Esto también se puede leer en español.

Leer en español

Don't show this again

Nest Learning Thermostat review: Second-gen Nest zeroes in on perfection

Auto Away detects when you're gone from the house and keeps your home within a certain temperature range.

You can also set the temperature for "away" from your mobile device or browser, or manually on the Nest before you leave the house to conserve even more energy. If you want to change the range for Auto Away while you're on the road, you can do that from the Nest app, too. My only complaint here is that manual Away mode doesn't switch into auto mode before you come home -- this makes sense when you're on vacation or out of the house for a while, but I'd like semi-auto Away that I can switch off manually when leaving the house but that would prewarm or cool the house before my regular return time.

Apps to die for
One of Nest Labs' challenges with the Learning Thermostat is showing that once the thermostat has learned your patterns, there's something going on worth your $250. The Nest Learning Thermostat apps, available for use on iPhones, iPads, Android phones, and, with this release, Android tablets, go a long way toward letting you know you're paying for something.

The Energy History screen serves up 10 days of energy-use data porn, showing exactly when and how often your heat or AC powered on over the course of each day. An icon appears to give a simple explanation for daily fluctuations, indicating whether weather or your presence in the house made a difference in your energy use. When you see all that information spelled out, you can certainly see how much "thinking" the Nest does behind the scenes to mold itself to your patterns.

I actually think that this screen may do more for energy conservation with the Nest than almost any other feature. It's human nature to geek out on metrics, and seeing how your actions affect whether the Nest awards you a little leaf may drive smarter choices. (Did you set Away when you left the house? Or did you let Auto Away turn off the furnace on its own?) It's fun to play against yourself for energy savings -- to a point. After a few months of Nest use, though, I find myself checking in less and less often. Maybe that's because the novelty has worn off, but maybe it's because I trust the Nest to be doing its job and learning from me.

Nest laptop control
View full gallery
Using the Nest app or Web site, you can get a detailed look at when your system uses energy (or not) and why. Nest Labs

Unfortunately, the Nest ends its reports after 10 days, but if you sign up for a monthly energy use report, you'll get a regular (automated) e-mail detailing your Nest performance during the previous month and any energy saved. I'd love to be able to request -- even just through the Nest Web interface, where there's more screen real estate -- a year-over-year history so that I could evaluate how much money and energy I'm saving over time.

Energy savings
I've now been using the Nest for more than a year, and can report that as a result my energy use has gone down an average of 15 percent over the winter months, saving me about $70 per year for a 2,000-square-foot house. We don't cool our house in the temperate Bay Area, so all our savings have come from our heating bill. In a summer climate, I would expect to save more per year.

Those who have heating and cooling systems both hooked into the Nest likely find an added advantage. A Nest feature called Airwave takes advantage of the cold coils on your air conditioner and blows the fan over them even after your compressor shuts down, theoretically eking out every last bit of chill from the unit. I don't have AC in my home, so I can't test its efficacy, but the concept sounds smart and sound. The Nest 3.5 software also introduces the option to control a home's fan independent of the AC (to move air around the house creating a cooling effect without actually running the AC) on a set schedule or on demand.

Nest 3.5 introduces another feature called "Cool to Dry," which helps homes in extremely humid climates keep the moisture out of the air when humidity reaches mold-inducing levels but without running the AC for any longer than it would take to reduce the humidity to mold-safe levels. And in certain markets, Nest Labs now partners with local utilities to offer automatic rebates or to let those utilities create even-more-efficient cooling profiles on days when peak energy use may be a problem for the utility or the community. These programs are all completely optional for the user, and you can read more about them at the Nest Web site.

Installation is easy, as long as your home's wiring isn't weird
The Nest Learning Thermostat doesn't work with all houses, but there's a tool on the Nest Web site to help you determine whether your current wiring will work with Nest. It took me one peek at my thermostat and about 30 seconds online to figure out that I could install the device.

Nest says that you'll be fine installing the thermostat yourself if you're comfortable installing a light fixture, but in some ways, a Nest is even easier to install than a lamp. The Nest base (the part that accepts the wires from your furnace or AC unit and snaps under the Nest dial and screen) comes with a built-in level, and has reverse clips that hold the wires so that they're easy to work with with your fingers. The box comes with a wall mount (in case your wall, like mine, needs painting under your old thermostat and you don't have time to patch paint), screws that work in both wood and drywall, a screwdriver (with all the bits you may need neatly tucked into the handle) for a variety of situations, and handy labels to help you remember which wire is which. I found that I still needed to break out my cordless drill, though, to drill holes in my wood wall.

Nest package contents
The Nest comes with everything you'll need to install the thermostat yourself except a drill and a pencil. Lindsey Turrentine/CNET

The entire original Nest installation took me no longer than 15 minutes -- until I snapped on the faceplate. Theoretically, the wires from your furnace to your thermostat power the Nest, but mine didn't power on. It turns out that, through no fault of the Nest, my 60-year-old home was wired with a bizarre set of switches and had speaker wire completing part of the circuit. Thankfully, Nest Labs telephone tech support was quick, friendly, and exceedingly patient while helping me troubleshoot the problem.

Nest 2 wiring
View full gallery
Once you've labeled the wires and mounted the Nest base, plugging in the wires takes mere seconds. Lindsey Turrentine/CNET

The lesson here is: all houses are different, so be prepared for quirks, especially in older homes. But irregularities could crop up with any home wiring project. Nest offers a concierge service for $119 per device if you'd rather not take the risk, but seriously? You can do it.

Once I fixed the problem, the Nest powered on, walked me through setting the location (for weather reports) and jumping on my home's Wi-Fi, and I was off to the races. It took me much less time to set up the Nest Learning Thermostat than it does to figure out the settings and boot up e-mail accounts on a new smartphone.

In a market flooded with $20 programmable thermostats, a $250, high-end thermostat is a hard sell no matter how beautiful. A startup with a lot of attention, Nest Labs has leaned into quality to justify the price; everything about the Learning Thermostat screams classy and thoughtful. If you love the look and feel of high-end design, you won't regret the investment, although you'll start to feel the money bleed if you have a two-zone heating and cooling system and shell out for more than one Nest. If you don't already closely track your energy use, you'll probably make the money back over time, too, but it might take a few years.

Comparable Smart Home

All Smart Home

Best Products

All Best Products