This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.
CNET Update: OKCupid plays with our hearts without worry
About Video Transcript

CNET Update: OKCupid plays with our hearts without worry

2:58 /

The dating site conducted an experiment that falsified compatibility matches without telling users. When the results were published, OKCupid's co-founder said only two users complained. CNET's Bridget Carey explains the test and why it matters.

Okay, cupid is playing games with our hearts. I'm Bridget Carey and this is your cnet update. [MUSIC] Let's talk about love. The dating website OKCupid is stirring up some controversy with a little experiment it performed on it's users. To see how much compatibility test matter, it told people who were 30% compatible that they were actually a hot match. Turns out when you're told you're a good match, even if you aren't, you're almost twice as willing to have a conversation with that person. OkCupid also tested the opposite. It told users that were a great match. That they were only 30% compatible. Now some folks were influenced and less willing to talk. But many still ended up having a conversation. So although it's good to be a match. It helps to be told you're a match. This is a fascinating experience. These folks didn't agree to be part of an experiment. Unless you count agreeing to some. Vague legal statement in the data use policy some say messing with human emotions in secret is unethical. OK Cupid often does light-hearted reports that poll users and study how the site's being used but this is a dating site that doesn't take itself too seriously. But toying with love and emotions with false match results falls into a different uncomfortable category. Let's back up to see the bigger picture here. OkCupid's co-founder, Christian Rudder, says this experiment was done in the quest to improve the service's matchmaking algorithm. And that people were later made aware of their actual matches. But the timing's interesting. He's also promoting a new book. In an email, Rudder told me that, out of the 1.2 million users that logged into OkCupid when this study was announced. The site only received 2 complaints from users. So we have to ask ourselves, if OK Cupid users aren't that upset, will other web sites look at this example and also try to get away with conducting similar mind games, warping the information we see? They say you can't believe everything you read on the internet, but maybe we need to update that thought. You can't always trust what you read on the internet because you could be part of an experiment. Facebook got heat recently for a similar reason. Emotionally manipulating users in the name of science. But Facebook will find a new way to annoy some users this week. It has begun the process of forcing everyone to download the messenger app to hold private conversations. Users who have not downloaded the separate messenger app are getting emails nudging them that soon the main Facebook app will no longer let you have private messages. That's your tech news update and you may have noticed our set background is different. This will be my temporary home for awhile while our old studio is under construction, but in the meantime you're still getting the same update flavor, just in a new limited edition package. From our studios in New York, I'm Bridget Carey. [MUSIC]
  • This is the interactive sidebar!

    Click any icon for more information as they appear--don't worry, we'll pause the video and wait for you to come back.

  • Links Polls Galleries
  • Video Review

New releases

The Armor A60 portable drive can...
2:10 October 24, 2014
CNET editor Dong Ngo did some blah blah talking and then a real-world drop test on the Silicon Power Armor...
Play video
Macan: Meet the very different...
21:47 October 24, 2014
Porsche Macan marks the beginning of several chapters for the carmaker, plus a new list of the safest cheap...
Play video
Help battling robots cause even...
6:03 October 24, 2014
This week on Crave, we take a closer look at the Hendo hoverboard, fly on a Virgin Galactic spaceship, and...
Play video
Bowers & Wilkins C5 Series 2: A...
2:00 October 24, 2014
The C5 Series 2 sounds better than the original and is one top in-ear headphones for less than $200.
Play video
Mr. Coffee gains some smart home...
2:27 October 24, 2014
The $150 Mr. Coffee Optimal Brew Smart brews 10-cups at a time and can be controlled by the Wemo mobile a...
Play video
The Philips 100W Equivalent LED...
1:20 October 24, 2014
We tested this bulb to see if it's a better buy than GE or Cree
Play video
Breaking open iPads, Groupon's...
2:54 October 24, 2014
The iFixit team reveals the secrets inside the new iPads, Groupon mimics Yelp, and Microsoft kills the free...
Play video
Vizio P series: Good and cheap...
2:31 October 24, 2014
The highly anticipated Vizio P series is among the cheapest 4K TVs available and delivers a very good picture,...
Play video