Best and worst smartphone interfaces

I think we all can agree: however easy or hard it is to get around a phone's software features is just as crucial as its hardware frame. Over the past year, we've covered six mobile operating systems: Android, iOS, Windows Phone 7, BlackBerry OS 6, Symbian 3, and the forthcoming Web OS 2.0. Judging the designs of these interfaces is subjective, so you may not agree with all our points if your phone runs on one of these platforms, but we CNET mobile editors align our views on the following 10 smartphone "skins."

iOS 4

Like: It's almost difficult to recall the days before Apple's iPhone shattered the norm of the shrunken desktop UI (adopted by many a smartphone OS) with its elegantly simple design. Since then, the iPhone 4 has beautifully carried on the tradition of finger-friendly icons on a series of swipable screens with some useful enhancements like a pop-under multitasking bar and folders for grouping similar apps. Rearranging icons can still be cumbersome, but the universal search bar does help find programs (and people) in a sea of apps.

Updated:
Photo by: Josh P. Miller/CNET / Caption by:

Stock Android

Like: Google's unadorned Android looks--without any additions from manufacturers--are still some of our favorite flavors. We called the T-Mobile G1 interface "clean, fun, and easy to use." That also applies to the updated Android UI on the Nexus S (left) and Nexus One (right). These share a Google search bar, intuitive icon controls, and the ability to customize multiple home screens with widgets, shortcuts, and application icons. Live wallpaper keeps things visually interesting. The more recent Nexus S slightly darkens the Nexus One's color scheme and tweaks the virtual keyboard font.

Updated:
Photo by: Josh Miller/CNET / Caption by:

HTC Sense

Like: Google's openness allows for phone manufacturers to lay their interfaces over the Android base, thereby standing out from competitors.

HTC Sense isn't exclusive to Android phones (it's known as known as the TouchFLO, for example, on the HTC Touch Pro2), but it's our favorite manufacturer add-on interface for Android. Shown here on the HTC Evo, Sense has several high-gloss wallpapers, slick widgets, and curved, highly polished navigation bar. It also has it unique Leap screen, a pinch feature that pulls back to show thumbnails of all your home screens. Plus, we love watching animated rain and fog fill the display when you return to the Home screen on inclement days.

Updated:
Photo by: Sarah Tew/CNET / Caption by:

MotoBlur, Droid edition

Like: We prefer Motorola's revised MotoBlur theme to the original, thanks to the rather aggressive Borg metaphor of Verizon's Droid series. Android phones like the Droid X have ditched MotoBlur's colorful, bubbly UI for cleaner, more austere colors and lines among its multiple, Google-given home screens.
Updated:
Photo by: Sarah Tew/CNET / Caption by:

WebOS

Like, but...: The peppy WebOS interface burned brightly, but has mostly faded from view as Palm Pre and Palm Pixi sales declined and Palm struggled for survival. While we liked the gestures, the flexible navigation bar you pull up with your finger, and the Launcher, the OS wasn't intuitive. However, it was inventive.

The forthcoming Palm Pre 2 is the first Palm phone to release under HP's new ownership; it will also premier WebOS 2.0. The update looks promising, with enhanced multitasking and a more powerful universal search "widget" that can also be used to quickly compose texts and update social networking status. But will it be as compelling and eye-catching in its 2011 refresh as it was in its 2009 debut? We won't know until it's in our hands.

Updated:
Photo by: Palm / Caption by:

TouchWiz 3.0

Don't like:Samsung's TouchWiz interface used to elicit groans; we weren't fans of the 2.0 interface with its impossible-to-ignore widgets tray that's still found in smarthpones of yesteryear like the Windows Mobile-run Samsung Omnia II.

However, Samsung has smoothed and finessed the TouchWiz 3.0, at least in terms of Android. On the Samsung Fascinate, for instance, TouchWiz 3.0 ditches the intrusive, pop-out widget tray and adds new social networking widgets. It also uses a grid layout that makes it easy to view applications across multiple, swipable pages. The stock Android phone, on the other hand, requires you to scroll up and down to see apps--albeit using a neat "box" metaphor.) While TouchWiz is much improved, we still prefer the snappier, more polished HTC Sense.

Updated:
Photo by: Sarah Tew/CNET / Caption by:

MotoBlur

Don't like: Motorola's Motoblur has improved since the early days of the Android-running Motorola Cliq (MotoBlur review), where it overwhelmed with its influx of social networking information.

Motorola has toned MotoBlur down by allowing filters for the social "Happenings" widget, something we can appreciate in phones like the Motorola Citrus. Still, we don't love having to sign up for a MotoBlur account, and the interface seems blocky and amateurish compared to smooth operators like HTC's Sense.

Updated:
Photo by: Josh Miller/CNET / Caption by:

Blackberry OS 6

Grudgingly don't like: BlackBerry OS 6 is nimbler than its predecessor, but compared to the sleeker Android and iPhone interfaces, it's one monochromatic clunker. RIM offers few preloaded themes on its flagship BlackBerry Torch, instead expecting you to download alternatives on your own. Larger, finger-friendlier icons and universal search make OS 6 usable, even likable, but the updates just play catch-up with competing smartphones.

True, there is a new navigation bar that lets you swipe sideways to reveal favorite and frequently used apps to name two, plus a new task manager as well, but we couldn't call either one inspired. Don't get us wrong, OS 6 is welcome. We just think RIM could have done a better job shaking things up visually.

Updated:
Photo by: Sarah Tew/CNET / Caption by:

Symbian 3

Don't like: We can't help but sympathize with Nokia, whose share of the mobile market is on the edge of decline for the first time in years as Android and iOS continue making inroads. Symbian 3 takes the Symbian OS in the right direction, we'll give it that, but compared to its lither competitors, the OS (shown here on the Nokia N8) is still clunky and unintuitive.

Updated:
Photo by: Bonnie Cha/CNET / Caption by:

Windows Phone 7

Jury's still out: Microsoft gave us one of the most dramatic mobile overhauls ever when it introduced Windows Phone 7 this past fall. Windows Mobile 6.5 looked like a computer; the new OS looks like a poster.

A very stripped-down Start screen now consists of colorful "live tiles," large icons that represent everything from apps and features to people; some dynamically update with information like missed calls and incoming texts. A second page lists all apps and tiny icons. When you open an app, the "panoramic" interface is also unique and different; it's flexible for developers, but often overlays foreground functions on a background image that spans all the app's swipable screens. There are problems, however, like limited support for landscape mode, especially on that Start screen.

We commend Microsoft for taking a chance on a bold, brash Zune-like design, but not all of us editors connect with the visuals, which almost feel like a throwback with their 2D simplicity. Still, being able to nimbly navigate a powerful phone like the HTC HD7 speaks well of the Windows Phone 7 layout.

Updated:
Photo by: Microsoft / Caption by:
Hot Galleries

Last-minute gift ideas

Under pressure? These will deliver on time

With plenty of top-notch retailers offering digital gifts, you still have time to salvage your gift-giving reputation.

Hot Products