Why You Can Trust CNET Mandrake Linux PowerPack Edition 9.0 review: Mandrake Linux PowerPack Edition 9.0
Mandrake Linux PowerPack Edition 9.0
With version 9.1 of its Linux distribution, MandrakeSoft has come as close as anyone to making Linux truly competitive with Windows. How? Mandrake Linux 9.1's relatively easy installation process isn't the reason; after all, easy, graphical installs have become the norm for recent Linux distributions, such as Red Hat Linux 8.0 and SuSE Linux 8.1. Believe it or not, Mandrake's fonts make all the difference. Mandrake offers fully readable word processing documents, spreadsheets, and Web pages, as well as granular font control. It's also brimming with bundled apps and can now automatically partition a Windows NTFS drive, something Red Hat and SuSE can't do. Mandrake Linux 9.1 doesn't resoundingly trump Red Hat or SuSE, but if you're looking for easy reading and support for NTFS partitioning, give this one a try.
Not long ago, Linux installations brought fear and trepidation to the uninitiated, but thankfully, that's no longer the case. Mandrake Linux 9.1 offers a graphical process and throws out only a few stumbling blocks. (For example, the setup asks for a username or an e-mail address of a security administrator but doesn't explain what the request is for--most users can safely ignore it.) Overall, though, setup runs smoothly, and although the help text is not as extensive as Red Hat's, installation is more suited to Linux newbies, thanks to the series of relatively simple wizards.
You can easily create an installation floppy by launching the Mandrake setup from Windows.
The same easy setup applies to the partitioning process, too. Like SuSE 8.1, Mandrake 9.1 offers an automatic partitioning option that makes use of free space on your hard drive to install the necessary Linux partitions and carry on with the installation. You can also use the built-in partitioning utility to manually choose the size of your partition, or you can tell Mandrake to get rid of all existing operating systems (which wipes out Windows and anything else) and take over the whole system. The default is automatic partitioning, which worked smoothly in our tests.
KDE 3.1 improves slightly on the previous interface with a better grouping of icons and applications.
Mandrake ships with all the standard Linux desktop environments--KDE, GNOME, ICEwm, Enlightenment, WindowMaker, and so on--and installs both KDE 3.1 (with some slightly more useful icon groupings) and GNOME 2.2 by default--a nice touch. You can then easily switch from one to the other, and if you choose to install any other window managers, you can select them at login. Mandrake 9.1 runs all of its desktop environments atop XFree86 4.3.0, the most recent version available of Linux's common X Window graphical user interface (GUI) system.
Once you have this OS up and running, you'll immediately notice its highly readable fonts. While the screen display still doesn't come close to a Windows XP screen with the ClearType font smoothing option turned on, especially on notebooks, Mandrake has given us the first truly readable Linux fonts out of the box. If they aren't pretty enough by default, you can also control the antialiasing of your system's fonts to improve things even more.
You can control the antialiasing of your system's fonts, including the type of subpixel hinting.
While Mandrake's help screens work well, novices will still have trouble navigating the OS. For example, you must look inside the /mnt directory to examine your Windows drives in the file manager (Konquerer in the case of KDE, Nautilus in the case of GNOME)--not easy to figure out--and it's also hard to know where to look in order to launch newly installed programs. But the same could be said for any unfamiliar OS, and this is really a KDE and GNOME issue, not specifically a Mandrake one.
The rpmdrake tool lets you select the packages you wish to install, offering in many cases a description of what the program does.
In the world of Linux distributions, the word features means primarily two things: the configuration dialogs (preference menus that let you customize everything from your desktop environment to peripherals), and the range and number of included applications. In both regards, Mandrake 9.1 stacks up well against its competition. Mandrake 9.1 offers several configuration screens to choose from, including KDE's and GNOME's standard dialogs and another one specific to Mandrake. Mandrake 9.1 offers strong support for multiple desktops, as well as plenty of configuration options for networks and peripherals.
The KDE Control Center lets you access all possible configurations for the KDE environment.
Mandrake also ships with several groups of applications, called packages in Linux-speak. During setup or anytime later, you can install a host of games, utilities, applications, and servers. The Standard Edition includes the latest Apache Web server, as well as GNOME's well-regarded (and very Outlook-like) Ximian Evolution. The entire installation fits into a few gigabytes of space, so we recommend installing all the apps if you have room. The PowerPack Edition includes Sun's StarOffice 6.0 productivity suite, in addition to the two suites packaged with the Standard Edition, OpenOffice and KOffice. In fact, PowerPack includes two CDs filled with commercial applications, plus another with more applications, none of which are part of the Standard Edition package. The PowerPack Edition includes two printed user guides, two months of free technical support (instead of one), and unlimited security updates for one computer.
GNOME's Ximian Evolution has become many Linux users' e-mail program of choice.
New to 9.1 (which runs Linux kernel 2.4.20 with the 2.4.21 patch) are a couple of important underlying features and one purely aesthetic one. The latter is Mandrake's Galaxy desktop theme, which you can use or replace with a different theme as you wish, but which has the advantage of providing a unified look to both the KDE and GNOME desktops, so it's not too jarring to switch between them. More importantly, you'll find an automatic network-configuration tool, called zeroconf, which helps you configure Ethernet, DSL, and cable connections. Version 9.1 also includes the ability to resize NTFS partitions. Whereas many other Linux distributions, including SuSE 8.1, can't automatically partition a Windows NTFS drive during setup, Mandrake 9.1 now allows direct manipulation and autopartitioning of NTFS drives (although, as with any partitioning package, it's still a good idea to back up everything you can before working with disk partitions).
Technical support for Mandrake 9.1 comes in different forms for different editions. If you download the distribution, you don't get any support. If you buy the Standard Edition, you're entitled to 30 days of Web-only installation support via e-mail. (Mandrake guarantees a response within 48 hours and follows through.) Purchasers of the PowerPack Edition get 60 days of this installation support, plus a security update license for one computer. There's no free phone support, however; it'll cost you $29 per incident, plus the toll call. By comparison, Red Hat Linux 8.0 Professional includes no phone support whatsoever but has similar online offerings boosted by 30 days' access to premium downloads and automatic OS updates. SuSE Linux 8.1 has the best support of the three, with free installation support by e-mail, fax, or phone for 90 days.
You can easily create an installation floppy by launching the Mandrake setup from Windows.
The same easy setup applies to the partitioning process, too. Like SuSE 8.1, Mandrake 9.1 offers an automatic partitioning option that makes use of free space on your hard drive to install the necessary Linux partitions and carry on with the installation. You can also use the built-in partitioning utility to manually choose the size of your partition, or you can tell Mandrake to get rid of all existing operating systems (which wipes out Windows and anything else) and take over the whole system. The default is automatic partitioning, which worked smoothly in our tests.
KDE 3.1 improves slightly on the previous interface with a better grouping of icons and applications.
Mandrake ships with all the standard Linux desktop environments--KDE, GNOME, ICEwm, Enlightenment, WindowMaker, and so on--and installs both KDE 3.1 (with some slightly more useful icon groupings) and GNOME 2.2 by default--a nice touch. You can then easily switch from one to the other, and if you choose to install any other window managers, you can select them at login. Mandrake 9.1 runs all of its desktop environments atop XFree86 4.3.0, the most recent version available of Linux's common X Window graphical user interface (GUI) system.
Once you have this OS up and running, you'll immediately notice its highly readable fonts. While the screen display still doesn't come close to a Windows XP screen with the ClearType font smoothing option turned on, especially on notebooks, Mandrake has given us the first truly readable Linux fonts out of the box. If they aren't pretty enough by default, you can also control the antialiasing of your system's fonts to improve things even more.
You can control the antialiasing of your system's fonts, including the type of subpixel hinting.
While Mandrake's help screens work well, novices will still have trouble navigating the OS. For example, you must look inside the /mnt directory to examine your Windows drives in the file manager (Konquerer in the case of KDE, Nautilus in the case of GNOME)--not easy to figure out--and it's also hard to know where to look in order to launch newly installed programs. But the same could be said for any unfamiliar OS, and this is really a KDE and GNOME issue, not specifically a Mandrake one.
The rpmdrake tool lets you select the packages you wish to install, offering in many cases a description of what the program does.
In the world of Linux distributions, the word features means primarily two things: the configuration dialogs (preference menus that let you customize everything from your desktop environment to peripherals), and the range and number of included applications. In both regards, Mandrake 9.1 stacks up well against its competition. Mandrake 9.1 offers several configuration screens to choose from, including KDE's and GNOME's standard dialogs and another one specific to Mandrake. Mandrake 9.1 offers strong support for multiple desktops, as well as plenty of configuration options for networks and peripherals.
The KDE Control Center lets you access all possible configurations for the KDE environment.
Mandrake also ships with several groups of applications, called packages in Linux-speak. During setup or anytime later, you can install a host of games, utilities, applications, and servers. The Standard Edition includes the latest Apache Web server, as well as GNOME's well-regarded (and very Outlook-like) Ximian Evolution. The entire installation fits into a few gigabytes of space, so we recommend installing all the apps if you have room. The PowerPack Edition includes Sun's StarOffice 6.0 productivity suite, in addition to the two suites packaged with the Standard Edition, OpenOffice and KOffice. In fact, PowerPack includes two CDs filled with commercial applications, plus another with more applications, none of which are part of the Standard Edition package. The PowerPack Edition includes two printed user guides, two months of free technical support (instead of one), and unlimited security updates for one computer.
GNOME's Ximian Evolution has become many Linux users' e-mail program of choice.
New to 9.1 (which runs Linux kernel 2.4.20 with the 2.4.21 patch) are a couple of important underlying features and one purely aesthetic one. The latter is Mandrake's Galaxy desktop theme, which you can use or replace with a different theme as you wish, but which has the advantage of providing a unified look to both the KDE and GNOME desktops, so it's not too jarring to switch between them. More importantly, you'll find an automatic network-configuration tool, called zeroconf, which helps you configure Ethernet, DSL, and cable connections. Version 9.1 also includes the ability to resize NTFS partitions. Whereas many other Linux distributions, including SuSE 8.1, can't automatically partition a Windows NTFS drive during setup, Mandrake 9.1 now allows direct manipulation and autopartitioning of NTFS drives (although, as with any partitioning package, it's still a good idea to back up everything you can before working with disk partitions).
Technical support for Mandrake 9.1 comes in different forms for different editions. If you download the distribution, you don't get any support. If you buy the Standard Edition, you're entitled to 30 days of Web-only installation support via e-mail. (Mandrake guarantees a response within 48 hours and follows through.) Purchasers of the PowerPack Edition get 60 days of this installation support, plus a security update license for one computer. There's no free phone support, however; it'll cost you $29 per incident, plus the toll call. By comparison, Red Hat Linux 8.0 Professional includes no phone support whatsoever but has similar online offerings boosted by 30 days' access to premium downloads and automatic OS updates. SuSE Linux 8.1 has the best support of the three, with free installation support by e-mail, fax, or phone for 90 days.
Score Breakdown
Setup 8Features 9Performance 0Support 6