Oscars 2019: Breaking down Black Panther's chances for best picture
Commentary: If any superhero movie can take home major awards, Black Panther is the one. But should the Academy Awards resist Marvel's cultural domination?
Richard TrenholmFormer Movie and TV Senior Editor
Richard Trenholm was CNET's film and TV editor, covering the big screen, small screen and streaming. A member of the Film Critic's Circle, he's covered technology and culture from London's tech scene to Europe's refugee camps to the Sundance film festival.
Black Panther has already bagged a bunch of gongs. Among a swath of award nominations, it's scooped the best-film award from the African-American Film Critics Association, the Black Reel Awards, BET and MTV. The film's music, visual effects and actors have also been rewarded with a BAFTA, two Grammys and several other wins. In January, it scooped up the Screen Actors Guild award for outstanding performance by a cast, and the SAG Awards often prove to be a leading Oscar indicator.
Without taking away from the achievements of the movie magicians rewarded for their skill and creativity in individual areas, best picture and best director remain the pinnacle of the awards season. And Black Panther deserves to challenge for the big awards.
Watch this: Oscars 2019: How to write the perfect best picture speech and go viral
Genre flicks can win these headline awards. The Oscars are often associated with worthy dramas like Spotlight or 12 Years a Slave, but nominees like Avatar and Gravity and last year's best picture The Shape of Water show sci-fi and fantasy aren't necessarily an outside bet. Meanwhile box office success didn't rule out best picture winners like Titanic and Braveheart.
What's more, Black Panther, for all its adrenaline-fuelled action and CG effects, is more than a superpowered beat-'em-up.
Like BlacKkKlansman and Green Book, it tackles timely and relevant questions of race and prejudice. Where those other films examine the subject through a historical lens, Black Panther looks at the here and now. The scene in which African artifacts are reclaimed from a British museum gives a succinct take on the bearing of colonial history on the present. And the whole Afrofuturist premise of Wakanda's highly advanced nation gives a glimpse at a possible future for the people scarred by that history.
On top of that, Black Panther is written, directed and largely created by black filmmakers. In a year the movie industry has had to take a long hard look at itself, the story of who's behind the camera is as important as the story unfolding on screen.
So if Academy voters want timely subtext and positive representation as well as a thrilling story and cinematic verve, it's all there between the punches and one-liners.
Of course, Black Panther doesn't have to win an Oscar. Director Ryan Coogler and the folks at
are probably pretty happy with the billion dollars Black Panther raked in at the box office, the rapturous reception from audiences and the near-universal critical acclaim.
And those who've been thrilled and empowered by the film don't need a stamp of approval from the Academy. An Oscar, at this point, would be merely the icing on the cake.
Besides, awards may actually be the last bastion against Disney and Marvel's total cultural domination. As much as we love superheroes and blockbuster shared universes, they're increasingly crowding out anything that isn't a remake or sequel from the big screen. So you could argue smaller and riskier original feature films need the boost awards buzz gives them. If the BAFTAs and the Golden Globes and the Oscars remind jaded viewers that the big screen is made for more than superheroes, it might motivate us to try a wider variety of movies.
Watch this: How Marvel made 'Black Panther' look so amazing
And may stop us from staying on the sofa with Netflix, too.
Which brings us to Netflix's Roma. Now available to stream to your TV or laptop or phone, Alfonso Cuaron's spellbinding drama is a cinematic triumph and richly deserves its best picture consideration. Although... comparing Roma to Black Panther shows the strangeness of artistic awards -- how do you weigh up two such different films? Regardless, a win for Netflix's Roma could also be seen as the start of a new era, as the highest bastion of the movie industry acknowledges a changing industry.
Whichever film wins, Tuesday's nominations signal some timely changes for movies. It remains to be seen who the winners are -- not just on Feb. 24 but in the future of features.
First published, Jan. 22. Update, Jan. 27 at 10:06 p.m. PT: Adds SAG Award win. Update, Feb. 21 at 10:55 a.m. PT: Adds additional awards the movie has won.