/> ED I T O R S C H O I C E IN N O V A T IO N A W A R D
X

CNET editors pick the products and services we write about. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

NitroBrew review: High-priced nitro-infusing gadget adds fizz to your drink at the expense of flavor

bb-ces

Nitrogenation, the process of adding finely textured air and CO2 bubbles to beverages under high pressure, has long been a favorite of sweet stout and cream ale drinkers. Traditionally employed when pouring Irish and English ales and stouts, the technique dates back to the mid-20th century. Without a doubt the practice gives beer a smooth, sweet flavor that's rich, less bitter, and lingers pleasantly on the palate. Now baristas have begun to harness nitrogen's powers too since it lends cold-brewed coffee a similarly delicious taste and thickness.

nitrobrew-product-photos-1.jpg
4.6

NitroBrew

The Good

The NitroBrew adds smooth, creamy nitrogen bubbles to drinks without the need for pro equipment.

The Bad

With a sky-high price the NitroBrew kit costs too much. The contraption is also confusing and difficult to operate and deadens the flavor of most of the drinks you run through it.

The Bottom Line

Saddled with a steep price and disappointing performance the NitroBrew falls flat on its promise to make delicious nitrogenated drinks at home.

The equipment you need to nitrogenate liquid, first popularized by the legendary Guinness brewery, entails cumbersome kegs, hoses, pipes, and taps. Enter the NitroBrew, a $500 system (the site says to contact the company for international pricing and shipping, but that is roughly equivalent to £325 or AU$ 670) whose creators promise will let any consumer add a nitrogen-powered kick to any drink. While the NitroBrew converts beers and coffee into wonderfully frothy confections, it's a pain to use, expensive, doesn't always work and more often than not dulls the taste of drinks you make.

NitroBrew is built to turn any drink into silky-smooth nitro beverages (pictures)

See all photos

A sweet but complex pour

The urge to enjoy drinks laden with creamy nitrogen bubbles is a powerful one. Beverages prepared in this manner are seductively smooth, rich and possess a deeply complex yet sweetly rounded flavor. Frankly if done right it's an irresistible combination. Once the sole domain of a handful of exclusive (often imported) stout beers and ales, the allure of nitrogen is now spreading to the coffee world, too.

No matter how much you relish a nitro-poured confection, it's hard to overcome the fact that restaurant-grade nitrogen tap systems require lots of equipment and know-how to install and operate. These setups typically consist of a bulky 5-gallon gas cylinder (with nitrogen and CO2 mix under high pressure), a nitrogen regulator valve, not to mention a specially designed stout tap and a nest of tubing.

Enlarge Image
The NitroBrew is small but has a lot of parts. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

The NitroBrew hopes to solve this dilemma by shrinking everything you need to serve nitrogen-infused drinks at home down into something that'll fit onto your kitchen countertop.

Nitro on micro

The NitroBrew may be small enough to shoehorn onto your average home bar but remains a contraption in every sense of the word. Cobbled together from a mix of off-the-shelf parts and custom tools, the kit feels more prototype than prime-time consumer product. The most intimidating component of the NitroBrew kit is its air compressor. Shaped like some kind of internal combustion engine, the hefty (6 pounds, 14 ounces or about 3.12kg) device wouldn't be out of place on top of car hoods or maybe sprouting from a lawn mower.

Enlarge Image
The biggest and most confusing part is the air compressor. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

If you've ever done any hobby airbrushing, though, you might recognize this gadget for what it is, a repurposed Central Pneumatic air compressor model 93657 (also sold under the Harbor Freight brand).The 1/6-horsepower compressor plugs into standard North American three-prong AC electrical outlets and is designed to power airbrush paint applicators preferred by model builders and novelty illustrators.

Connected to the compressor via a coiled hose is a rectangular hunk of metal about the size of a jewelry box. Called a Charging Station, on one side of this box sits a spring-loaded circular hole which actually is a pneumatic switch valve. The valve pushes pressurized air from the compressor into the NitroBrew kettle, "charging" it if you will.

Enlarge Image
The Charging Station uses a pressure switch valve. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

The kettle, the final piece of the NitroBrew puzzle, is crafted from stainless steel and looks like a cross between a tiny pressure cooker and an oversize cocktail shaker. It's within this vessel that the magic of nitrogenation happens. The container consists of a metal lid (sealed by a rubberized gasket) which swivels onto a lower portion designed to hold a maximum of 12 fluid ounces, The lid also houses a pen-shaped nozzle tooled to interface with the Charging Station's switch valve.

Enlarge Image
The magic of nitrogenation happens in the stainless steel kettle. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

It's not easy to NitroBrew

The creators of NitroBrew may claim the device is a breeze to operate, saying, "it's fast to set up and easy to use." In my experience using the system was anything but simple. For starters, the included instructions fall short of what I call a proper manual. Really a five-page computer print-out, the basic document is light on many details, particularly how to operate the bundled air compressor.

Operating the compressor is one of the most confusing aspects of the NitroBrew kit. Not only is it crucial to set the machine's pressure output correctly to achieve quality drinks, the compressor arrived with its controls wildly off the mark.

In the NitroBrew's defense, an additional "quick instruction" leaflet (one page) does say to "adjust the pressure regulator to 35 PSI" but neglects to explain precisely how to do this. I learned (only through a lot of fiddling and trial and error) that I needed to unlock then twist the compressor's regulator knob fully closed first. This is done by spinning the knob counterclockwise all the way even though it feels like doing so will cause the control to pop right off the compressor.

From here I was able to calibrate the pressure setting, confirmed by an analog dial, by switching the compressor on and gradually cranking the regulator knob clockwise. Regardless this procedure is painstaking and far from user friendly. That said, once set properly the compressor will automatically shut off when the internal pressure of the kettle lands on your selected value.

Enlarge Image
You have to calibrate the air compressor manually. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

I also ran into trouble getting a dependable airtight seal when closing the NitroBrew's kettle lid even though I followed the supplied directions to the letter. About half the time the lid swiveled into place gently, locked with an audible click, but failed to pressurize. My only workaround was to turn the "locked" lid in the reverse direction slightly thus hitting the pressure seal sweet spot.

Enlarge Image
Using the Charging Station to pressurize the kettle was tricky. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Another key action that's critical to making nitrogenated beverages, and one lesson I learned the hard way, is serious shaking. If I didn't vigorously agitate the kettle using both hands, cocktail shaker-style, my drinks became uncarbonated and lifeless. I must stress, too, that after NitroBrewing my way through a whole sixpack (making, not drinking), and all the required kettle shaking, I was completely bushed.

Enlarge Image
Using the NitroBrew right requires a heck of a lot of shaking. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Tiny bubbles, flat taste

I spent a lot of time with the NitroBrew hoping to enjoy some truly delicious results. Sadly in almost all cases what the gadget whipped up was a big disappointment. Both the beer and cold-brewed coffee I successfully processed did have a richer, rounded texture and creamy mouthfeel. I also saw the neat cascading bubble effect nitro stout fans know and love.

Enlarge Image
Add that distinctive bubble cascade to beer and cold-brewed coffee. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Unfortunately the NitroBrew significantly flattened the flavor and complexity of all but the most intense of alcoholic and java-based concoctions. For example I and my fellow crew of CNET editors preferred the slightly bitter finish of the un-NitroBrewed Vanilla Java Porter from Atwater Brewery. While supercreamy and rich, the porter became unbalanced and cloyingly sweet. The same was true of Kentucky's own West Sixth's Cocoa Porter.

If you have notions that the NitroBrew can perform alchemy by turning say a watery brew like Budweiser into something special, think again. What emerged from the kettle was an unbelievably noxious (and flat) liquid absolutely devoid of crispness or taste.

nitrobrew-product-photos-36.jpg
Stouts and porters became smooth and creamy but most of the time lost flavor. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

It was only the powerfully intense Lefthand Milk Stout that benefitted from NitroBrew treatment. The vanilla and coffee notes were favorably highlighted in the NitroBrewed drink; that may not be everyone's cup of tea, but it's a taste I'm sure some will appreciate. Of course, you can also just buy a six-pack of Lefthand's own bottled Nitro Milk Stout and save yourself about $490.

Enlarge Image
NitroBrewed coffee was smooth, creamy, with a stout-like feel. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

The NitroBrew did a fair job of adding creamy nitrogen bubbles to cold brewed coffee. Drinks I ran through the system definitely approached a Guinness level of nitro-carbonation. Of course I did have to supply a few ounces of club soda to help the process along. I also found that bringing more flavor to this cold-brewed party yielded better results.

Enlarge Image
A touch of bitters and maple syrup greatly improved nitro cold-brew flavor. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

For example adding a few dabs of Fee Brothers Aztec Chocolate bitters along with a tablespoon or so of maple syrup did wonders in terms of both depth and sweetness. Otherwise I and my group of taste-testers preferred my cold-brew coffee base straight with a touch of ice.

Conclusion

Like many radically innovative products, the NitroBrew promises quite a lot but ultimately fails to deliver. It falls flat on its fundamental pledge to nitrogenate any beer or coffee drink as well as a true nitrogen tap would. In my personal experience, the quality of beer pushed through a pro nitro setup run rings around the blunted flavor of beverages the NitroBrew makes. This is also true of cold-brew coffee the NitroBrew processed, though doctoring the mix with extra seasoning definitely improved things.

A further hindrance to the NitroBrew's success is its clunky and confusing operation. The lack of a proper manual to help smooth out some of the gadget's rough edges certainly doesn't improve matters. Of course other devices would like to provide similar abilities to home bartenders such as the Fizzics machine and Joetap, but until they hit the market or I have a chance to try them out, I recommend leaving nitro pours to the pros or become one yourself.

nitrobrew-product-photos-1.jpg
4.6

NitroBrew

Score Breakdown

Performance 5Design 4Features 5Maintenance 4