X

Neato XV Signature Pro review: Is this boring little bot better than the Roomba?

Meet the bot that's raising the bar for robot vacuums.

Ryan_Crist2.jpg
Ry Crist
Ryan_Crist2.jpg

Ry Crist

Senior Editor / Reviews - Appliances

Originally hailing from Troy, Ohio, Ry Crist is a text-based adventure connoisseur, a lover of terrible movies and an enthusiastic yet mediocre cook. A CNET editor since 2013, Ry's beats include smart home tech, lighting, appliances, and home networking.

See full bio
9 min read

CNET editors pick the products and services we write about. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

When people think about robot vacuums, the first word that probably comes to mind is "Roomba," the signature offering from Massachusetts manufacturer iRobot. Take a look at today's market, though, and you'll find a variety of robot vacuums to choose from, all of which would love to make a run at the Roomba's robo-reign over the living room. One particularly worthy competitor is the Neato XV Signature Pro, the latest model from a smallish, California-based manufacturer called Neato Robotics.

2013_07_29_2468.jpg
8.2

Neato XV Signature Pro

The Good

The <b>Neato XV Signature Pro</b> is simple to use, and it outperformed the competition in almost all of our cleaning tests, at substantial cost savings.

The Bad

Compared with other robot vacuums, the Neato is a bit boring and feature-light.

The Bottom Line

The Neato offers unmatched value in its field. Its performance, simplicity, and price make it an excellent choice for buyers seeking an effective, low-maintenance robot vacuum.

The first, most obvious contrast between the Neato and other robot vacuums we reviewed is the price. Despite being Neato Robotics' newest and most advanced robot vacuum, the Signature Pro only costs $449.99. In comparison, the top-of-the-line Roomba 790 costs $699.99, while LG's Hom-Bot Square costs $799.99. Those are some substantial savings, making the Neato an attractive choice for buyers who might have been curious about robot vacuums in the past, but who found the higher price tags to be a deal-breaker. But still, $450 is a lot of money -- is the Neato worth it?

We say yes. After dozens of cleaning runs across multiple surfaces, and with multiple variations of debris scattered in its path, the Neato emerged as the clear favorite. In almost every situation we threw at it, the Neato picked up more debris than the competition, often in significantly less time. It's an efficient, powerful little machine, and its laser-guided navigation system is one of the smartest you'll find in any robot vacuum. It performed best on standard, medium-pile carpet, and impressed us with how well it picks up pet hair. If you're a dog or a cat owner living in a carpeted home, the odds are good that you'll love this vacuum. As for me -- a non-pet owner who loves hardwood floors -- it's still unquestionably the robot vacuum I would buy for myself.

At 8.6 lbs., the Neato is the heaviest robot vacuum that we tested. Colin West McDonald/CNET

Construction and design
The Neato is sturdy and well-built, with a tough outer shell capable of withstanding the inevitable barrage of gentle bumps against the legs of your dining-room table. It sits low to the ground, too, for greater access beneath furniture and cabinetry. The bin lifts conveniently out of the top of the machine - you won't need to flip it over or yank a drawer out to empty it, which makes for faster, easier cleaning than other models we tested. The backlit menu is easy to use, with a simple interface that makes scheduling a cinch.

At first glance, the Neato resembles the bottom section of your typical upright vacuum, at least in terms of its shape. It's a design approach that might help the Neato feel familiar, but it's also one that fails to highlight its modern, forward-thinking appeal. Throw in the black-and-white LCD menu that seems lifted from the very first generation of iPods, and the Neato actually feels downright dated, and certainly not as fun or quirky as other machines we tested.

Simply put, for all its smarts, the Neato feels a bit soulless. This might sound like an obtuse criticism, but for a machine that relies on artificial intelligence, subtle, playful touches of personality can really go a long way -- something that iRobot seems to have mastered in the Roomba after several generations of development. The closest the Neato comes is when it offers text asking you to put it down on the floor or thanking you for cleaning its bin. It's a polite machine, for sure, but not the life of the party.

Charging the Neato takes 2 to 3 hours. When it's finished, the light will change from red to green. Colin West McDonald / CNET

Usability
For such a sophisticated device, the Neato is surprisingly simple to use. Just press the power button to wake it, then press it again to set the vacuum off on a floor-cleaning expedition. When it's finished, the Neato will automatically find its way back to its charging station for a well-earned nap. It will also return home in the middle of a run if its battery is running low; once charged, it will automatically return to the spot where it left off and resume cleaning.

Even more convenient is the Neato's scheduling ability. Just turn it on and tell the Neato what days and times you want it to clean, and it'll take care of the rest. You can program it to skip days if you want, and you can even program it to run at different times on different days, a nice feature that you won't find on a lot of other robot vacuums. The scheduling feature is particularly useful if you want the Neato to tidy up while you're away at work during the day, or overnight, while you're asleep. I wouldn't recommend late-night cleaning runs, as the Neato was the loudest robot vacuum that we tested. While not as loud as a full-size vacuum, it's still noisy enough to wake you up.

Performance

Rice (out of 2.5 oz)
(Longer bars indicate better performance)


2.05
2.33
2.13

iRobot Roomba 790
2
2.32
2.25

LG Hom-Bot Square
1.85
1.87
2.13

Pet hair (out of 0.2 oz)
(Longer bars indicate better performance)


0.15
0.15
0.18

LG Hom-Bot Square
0.083
0.02
0.08

iRobot Roomba 790
0.047
0.05
0.17

Sawdust/sand mix (out of 1.25 oz)
(Longer bars indicate better performance)


0.42
0.43
0.92

iRobot Roomba 790
0.3
0.23
1.12

LG Hom-Bot Square
0.23
0.27
0.75

Infinuvo CleanMate QQ5
0.15
0.13
0.07

In our tests, the Neato was the overall standout, dominating the competition on each variety of carpet and performing well on hardwood, too -- though not quite as well as the Roomba when it came to picking up rice or our sand-sawdust mix. The data paints a very clear picture of the Neato's considerable vacuuming power, and it's hard not to like what you see. Pet owners in particular should pay attention -- the Neato honestly blew the competition away when it came time for dander duty.

The Neato is also an effective navigator. It had no trouble mapping out our test spaces and covered them with ease, rarely getting stuck and needing us to intervene. At only 4 inches high, it was able to clean beneath our couches, coffee tables, and bookshelves, and also navigated beneath low-hanging curtains, an obstacle that regularly confused some of the other robot vacuums we tested.

Despite being the slowest-moving vacuum that we tested, the Neato actually finished its runs faster than most of the competition, and this is a testament to how effectively and efficiently it covers space. Unlike the others, which zigzag chaotically about, the Neato maps out a perimeter, then fills it in with a precise back-and-forth, row-by-row motion. This also means that it rarely covers the same ground twice -- but thanks to its powerful suction and slow, steady pace, it really doesn't need to.

No Labradoodles were harmed in the testing of this robot vacuum. Colin West McDonald/CNET

These navigation capabilities are even more impressive once you throw common household obstacles into the mix. In addition to mapping out the perimeter, the Neato's invisible lasers will calculate the position of your furniture, as well. Once it has the lay of the land figured out, the Neato will weave back and forth through all of it, deftly avoiding every obstacle in its path. Watching it in action for the first time is about as cool as it gets.

The Neato also comes packaged with a 6-foot strip that you can lay on the ground to create a virtual boundary. This boundary did an excellent job, and was slightly easier to use than the Roomba's invisible walls, which involved imprecise aiming. Better still, the Neato strip didn't require us to run out to the store and pick up C batteries like you'll need for the Roomba's electronic barrier modules.

No robot vacuum is perfect though, and the Neato, for all its strengths, is no exception. During one test run in a furnished living room, the Neato spent a few futile minutes trying to ascend the sloped leg of an easy chair, and ultimately needed me to step in and correct its path. However, this specific chair seemed to be a tricky spot for almost all of the vacuums we tested, and unlike the Neato, some of the other units needed to be course-corrected more than once, and in multiple spots.

One more disappointment: during our admittedly punishing nuts-and-bolts test, the Neato found its brushes jammed by a three-quarter-inch washer, and again, I needed to step in and fix the problem before it would continue. While it might not be the best vacuum for extremely heavy debris, in most cases I feel confident saying that it should be able to make its way through your home without getting stuck and requiring rescue.

One other key gripe about the Neato is that it lacks some of the features commonly found in other robot vacuums. Unlike the LG Hom-Bot Square, which offers a variety of options for how it cleans your home, the Neato doesn't have any customizable cleaning modes, aside from spot cleaning, which simply tells the machine to vacuum in a specific, concentrated area. I like the Neato's orderly approach to cleaning, but I also enjoyed the way the Hom-Bot allowed me to experiment with different cleaning styles. I found I missed that level of customization with the Neato. Also, the Neato was the only vacuum we tested that didn't come with a remote, utterly dashing my hopes of using it to chase my cat. That said, none of those features made the Hom-Bot worth the extra $350.

The Neato comes with a pair of interchangeable brushes: a spiraling brush designed for rigorous carpet cleaning, and a rubber, straight-edged brush, better suited for smooth surfaces like wood and linoleum. Both of these performed as intended, and both of them also did well in the opposite environment, so if you forget to change a brush out (or if you're just too lazy to bother -- you are, after all, using a robot vacuum), your Neato will still get the job done just fine.

The Neato's bin is easy to remove and easy to clean. Colin West McDonald/CNET

Maintenance
The Neato's bin is a little on the small side, so you'll need to empty it out fairly regularly. It lifts easily out of the top of the machine, and boasts an allergen-reducing filter that snaps in and out of place to allow you to empty its contents. The Neato comes packaged with an extra filter, with additional replacements available for sale on the Neato Robotics Web site.

The Neato will charge in 2 to 3 hours, and will go for approximately 90 minutes before the battery runs out. In my home testing, I found that it was able to clean the kitchen, living room, dining room, and hallway of my 800-sq.-ft. apartment in about 35 minutes, with just over half of the battery remaining when it arrived back at its charging station. Cleaning time may vary depending on your furniture and the layout of your home.

Service and support
In addition to a one-year, limited warranty with an option for extra, extended coverage, the Neato comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee: users who aren't completely satisfied can return the Neato for a full refund, less shipping. Neato Robotics only offers this guarantee for vacuums sold directly through its Web site, so if you're purchasing from a third party, be sure and check that company's specific return policy.

The Neato Web site also features an extensive series of tips and tricks, how-to videos, frequently asked questions, and troubleshooting guides. You'll find periodic software updates that you can install on your Neato using a Mini-USB cable (not included). Recent updates have included the addition of the Neato's spot-cleaning mode, and improved corner navigation.

You can also call Neato directly at 1-800-642-0944 for toll-free technical support 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

Get to know the Neato XV Signature Pro robot vacuum (pictures)

See all photos

Conclusion
No other robot vacuum comes close to matching the value of the Neato. Out of all the machines that we tested, the Neato performed the best. Its ease of use and relatively low price level of $450 make it a product we could all envision ourselves owning, using, and enjoying on a daily basis, which isn't something we can say for every model we looked at. The Neato won't replace your upright vacuum outright (no robot vacuum will), but it will allow you to leave the upright in the closet and save it for those special circumstances that require good ol' human intelligence.

For its high level of performance and outstanding value, the Neato deserves first consideration from anyone thinking about buying a robot vacuum, especially pet and carpet owners. Shoppers looking for an abundance of cleaning modes to experiment with may also want to look into the LG Hom-Bot Square, while those looking for a more aesthetically minded unit that brims with personality will want to check out the Roomba 790. But in my view, none of these units offer enough of an edge over the Neato to justify the higher price tags, and at the end of the day, the Neato is simply the better vacuum.

2013_07_29_2468.jpg
8.2

Neato XV Signature Pro

Score Breakdown

Performance 9Design 8Features 7Maintenance 9