This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.

CNET Top 5: Home entertainment tech flops of the decade

About Video Transcript

CNET Top 5: Home entertainment tech flops of the decade

3:06 /

Five home entertainment technologies that refuse to die, but should.

-My god! It's been a good run this first decade of the 21st century. We got in to HDTV, digital TV, streaming TV, TiVo in TV, and just about all of it wrapped in surround sound. Then, there were the losers. I'm Brian Cooley with top 5 home entertainment technologies that landed with a thud and it was still trying to scrape off our shoes. Number 5, HD DVD, almost a hit actually. It was that close between Sony's Blu-ray and Toshiba's HD DVD in the battle for disk space high-def. The Blu-ray format could hold more data, but HD DVD had some manufacturing advantages. In the end, it was studio support which was split until Warner said, "No. We're going Blu-ray." And Sony won it. Too bad it was a shortest victory, though. Now, that all the disks are being overshadowed by a move to a disc-less future of streaming. Number 4, CableCARD. This was suppose to get rid of those nasty dated poorly engineered cable boxes that mar your, otherwise, carefully rigged AV system. The idea was you would just plug a CableCARD into a slot on your TV and that would enable all the channels on your cable system. Simple, elegant, flexible, dead. The industry never got on the same page on this one, and it wasn't cohesively ruled out in either cable systems or televisions. And when you're trying to bridge those 2 technologies, that will kill it. Number 3, the DVD recorder. Shortly after DVD arrived on the scene, we all got excited about recording on those little silver discs lots of capacity, random access, easy to add and delete chapters of content, and also durable. Everything VHS was not ecxcept for one problem, TiVo. And the fact that recording a DVD was always cumbersome and time consuming. Just how I wanna spend time in my living room. Number 2, Sony's LocationFree TV. This one's weird, Sony laid out this vision for streaming whatever is on your home AV system to your computer over the internet and nobody got it. Sling came along with the same idea and folks got it. Chalk it up to Sony's uncanny ability to be obtuse about selling their innovations. And let's face it, Slingbox didn't exactly turned into a must-have either. But the number 1 home entertainment dud of the first decade of the 21st century has to be the towering twins of total technology, DVD Audio and Super Audio CD. Good grief. Who went into a board meeting and sold the idea of producing major new formats of discs for the audiophile in us all? Real audio nuts of which they are a few have vinyl in an artist in CDs. The rest of us are happy with the compressed slop that comes off the iTunes and Amazons stores. This idea was so bad, there was never even any hype around it. And in the tech biz, that's amazing. I'm Brian Cooley. Thanks for watching.

New releases

2015 Subaru Outback 3.6L Limited
6:00 January 26, 2015
Does the new Outback do enough to keep Subaru drivers coming back? Brian Cooley gets behind the wheel and checks the tech.
Play video
Icy adventure in the Land Rover Discovery Sport
1:10 January 26, 2015
Land Rover takes CNET editor Wayne Cunningham for a drive across Iceland, covering snow, ice and a river, in its new Discovery Sport...
Play video
iSmartAlarm's new camera sets out to secure the smart home
2:33 January 26, 2015
For $150, the iCamera Keep looks like a promising addition to one of our favorite security systems.
Play video
The thinnest tablet (so far) houses a stereoscopic camera
2:48 January 26, 2015
The Dell Venue 8 7000 is a skinny tablet with phat photography chops.
Play video
This tough garage fridge chills under extreme conditions
1:27 January 26, 2015
Designed to tame the harsh temperature swings of your garage, the Gladiator Chillerator works to keep its insides cool no matter w...
Play video
Sling TV launches with a new twist on Internet TV
2:54 January 26, 2015
Television service makes an evolutionary leap with Dish's $20 monthly plan, the NFL arrives on YouTube, and Freewheel offers Wi-Fi-only...
Play video
Is this the most exciting Mini in the world?
6:25 January 26, 2015
The Gen 3 Mini is a new category for the Mini Challenge, a racing series in the UK featuring the iconic little hatchback. XCAR tried...
Play video
Sling TV review: Live ESPN, CNN and others for $20 per month is great, but not for everyone
1:47 January 26, 2015
For the price of a cheap dinner, Sling TV "unbundles" traditional cable TV channel lineups with a handful of Internet-delivered channels,...
Play video