X

AI or Not AI: Can You Spot the Real Photos?

Take a look at these images and see if you can tell which are "fake."

James Martin
James Martin is the Managing Editor of Photography at CNET. His photos capture technology's impact on society - from the widening wealth gap in San Francisco, to the European refugee crisis and Rwanda's efforts to improve health care. From the technology pioneers of Google and Facebook, photographing Apple's Steve Jobs and Tim Cook, Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg and Google's Sundar Pichai, to the most groundbreaking launches at Apple and NASA, his is a dream job for any documentary photography and journalist with a love for technology. Exhibited widely, syndicated and reprinted thousands of times over the years, James follows the people and places behind the technology changing our world, bringing their stories and ideas to life.
James Martin
firefly-beautiful-utah-mountains-in-the-distance-hot-springs-in-the-foreground-63804.jpg
1 of 17 CNET

What is real? Well, sometimes it's hard to tell.

As the images we see online become increasingly manipulated, the difference between an AI-manufactured image and a "real" photograph is increasingly hard to discern.

Take a look at the images in this gallery and see if you can spot the real from the fake. The answer will be in the caption for the subsequent photo. For instance, we'll tell you about the image above in the caption for the photo that follows, and so on.

Scroll on and see how you do.

Also see our in-depth feature story: How Close Is That Photo to the Truth? What to Know in the Age of AI

Editors' note: CNET is using an AI engine to help create some stories. For more, see this post.

death-valley-national-park-7302-16-9
2 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 1: The image of a dawn marine layer of fog hovering in a valley was AI-generated.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 2.

apple-091217-steve-jobs-theater-3858.jpg
3 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 2:  Though smooth and painterly, the desert landscape is an actual photograph taken at Zabriskie Point in Death Valley National Park, California.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 3.

firefly-a-portrait-of-a-tourist-couple-in-foggy-san-francisco-on-vacation-in-casual-clothing-backpa.jpg
4 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 3: It may look like an awkward composite, but the image of people milling about in a glass-walled building interior, taken through the windows above Apple's Steve Jobs Theater in Cupertino, California, is a real photograph.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 4.

outside-lands-2015-classixx-0054.jpg
5 of 17

Answer for photo 4:  It looks like a believable-enough visit to foggy San Francisco, but the image of the couple in front of the Golden Gate bridge was AI-generated.

Notice the image's confusion in the details of the textures on the straps of his backpack, and some problems with the continuity of the lanyard.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 5.

firefly-a-candid-shot-of-a-group-of-friends-eating-at-a-restaurant-in-the-city-one-person-taking-a.jpg
6 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 5: The image of an enthusiastic crowd at a Classixx show at the Outside Lands music festival in San Francisco in 2015 is a real photograph.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 6.

firefly-a-portrait-of-a-rugged-man-in-his-30s-camping-out-in-the-woods-and-his-dog-enjoying-nature.jpg
7 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 6: At first glance, it may look normal and real, but the image of three woman at a cafe was AI-generated. 

Notice the two awkwardly placed pink-tipped fingers poking from behind the arm in the foreground. Also, the woman in the center has a jumbled hand, as does the woman on the right.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 7.

jamesco-smiling-old-woman-seated-on-thailand-beach-hut-bar-kaya-fe426fc8-3238-4b40-bf5c-45d212e0a1ca.png
8 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 7: It's very cute, but the image of a man and his dog at a campsite was AI-generated. 

Check out some of the image's problems in the man's fingers and his watch and around the dog's tongue. 

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 8.

storied-greece-photos-0640
9 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 8: The image of a smiling Japanese woman at a tiki hut on a beach in Thailand was AI-generated. 

Notice her awkward and elongated arm and fingers.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 9.

firefly-avocado-toast-on-a-plate-fresh-baked-bread-beautiful-presentation-in-a-trendy-restaurant-1.jpg
10 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 9: The image of a mother and son at a refugee camp in Thessaloniki, Greece, is a real photograph.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 10.

img-0738.jpg
11 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 10: The delicious-looking avocado toast on the dark stoneware plate is nearly perfect, and also AI-generated. 

Notice the strange form of the lime on the left, and the just too perfect texture of the crust.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 11.

firefly-brand-new-wireless-headphones-made-out-wood-on-a-textured-concrete-surface-85428.jpg
12 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 11: On the other hand, the tasty-looking avocado toast on the white paper plate is real food, and a real image.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 12.

firefly-brand-new-wireless-headphones-made-out-of-metallic-material-laid-out-neatly-on-a-black-tabl-1.jpg
13 of 17

Answer for photo 12: Although it is a pretty convincing product shot, the image of the wooden headphones was AI-generated. The textures are flat and lifeless, and the image overall reads more like a 2D rendering than a photograph.

I'd be tempted to buy a pair of them, though! 

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 13.

dr-jamesco-buzzkill-90s-attitude-teen-girl-white-trash-crop-top-b136ea9d-6afb-4ec2-bf7b-3511e2173c92.png
14 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 13:  The gray headphones, too, are 100% AI-generated.

I find this one very hard to discern. The lighting is very good, but the dimensions of the band look off.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 14.

img-0515
15 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 14: Although the image of the young woman on a bench is a fantastic, well-lit "portrait," it too was AI-generated.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 15.

jamesco-smooth-rocky-shore-along-lake-tahoe-clear-aqua-marine-w-9dc9b2cb-218a-443d-b36b-1726e80c8d04.png
16 of 17 CNET

Answer for photo 15: The image of the skier standing in the freshly fallen powder in Mott Canyon at Heavenly Resort in Lake Tahoe, Nevada, is a real photograph.

Scroll down to the next caption to find out about photo 16.

img-9842.jpg
17 of 17

Answer for photo 16: The image of the rocky lakeshore, though very much looking like the eastern shore of Lake Tahoe, was AI-generated.

Answer for photo 17: This final image, however, is a 100% real photograph of Lake Tahoe taken in Incline Village, Nevada.

So how'd you do?

More Galleries

My Favorite Shots From the Galaxy S24 Ultra's Camera
A houseplant

My Favorite Shots From the Galaxy S24 Ultra's Camera

20 Photos
Honor's Magic V2 Foldable Is Lighter Than Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra
magic-v2-2024-foldable-1383

Honor's Magic V2 Foldable Is Lighter Than Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra

10 Photos
The Samsung Galaxy S24 and S24 Plus Looks Sweet in Aluminum
Samsung Galaxy S24

The Samsung Galaxy S24 and S24 Plus Looks Sweet in Aluminum

23 Photos
Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra Now Has a Titanium Design
The Galaxy S24 Ultra in multiple colors

Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra Now Has a Titanium Design

23 Photos
I Took 600+ Photos With the iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max. Look at My Favorites
img-0368.jpg

I Took 600+ Photos With the iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max. Look at My Favorites

34 Photos
17 Hidden iOS 17 Features You Should Definitely Know About
Invitation for the Apple September iPhone 15 event

17 Hidden iOS 17 Features You Should Definitely Know About

18 Photos
AI or Not AI: Can You Spot the Real Photos?
img-1599-2.jpg

AI or Not AI: Can You Spot the Real Photos?

17 Photos