Belkin NetCam HD+ Wi-Fi Camera review: Belkin tries for entry-level security camera supremacy
Belkin adds two-way talk and WeMo compatibility to its revamped NetCam HD+, but can this inexpensive Wi-Fi camera steal the show?
Belkin's $130 NetCam HD+ (£130 in the UK, and AU$170 in Australia) is an updated version of the brand's existing NetCam HD. The basic NetCam HD had decent specs already, but Belkin added two-way talk and WeMo product integration to its latest iteration -- these extra features give the new NetCam HD+ Wi-Fi camera a unique edge over other DIY security IPs.
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
While its 720p resolution didn't match the $199 Dropcam Pro's 1080p, it still returned a pretty clear image on both the web and mobile apps (although that could vary depending on your Wi-Fi connection). And, if you spend $10 a month or $100 a year on the optional Cloud+ services, you can save 14 days of clips and receive instant push notifications whenever the built-in motion detector senses activity. Overall, Belkin's $130 NetCam HD+ delivers high-end features at a comparatively affordable price and I think it's a great fit for anyone interested in a solid lower-cost IP camera -- just be prepared to trade some video quality for the HD+'s value.
Curb appeal
The NetCam HD+ has a white finish and is made up of plastic components, with the exception of a small metal joint that connects the camera to its stand. That metal component makes it very easy to adjust the camera angle as needed. While the HD+ doesn't feel as durable as the Dropcam Pro, it is well proportioned and nicely designed -- especially compared with Samsung's top-heavy $189 SmartCam HD Pro .
The box includes the camera, an integrated stand, a power cord, and hardware for optional wall mounting. It has a 95-degree diagonal field of view and a glass lens. Since the $199 Piper security system has a 180-degree glass fish-eye lens, this 95-degree lens isn't particularly impressive. But, that shouldn't be a problem if you want to monitor a smaller room or a particular section of your home or business.
While Belkin's HD+ doesn't have Dropcam Pro-level optics, the local SD card storage of the Samsung SmartCam HD Pro, or the Z-Wave compatibility and additional environmental sensors of Piper, a side-by-side comparison may make you think twice before spending $199 on a Dropcam when you can get something pretty similar for $130.
The HD+ has a speaker and a microphone, free real-time monitoring, night vision, and the option of 14-day cloud storage and motion-related push notifications for an additional $10/month or $100/year. You can also set up rules with Belkin WeMo products on the WeMo app.
Here's a rundown of the NetCam HD+'s options versus the competition:
Belkin NetCam HD+ | Dropcam Pro | Piper | Samsung SmartCam HD Pro | |
Price | $130.00 | $199.00 | $199.00 | $189.00 |
Color | White | Black | White | White |
Field of view (diagonal) | 95 degrees | 130 degrees | 180 degrees | 128 degrees |
Video quality | 1,280x720 | 1,920x1,080 | 1,920x1,080 | 1,920x1,080 |
Cloud storage | Yes, $10/month or $100/year for 14 days | Yes, $10/month or $99/year for 7 days or $30/month or $299/year for 30 days | Yes, saves up to 1,000 clips at no extra cost | No |
Local storage | No, but you can download clips from the Web app | No | No | Yes, SD card |
Glass lens | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Night vision | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Mobile app | Yes, Android and iOS | Yes, Android and iOS | Yes, Android and iOS | Yes, Android and iOS |
Web app | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Bluetooth | No | Yes | No | No |
2-way audio | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Motion and sound alerts | Motion only, and limited to email alerts unless you subscribe to Cloud+. | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Protocol integration | No | No | Yes, Z-Wave | No |
The nitty-gritty
This IP camera was very easy to set up. Basic instructions are included in the box, but the Belkin NetCam Android or iOS app can also guide you from start to finish. The whole process took less than 10 minutes.
It was as simple as plugging in the camera, connecting to the Belkin NetCam Wi-Fi network, and downloading and launching the app. The app immediately recognized the new camera and walked me through registration and final steps.
You can see the name of every camera you have registered on the home screen -- I named mine "Living Room." From there, you can click on the camera and start monitoring live. You can access a handful of different features directly from the video screen. Take a screenshot or a recording of what you see and it will automatically show up in your phone's photo directory. You can also click on the speaker to listen to audio and hold down the microphone button to talk.
There's also a settings section where you can customize your camera a bit more -- change its name, share footage with friends, adjust the sensitivity of the microphone, speaker, and motion detector, opt in to email notifications, and access the optional NetCam Cloud+ Premium services. Email notifications will only send you screenshots of motion activity, so many of you will want to spend the $10/month or $100/year on Cloud+. Fortunately, you can sign up for a free 30-day trial to decide if 14 days of rolling video clip storage, motion-related push notifications, and the ability to permanently save motion-triggered clips as MP4 files are worth it.
Belkin's NetCam HD+ delivered very good performance throughout testing. I received instant push notifications and emails when the camera detected motion. The saved video clips were clearly timestamped for easy access and the live monitoring and related two-way talk features were similarly straightforward.
I did experience periodic lag times and blurry video footage, particularly when someone walked by quickly, but it didn't cause any significant performance issues. I do wish the HD+ could send notifications based on sound like the Dropcam Pro, the Samsung SmartCam HD Pro, and Piper, but I'm willing to accept that this reasonably-priced Wi-Fi camera can't double as a baby monitor.
Currently, the Belkin NetCam app controls the majority of the HD+'s functionality, while the separate WeMo app handles any rules you may want to set up between the HD+ and WeMo devices. I would prefer HD+ access exclusively from the WeMo app, but it wasn't terribly inconvenient. I used the WeMo app to create the rule, "When the camera detects motion, turn on the lamp connected to the WeMo Switch." I didn't experience any issues with it, and as the WeMo line grows , the options for rule customization are sure to expand.
The takeaway
Belkin's $130 NetCam HD+ isn't perfect, but it does a lot when you compare its price with those of some of its competition. For roughly $70 less than the $199 Dropcam Pro and the $199 Piper, and roughly $60 less than the $189 Samsung SmartCam HD Pro, you get decent video footage, WeMo product integration, night vision, and responsive motion alert emails.
If you're concerned about your feed being filtered through Belkin's server, you should probably avoid Cloud-based IP cameras altogether. And if you want audio alerts and a wider-angle lens, consider the $199 Dropcam Pro or the $199 Piper. Otherwise, I would definitely recommend this camera to someone searching for an easy and affordable entry point into home security and home automation.