Week in review: Yahoo snubs Microsoft--again

Microsoft and Carl Icahn tag-team on Yahoo, and it seems that just about everyone else got their day in court. Also: earnings season heats up.

Yahoo snubbed another takeover offer--this time from Microsoft and Carl Icahn. But that doesn't mean Yahoo is dead-set against a deal.

Yahoo announced over the weekend that it had rejected a joint-buyout proposal the software giant and investor activist offered the night before, which called for a "complex restructuring" and sale of Yahoo's search business to Microsoft.

The joint proposal called for Microsoft to buy the search business and Yahoo to swap out its board members for Icahn's dissident slate, who would then have control in running the remainder of Yahoo's businesses.

In rejecting the offer, Yahoo told Microsoft that it was willing to sell the entire company for at least $33 a share and that its board believed such a deal could be negotiated and executed before its annual shareholders meeting on August 1. Yahoo said it also informed the software giant that it remained willing to negotiate an "improved search-only transaction."

This sparked another round of letter writing.

Microsoft jumped into the brawl between Yahoo and Icahn on Monday, issuing a "set-the-record-straight" statement on its sweetened-yet-rejected offer for Yahoo's search business. The software giant said its search-only proposal "did not include changes to Yahoo's governance."

In other words, it was Icahn, the other partner in Microsoft's joint proposal, who was asking for all Yahoo board members and top management to resign immediately. But even Icahn, in his letter to shareholders Monday, noted that he was willing to discuss keeping some of the Yahoo directors around, and even founder Jerry Yang as "Chief Yahoo."

Microsoft also contends that its sweetened offer has been incorrectly portrayed as a "take-it-or-leave-it ultimatum" rather than a "timetable" to push negotiations forward. Yahoo, in its investor presentation, notes that Microsoft gave the company only 24 hours to consider its proposal.

In a yet another letter to shareholders, Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang and Chairman Roy Bostock claim that the latest proposal from Microsoft and Icahn "will destroy stockholder value at Yahoo."

The letter complains that Icahn invested in Yahoo only two months ago, and is just looking for a deal to "recover his investment and get back his money quickly--even a deal that does not provide full and fair value to you."

Despite those harsh words, Yahoo may finally be warming up to the idea of a takeover. The letter contained this interesting passage: "First, we will sell the entire company to Microsoft for $33 per share or more, if Microsoft will negotiate a transaction that delivers certainty of value and certainty of closing."

In the meantime, Icahn is turning his focus on the proxy battle in which he seeks control of the Yahoo board and will run a slate of nine dissident directors, according to his definitive proxy, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Icahn's announcement finally answers the question that has left investors wondering whether he would try to replace Yahoo's entire board at its August 1 annual shareholders meeting, or go after only a few seats to serve as a cattle prod.

Yahoo's nine current board members are up for re-election to a one-year term. Icahn's goal is to ensure that the next time Microsoft, or any other suitor, comes a-calling that the path to a buyout will face far fewer potholes.

On tech's court docket
The courts were busy this week with tech issues, the most prominent of which led to a ruling that eBay cannot be forced to police its auction listings to identify counterfeit Tiffany & Co. products. In what could become a landmark case for auction Web sites, the court said trademark law cannot be used to force eBay to shoulder the burden of examining individual auction listings for possible counterfeits.

The debate centers on whether the product manufacturer or the auction site should bear the cost of policing eBay listings for fakes. For its part, eBay says it spends $5 million a year in maintaining its fraud search engine, which has 13,000 rules that are designed to identify counterfeit listings based on words such as "replica" or "knock-off." Listings flagged by the search engine are manually reviewed by customer service representatives.

Meanwhile, Europe's governing body is expanding the number of antitrust charges it is bringing against Intel. The European Commission filed court papers that bring three additional charges against Intel for abusing its dominant position in the chip market in Europe, including offering inducements to European retailers for not buying processors from the company's competitors, chiefly Advanced Micro Devices.

In addition, Intel is charged with paying a "leading original equipment manufacturer" to delay the launch of a product with an AMD central processing unit, and giving "substantial" rebates to the same OEM if it bought only CPUs from Intel.

Microsoft's latest legal headache is a suit from a little-known company called Gotuit Media, which charges that elements of Silverlight infringe on patented technology that belongs to the video metadata company. Gotuit seeks an injunction against the software maker, as well as damages and attorney fees.

Gotuit may be a relative unknown, but Microsoft is facing an opponent it knows quite well. Gotuit is represented by San Francisco-based lawyer Spencer Hosie, the same Hosie that successfully represented Burst.com in its suit against Microsoft.

At least two companies in the legal spotlight managed to broker a compromise. YouTube will be allowed to mask important user information from records it must turn over to Viacom.

"Viacom and the other litigants have backed off their demand for YouTube user-viewing histories," Google said in a statement. "We have reached agreement to anonymize the data."

The move comes after a federal court earlier this month ordered Google's YouTube to hand over usernames, IP addresses, and viewing histories to Viacom, parent company of Comedy Central and MTV Networks. This ignited a controversy over Internet privacy and put Viacom on the defensive.

Featured Video