/> ED I T O R S C H O I C E IN N O V A T IO N A W A R D
X

CNET editors pick the products and services we write about. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

Motorola Barrage (Verizon Wireless) review: Motorola Barrage (Verizon Wireless)

Kent_German.jpg

OVR
7.0

Motorola Barrage (Verizon Wireless)

The Good

The Motorola Barrage has a durable design and a functional feature set that includes push-to-talk. Photo and call quality are satisfactory.

The Bad

The Motorola Barrage's 3G connection is a bit slow, and video and music quality are unimpressive.

The Bottom Line

The Motorola Barrage offers Verizon Wireless customers a rugged push-to-talk phone with admirable call quality.

Motorola has a long history of creating durable cell phones, but with the occasional exception, they've ended up at Nextel. As we've long encouraged Moto to spread the rugged love, we were glad to see it launch the Motorola Barrage for Verizon Wireless. So named (or so we presume) because it can handle a barrage of elements, the Barrage offers a flip-phone design encased in tough plastic with rubber sidings. It's even supposed to take a full dunking in water. The feature set is functional, and call quality is good. You can buy it for $129 with a two-year contract and a $50 mail-in rebate. Otherwise, you can pay $179 and get it contract-free.

Design
The Barrage isn't pretty, but it doesn't have to be. While other phones may break with one drop to the floor, the Barrage should handle more than its share of bumps. It's big (3.78 inches by 2.09 inches by 0.96 inch), a bit angular, and its hinge is oversized and sturdy. Rubber patches overlay the plastic skin on the sides and front and rear faces. Indeed, the phone has a solid and comfortable feel in the hand, and it opens and shuts with authority. The size shouldn't affect its portability, particularly since the Barrage isn't too heavy (4.2 ounces).

The external display measures 1.6 inches and supports 65,000 colors. It's sufficiently bright and vibrant, and you can adjust the wallpaper. It shows the date, time, battery life, signal strength, and photo caller ID. You also can access the Barrage's music player and scan through your tracks without opening the phone. Below the display are the dedicated music controls, which you can find by feel.

The camera lens sits just above the display. There's no flash, but you can use the external display to take self-portraits. On the left spine you'll find the volume rocker and the push-to-talk (PTT) button. Both are raised and easy to find when you're on a call, though we wish that the volume rocker was a little larger. The Micro-USB/charger port sits just below. On the right spine are the voice dialing control, the speakerphone/handset locking key, and the 2.5mm headset jack. Unfortunately, you don't get an exterior camera shutter. The antenna forms a small loop at the top of the phone.

To keep the Barrage waterproof, the battery cover uses a locking mechanism at its bottom end. Moto doesn't include a tool in the box, so you'll need a coin or a sharp fingernail to get it off, but it's an easy process. The microSD card slot is located behind the cover (you don't need to remove the battery, too). Normally we'd disapprove of such an arrangement, but we get the need for it on a phone that can go swimming. Indeed, we gave the Barrage a full bath and it kept on ticking.

The 2.2 inch display shows 65,000 colors (176x220 pixels). Though it pales in comparison with 262,000-hue screens, it gets the job done. You can change the backlighting time, the dial and menu font size, and the brightness. The menu interface is available in three designs, and each allows for a degree of customization.

The Barrage navigation array is spacious and comfortable. There's a four-way toggle with a central OK button, two soft keys, a clear button, a camera shortcut, and the Talk and End/power keys. All keys are tactile and you can designate shortcuts for the toggle. They keypad buttons are equally satisfying. We could dial and text quickly and we could use the keys by feel. The backlighting is bright and the numbers on the keys are large.

Features
The Barrage has a 1,000-contact phone book with room in each entry for five phone numbers, two e-mail addresses, a street address and notes. You can save contacts to groups and assign them a photo and one of 12 polyphonic ringtones. PTT numbers are stored in a separate phone book; you can assign each contact an alert tone and organize them in groups.

Essential features include text and multimedia messaging, a calculator, a calendar, an alarm clock, a stopwatch, a notepad, and a world clock. You'll also find USB Mass storage, PC syncing, full Bluetooth with object transfer and stereo profiles, GPS with support for VZ Navigator, instant messaging, voice commands, a voice recorder, Web-based POP3 e-mail, and you can use the Barrage as a modem. And as mentioned, you can use Verizon's PTT network.


The Barrage's camera doesn't have a flash.

The Barrage's 2-megapixel camera takes pictures in five resolutions, from 1,600x1,200 down to a special size for photo caller ID. Editing options are standard. The camera offers a self-timer, a brightness control, five white-balance settings, three color effects, nine fun frames, a digital zoom, and three shutter sounds plus a silent option. The camcorder shoots clips two resolutions (320x240 and 176x144). Editing options are similar to the still camera, though not as extensive. Clips meant for multimedia messages are capped at about a minute, but you can shoot for longer in standard mode.


The Barrage offers admirable photo quality.

When finished with your clips and photos, you can transfer them off the phone via MMS, Bluetooth, a memory card or a USB cable. You also can upload them to a multimedia message or save them directly to the handset. The Barrage has a respectable 132MB of available shared memory and the external memory slot accommodates cards up to 16GB. Photo quality is quite good with natural colors and little image noise. Videos, on the other hand, are just average.

As an EV-DO phone, the Barrage supports the full range of Verizon's 3G services, including V Cast streaming video content, and the V Cast Music with Rhapsody. Both the V Cast menu and music store interface are pretty much unchanged from other Verizon phones. Player options include the usual limited shuffle and repeat modes, but V Cast Music also will recommend other songs based on your playlist. The Barrage includes an airplane mode for listening to your tunes while aloft.

You can personalize the Barrage with wallpaper and a selection of display themes, banners, and clock formats. More options and additional ringtones are available from Verizon using the WAP 2.0 Web browser. Aside from a Bing search app, the Barrage doesn't offer any applicants or games. You can always purchase titles; just keep in mind that Verizon uses BREW instead of Java.

Performance
We tested the dualband (CDMA 800/1900; EV-DO) Motorola Barrage in San Francisco and San Diego using Verizon Wireless service. Call quality was quite respectable. Voices sounded natural and the signal was clear. The volume could be louder, but we had no real complaints about the audio quality.

On their end, callers said we sounded fine as well with some not even knowing that we were using a cell phone. A few of our friends mentioned that the handset picks up some wind noise, but they were in the minority. Speakerphone calls were decent, though the volume also was a tad low.

EV-DO coverage was extensive, but the 3G connection wasn't very fast. It took over a minute to download a 3.7MB song, which is longer than it takes on comparable Verizon phones. V Cast videos also took several seconds to load.

Once streaming videos were running, the quality was about average. Though clips never paused or froze, the frame size is small, and we noticed some pixelation. It's fine for a few minutes, but we wouldn't want to watch a full program. Music quality was unimpressive over the external speaker. Fortunately, a headset offers a more enjoyable experience.

The Barrage has a rated battery life of 6.38 hours talk time and 22.25 days standby time. It has a tested talk time of 6 hours and 5 minutes. According to the FCC, the Barrage has a digital SAR of 1.25 watts per kilogram.

OVR
7.0

Motorola Barrage (Verizon Wireless)

Score Breakdown

Design 7Features 7Performance 7