/> ED I T O R S C H O I C E IN N O V A T IO N A W A R D
X

CNET editors pick the products and services we write about. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

Samsung PS51E8000 review: Samsung PS51E8000

niall-magennis.jpg

Samsung usually concentrates most of its marketing efforts on its LED TVs, but the company still produces some worthy large-screen plasma TVs. Often these have the same headline features as the LED models, but are offered at a cheaper price. The PS51E8000 is a good example of this -- it's got the same gesture and motion control features as the UE55ES8000, but it's available for around £1,300 online, compared to the LED model's asking price of £1,800. Seems like a good deal on paper, but how does it stack up in the flesh?

orig-samsung-ps51e8000-main.jpg
8.3

Samsung PS51E8000

The Good

Great online features; Skype video calling without the need for any add-ons; Strong 2D and 3D images; Good sound quality.

The Bad

Expensive; Motion and voice control features are not worth the effort.

The Bottom Line

Forget about the gimmicky voice and motion control features -- this set has plenty to make you sit up and take notice of it. It marries great online features with good audio quality and strong picture performance across both 2D and 3D. Its price is a little bit high unfortunately, especially compared to Panasonic's TX-P50GT50. That model has slightly better picture quality, but the Samsung PS51E8000 does outclass it when it comes to online features.

Voice control

The E8000 is the top-of-the range model in Samsung's current plasma lineup, so it's no surprise to find that like the company's high-end LED sets, you can control it via voice and motion as well as the standard TV zapper.

To use the voice control there are two trigger phrases. You either say "Hi TV" or "Smart TV". Unfortunately you have to select which one you want to use manually in the menu as you can’t just randomly swap between them.

Samsung PS51E8000
Do as I say, Mr TV, or there'll be trouble.

The TV has a microphone built in to the chassis to pick up what you say, but there's also one on the touchpad remote that Samsung supplies with the TV. The integrated mic works pretty well as long as there's not too much background noise in your room or you don't have the volume level set too high. Alternatively you can use the mic integrated into the touch remote, meaning you don’t have to use the trigger word and can then just press the button on the remote and speak. But if you've got the remote in your hand anyway, why wouldn't you just use the normal buttons?

There aren’t that many voice commands you can actually use. It's limited to stuff like changing the channel or adjusting the volume level. You can also launch a few of Samsung's Smart apps, but not third party apps.

The voice commands work reasonably well, but voice control is quite slow to react and there aren’t enough commands to make it really useful. Voice control can’t be used inside the Smart apps for example, and by the time you've said the trigger phrase and waited for the TV to respond, you could have just picked up the remote and changed channel.

Motion control

The TV also has a built-in camera that it uses for motion control. To let the set know you want to control it using motion, you have to raise your hand and wave it over and back with your palm facing outwards. This calls up a cursor onscreen that you can then move around with your open palm. To select something onscreen you close your palm into a fist.

Samsung PS51E8000
Wave your hand in the air like you just don't care.

The motion tracking tends to work reasonably well in a bright room, but usually doesn’t work at all in a darker room. Holding your palm up in the air becomes tiring after a short while as it feels unnatural. The granularity of the control isn’t quite fine enough for certain tasks, such as controlling the Web browser. Trying to scroll up and down on a webpage is annoyingly hit and miss. Minority Report it most certainly is not.

And this is the crux of the problem with the voice and gesture controls. While they're fun to try out when you initially get the TV, after a day or two you're unlikely to ever use them again, as it's just not worth the effort. When Apple introduced touch control on the iPhone people loved it because it was so much more intuitive than using a stylus. But here Samsung has introduced two control systems that are just slower and more difficult to use than a normal TV remote control.

While there are quite a few reasons this TV is worth your consideration,  the voice and motion controls aren’t among them.

User interface and EPG

Samsung has consistently delivered TVs with great looking user interfaces and the E8000 is thankfully no different. The menus are centred around a colourful homescreen from where you can access most of the TV's key features, from smart apps to the EPG. It can still take a little while to find your way around all the features, but there's less of the duplication within the menu than on the system used on LG's TVs.

Samsung PS51E8000
The EPG is one of the better ones you'll find on today's TVs.

The EPG is top notch too. The layout is bright and eye-catching, and there's an integrated video thumbnail window, so you can keep track of what you were watching while you peruse the programming guide. The only slight annoyance is that when you're watching a program and hit the Info button, it only shows a single line of the programme description.

Design and connections

The E8000 doesn't look quite as stylish as the ES8000, as it's not as slim and doesn't have as narrow a bezel around the screen. This is of course because it uses plasma rather than LED display technology. Nevertheless, by plasma standards it's still, on the whole, a good looking set. I like the way the bezel has an attractive transparent lip running around the outside, and the four-pronged stand is also a bold design statement.

Samsung PS51E8000
It's by no means a stunning set, but it's definitely managed to avoid a run-in with the ugly stick.

Strangely when it comes to connections, Samsung has only equipped it with three HDMI ports, whereas you'd usually find four of them on similar sized TVs from rival manufacturers. Nevertheless, the TV does have Ethernet, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth built in and there are both RF and satellite aerial inputs, as it has both Freeview HD and Freesat HD tuners onboard.

You also get three USB ports, to which you can connect a hard drive in order to enable the PVR-style recording features. There's also a set of full sized component inputs, and you can connect Scart devices to the set via the RGB extension adaptor cable.

Samsung PS51E8000
On the rear of the TV you'll find an expansion socket that is designed to allow you to upgrade its Smart TV features at a later date.

The rear of the set has an expansion port, which Samsung says will allow people to upgrade the set's Smart TV's feature in the future via a plug-in board. This sounds good in theory, but there's no indication as to when these boards will become available or how much they'll cost.

Digital media

Right from the get go, Samsung's smart TV platform was one of the front runners and the company has managed to keep that momentum going, with the result that its current offering is probably the best available on the market. When you fire up the Smart Hub on this TV, you'll find that most of the big media hitters are present and accounted for, including BBC iPlayer, Lovefim, Netflix and ITV Player. The continued absence of 4oD is unfortunate, although it's currently missing from all the Smart TV platforms, bar YouView.

Samsung PS51E8000
The TV supports ITV Player as well as BBC iPlayer, Lovefilm and Netflix.

There are plenty of other services such as the Acetrax and PictureBox movie rental options and news and information apps from BBC Sport, USA Today and Accuweather. The TV also has a built-in browser, which supports video playback on some sites -- but not all -- and is a tad sluggish to use. We can’t see anyone making use of it instead of the browser on their tablet, for example.

A major bonus of this model is its Skype software. As the TV has both a camera and microphone built in, you can make video calls right from the comfort of your sofa. It works extremely well, and both the speech and video quality is surprisingly good.

The TV also has a digital media player on board. This worked with Xvid and DivX files, but when it came to MKV files, they would only play locally from USB devices -- they wouldn't stream across a network from a NAS drive.

Audio quality

Plasma TVs use a slightly thicker chassis than LED equivalents, and as such they generally have better sound quality because there's extra space to fit in bigger speakers. The E8000 is no different in this regard -- its sound quality was just that little bit fuller sounding than Samsung's ES8000 models. It's still not exactly drowning in bass, but there's enough low-end poke to stop action movies from sounding thin and lifeless. Dialogue has good presence too and even music channels don’t sound half bad through the set's speakers.

2D picture quality

To be clear from the outset, the PS51E8000 produces very likeable pictures. It really does an excellent job of delivering images with great naturalness and tonal sophistication. They may lack the extra burst of brightness that you get on the company's LED models, but in some ways colours look more real because of it.

HD sources are pin-sharp, and Samsung's upscaling isn’t half bad either. It does introduce a little bit of extra picture noise, but upscaled images definitely look cleaner than they do on Samsung's ES6500 model, which I tested recently.

Samsung PS51E8000
Picture quality is very good, even if it does lack a bit of the extra depth that you'll get from Panasonic's 2012 plasmas.

Motion is very nicely handled too -- one of the inherent benefits of plasma technology -- making the set the ideal partner for a night in watching the footy.

There are weaknesses, however. While its black levels are very deep and consistent across the whole display -- unlike Samsung's high-end LED models -- the fact remains that they're just not as cavernously deep as those on Panasonic's latest plasma models. This has a knock on effect on its contrast performance too, as images aren’t quite as cinematically rich looking as you get from the likes of Panasonic's GT50 and VT50 models. The E8000 just lacks that extra dynamism, which Panasonic has succeeded in shoehorning in to this year's range.

3D picture quality

The E8000 is no slouch when it comes to 3D. Samsung includes two pairs of active 3D glasses with the set and these are very light, if a little bit on the fiddly side to wear. Naturally the glasses do dim the images from the TV a tad, and in this regard 3D pictures don’t look quite as attention-grabbing as they do on Samsung's LED models. Pictures also seem to be noisier in 3D than in 2D.

Samsung PS51E8000
The set comes with two pairs of 3D glasses.

The good news, however, is that 3D pictures look every bit as sharp as 2D images. There's almost no crosstalk when you're watching 3D movies, which really helps to draw you into the experience, especially if you're watching one of the better 3D titles, such as Scorsese's Hugo.

Conclusion

While its voice and motion control features are quite gimmicky, this Samsung set has great online features, good audio quality and strong picture performance across both 2D and 3D. Its price is still a little high though, compared to Panasonic's TX-P50GT50. You'll get slightly better picture quality from Panasonic's model, but the PS51E8000 definitely outclasses it when it comes to online features.