Driver tech like Tesla's Autopilot needs real regulation, says IIHS

Partially automated driving technology still requires the driver's full attention -- the IIHS says automakers aren't doing enough to make that clear.

Sean Szymkowski
It all started with Gran Turismo. From those early PlayStation days, Sean was drawn to anything with four wheels. Prior to joining the Roadshow team, he was a freelance contributor for Motor Authority, The Car Connection and Green Car Reports. As for what's in the garage, Sean owns a 2016 Chevrolet SS, and yes, it has Holden badges.
Sean Szymkowski
2 min read
Tesla Model 3 Autopilot
Enlarge Image
Tesla Model 3 Autopilot

The IIHS says automakers need to make sure these systems are safe in all scenarios.


Today, there are no self-driving cars on sale. Tomorrow, there will be no self-driving cars on sale. Next year, barring some mesmerizing breakthrough, there will be no self-driving cars on sale.

With that out of the way, what we see incorporated in some vehicles today are partially automated systems that still require the driver's full attention at all times. However, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety believes automakers aren't doing enough to make sure drivers understand this.

The IIHS on Thursday issued guidelines it hopes automakers, and the government, will strive for when it comes to partially automated technology. These systems rank at Level 2 on the SAE scale of autonomy and include Tesla's Autopilot, ' Super Cruise and ProPilot Assist. Level 5 is full autonomy, for reference.

In fact, the IIHS doesn't even think some features ought to be included in some Level 2 systems at all, such as automatic lane changes. Instead, the insurance industry-funded safety group thinks these systems should always keep the driver engaged.

Super Cruising in the 2018 Cadillac CT6 Platinum

See all photos

To resolve this, the IIHS believes automakers should install multiple guardrails. got partial high marks for including a camera system with its Super Cruise system that watches drivers to make sure they're paying attention, and a guardrail to keep Super Cruise active only on mapped, divided highways, but it offers no other functions to keep drivers alert. Drivers can literally leave their hands off the wheel with Super Cruise engaged.

As soon as the system detects the driver's attention has wandered, the IIHS wants to see a series of alerts fire off. First, a visual reminder; then, a more prominent visual reminder plus an audible or physical alert, such as a seat vibration. Drivers should get two more chances, per the guidelines, with all three alerts blaring and finally all three plus pulsed braking.

If the driver doesn't respond, the IIHS called on automakers to kill the system, bring the car to a slow stop and turn on the hazard lights. The partially automated tech should then be locked for the remainder of the drive, the IIHS suggested.

These are only guidelines, but the IIHS believes it's the best way to ensure drivers avoid crashes involving the systems and overreliance on them. As more automakers put this type of tech in their cars, these suggestions may well become real regulations.

Watch this: Super Cruising with the 2018 Cadillac CT6's autonomous tech

First published March 12.