Sony VPL-VW50 review: Sony VPL-VW50
Although the Sony VPL-VW50's picture quality falls short in a number of areas, it's easily one of the best values in 1080p front projection.
Editors' note, April 16, 2008 The rating on this review has been lowered from 7.5 to 7.2 due to changes in the competitive marketplace.
Sony shook up the high-end front projection market last September when it introduced the VPL-VW50 SXRD front projector at a list price of $5,000. The unit, dubbed the "Pearl," is still among the least expensive 1080p front projectors available. It does some things really well, although it falls short in a couple of important areas of performance. Nonetheless, given its price point and image quality, it's hard to argue against the Pearl's status as one of the best values among 1080p front-projectors.
As far as external appearance goes, Sony's VPL-VW50 is certainly one of the most attractive front projectors I've seen yet. It combines elegance and high-tech into a sleek look with smooth, rounded lines that was downright sexy. All of the connectivity is located on one side of the projector, cleverly hidden under the curve of the top of the chassis. The projector measures 15.6x6.9x18.6 inches (WHD) and weighs just over 24 pounds.
The remote control looks much like earlier Sony remote designs from the company's budget front projectors. It is rather basic with direct access keys for the picture formats, lens control, brightness, contrast, and aspect ratio selection. Fortunately the control is fully backlit, which makes use in a darkened home theater much easier. Unfortunately, input selection is not direct, which means you have to scroll through all the inputs by hitting the input key repeatedly. The internal menu system is also identical to previous Sony projector designs, and I found it easy to navigate and fairly intuitive to use.
The most important feature of the VPL-VW50 is its 1,920x1,080 (aka 1080p) native resolution, which allows it to display every detail of 1080i and 1080p sources without scaling. All other sources, including 720p HDTV, DVD, and standard-definition television, are scaled to fit the pixels. A high native resolution is especially important in front projectors because you're dealing with screen sizes much larger than typical TVs.
The VPL-VW50 has a few extras that will help you optimize the picture, although it lacks convenience features like PIP and the like. I was pleasantly surprised to find that the lens features (Focus, Zoom, and vertical shift) are all electronic. This enabled me to stand right up at the screen when sizing and focusing the image, which makes that chore far easier than if the lens features were manual. Of course, there are multiple preset picture modes to choose from including several user modes. I chose Standard to do my evaluation. Selectable color temperatures are on board, and the Low setting comes quite close to the industry standard color temperature of 6500 Kelvin. You can choose from four aspect ratio modes.
One of the most important picture-affecting features is the Iris setting in the Cinema Black Pro menu. The Advanced Iris should either be set to off or Manual. The Auto settings mean that the Iris will change depending on the picture content, effectively giving you black and white levels that are moving targets and constantly changing. The Manual setting will allow you to fix the Iris to the level of light output you need, and High and Low Lamp settings add a second level of light output control depending on how big a screen you need to fill. The Black Level Adjust and Gamma Correction features should both be turned off for the best performance. A Color Space option gives you the choice of Wide or Normal, with Normal coming a little closer to the system specifications for the primary colors of red, green, and blue. The RCP feature is a poorly implemented color management system that doesn't work at all and should be shut off. Click here to see the best settings we found or visit the Tips & Tricks section.
Connectivity options on the VPL-VW50 are relatively generous for a front projector. It sports two HDMI inputs, one component video input, one 15-pin VGA input for computers (which can handle resolutions up to 1,920x1,080), one S-Video and one composite video input, an RS-232 control port, and a 12-volt trigger for activating electric drop-down screens. I was pleased to find that the HDMI inputs both deliver the full resolution of 1080p signals (both 1080p/24 and 1080p/60), and disappointed to find that the component video input won't accept 1080p at all.
In terms of picture quality there is no doubt that resolution is seductive, and the Pearl does deliver every pixel of a 1080i/p HD source. It also has solid contrast ratio, which is arguably the most important performance parameter in a display. Where the Sony falls short is color accuracy; the primary and secondary colors are way off the mark. Grayscale tracking is also a little inconsistent for a high-performance projector, indicating some gamma problems. By way of comparison, my current reference projector remains the Samsung SP-H710AE 720p one-chip DLP projector, because it has near-perfect color in every regard once it is set up properly, and gamma that emulates a CRT, which in combination are more important than the fact that the Sony has a lower resolution.
Another long-standing weakness in all Sony HDTVs is noisy video processing. It is important to note that the DDE feature must be in the Progressive or Film mode when watching 1080i HD material, otherwise you will lose up to 50 percent of the vertical resolution from the signal, which makes it appear noticeably softer. On the positive side, this feature allows the VPL-VW50 to fully resolve 1080i HD sources, which is not the case with many projectors in this price range.
Color decoding was spot on, which means you will get rich, saturated colors on the screen without people looking like they have sunburns. For an inexpensive projector, it has a relatively good lens, with only a few chromatic aberrations, and panel alignment looks better than on its bigger brother the VPL-VW100, aka the Ruby. The Ruby's panel alignment was so bad that in some cases it looked like a misconverged CRT projector, with fringes of colors visible along some white lines.
HD content looked quite sharp on the VPL-VW50. Watching Batman Begins in HD on my cable system revealed good blacks, great snap to the picture, and well-saturated--if inaccurate--colors. Standard-definition cable looked pretty good on channels, such as CNN, that do a reasonably good job delivering the broadcast, but it didn't look so good on some of the heavily compressed analog channels.
HD DVDs were rendered with razor-sharp clarity. Seabiscuit, one of the best HD DVD transfers to date, in particular looked quite good. Skin tones looked extremely natural thanks to a relatively good grayscale. On the other hand, red and green objects like grass, hedges, and so on weren't rendered very realistically, which is a direct result of the skewed primary colors. If the VPL-VW50 delivered the correct primary and secondary colors or Sony fixed the RCP feature so that technicians like myself could correct them, the projector would be worthy of an Editor's Choice Award.
All things considered, the VPL-VW50 is one of the better values in 1080p front projection today. It delivers all of the resolution that a 1080p projector should, has good color decoding, processes 1080i HD sources well, and the price is ridiculously low for what you get. I just wish Sony and other manufacturers would start paying attention to the accuracy of the primary and secondary colors.
|Before color temp (20/80)
|After color temp
|Before grayscale variation
|After grayscale variation
|Color of red (x/y)
|Color of green
|Color of blue
|All patterns stable
|2:3 pull-down, 24fps
|Defeatable edge enhancement