valuation, cash needs and other factors.

Tesla shares on Tuesday closed down less than 1 percent, to $297.86.

The SEC, Tesla and Musk didn't respond to requests for comment.

Watch this: Sliding around in Teslas at the company's Alaska proving ground

Originally published Feb. 26 at 9:53 a.m. PT
Update Feb. 27 at 4:04 a.m.: Adds March 11 deadline for Musk to explain.