SAN JOSE, Calif. -- One of the first iPad prototypes will not be used as evidence in the trial between Apple and Samsung, despite it having been shown to jurors.
In a ruling near the end of the court session here today, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh said that Samsung could not use the tablet, which cropped up in a pile of new evidence last month, to help show differences in what Apple originally envisioned for its patented tablet design, and what it eventually shipped.
The design patent, called the '889 patent in the case between the two tech giants, depicts a rectangular tablet device. So far Apple says that has become the look of the iPad 2 and beyond, but that some of its subtleties -- like round corners, unibody back, and bezeled glass -- applied to the first-generation iPad as well.
In early court filings, Samsung argued that the differences were more broad, pointing todubbed the 035 model (pictured above), which looked more like the thick lid of one of the company's plastic MacBook laptops.
Despite Koh's decision, today was the second time the 035 prototype has been shown to jurors during this trial. Samsung's attorneys held it up during the company's opening statements last week, and once again today before Apple's attorneys took offense to its presentation, calling it an "ambush" during the tail end of industrial.
The trial continues tomorrow, with the expected testimony of early Apple designer Susan Kare, who is perhaps best known for creating the initial set of icons for the first Mac.
Apple - USE TAG
reading•Apple's ginormous iPad prototype kept out of trial
Aug 15•iOS 12: Release date, new features and hidden features
Aug 15•The 2018 iPhone X's and the Galaxy Note 9 could share these features
Aug 15•Twitter suspends Infowars host Alex Jones' ability to tweet
Aug 15•Alex Jones video that spurred Twitter suspension remained live on Periscope