Does Ring really reduce crime?

Security Cameras
I'm sure you've seen one of these commercials on TV or heard this selling point from Amazon's ring. To prove that the LAPD that having 10% of the homes of the rings were able to reduce crime by 50% and neighborhood. Preventing crime and making neighborhoods safer is a huge selling point for ring and a big reason why police departments work with the video doorbell company. But does it actually do what they claim it does? [MUSIC] To figure out the answer we obtained property crime records from three of Rings earliest partners Green Bay, Wisconsin, Aurora, Illinois and Fort Lauderdale, Florida. We then showed the data to crime analyst and spoke to the police department on how much safer Ring is actually made these neighborhoods The answer? There's almost no evidence to back up Rings claimed, I'll explain later, but first let's take a trip back to 2015. Ring has rested its claim that it reduces crime in neighborhoods from a study that it conducted in Los Angeles back in 2015, where it claims that it's video doorbells reduce burglaries by 55% in six months. Here's ring CEO Jamie Simon off repeating that claim after Amazon purchased the company. So we did a study with the LAPD where with 10% of the homes having rain, we were able to reduce crime by 55% in this controlled area, but the MIT Technology Review found that this was not the case. It was actually 42% over 10 months. And while that's still a decent drop, it did not last for long as that same neighborhood saw most burglaries in seven years within a year after that study. Despite that, Ring has constantly referred to this study using it as a way to convince hundreds of police departments to partner with them. This study is referenced in Ring's emails with police. And in contracts for these partnerships, it starts with Ring wants to help reduce crime and increase safety. So how has it worked out for these police departments? Well, let's ask them. This is from the Green Bay police department which was the 34th department in the US to sign up in August 2018. In 2019, we saw a 6% decrease in property crime there is no causation with the ring partnership. Here's Fort Lauderdale Police Department, rings third police partner. We cannot attribute a change in the number of property crimes solely to ring. As it is only one of the many tools we use to investigate unsolved crimes. And here's Aurora police rings 32nd police partner. I can't put numbers on it specifically if it works or if it doesn't reduce crime. Here's the thing, ring can point at annual crime statistics and say, Look, we are reducing crime. If you look at the FBI crime statistics, it'll show you that property crime has decreased in the time that ring came onto the market. That's awesome, right? But let's zoom out a little more and see the FBI is property crime rate from 30 years ago. Look at that property crime has been steadily decreasing every year from 1991 to 2014. Crime analysts know that looking at annual statistics is not an effective measure. So we decided to get a closer look and get data for monthly statistics. We requested for monthly data from the year before the ring partnerships began and the year after, this is what it looked like. This is a chart for Aurora Steph Curry The blue line on this chart represents before the ring partnership and the red line represents the year after. While it's lower because crime overall has been reducing for decades. Look at that parallel between the two lines. It indicates that crime rates follow the same trend over the year spiking and decreasing at almost the same time. Here's the theft rate in Green Bay, Wisconsin where it's not as parallel. But you can see the same fluctuation dropping in the winter and rising in the summer, just like it did the year before the ring partnership again. And in Fort Lauderdale, we actually saw that that's increased after the ring partnership, going from an average of three hundred and sixty nine thefts a month to three hundred and eighty two thefts a month, the next year. Does this mean that rings police partnerships are actually increasing crime? Absolutely not. But it does not support rings claims that it's making neighborhoods safer either. So why aren't police departments and crime analysts as quick to say that ring is reducing crimes as Amazon has been for the last two years. Probably because they're experts on the subject. There are many reasons why crime rates change. And they can be as complicated as, how long have the neighbours lived in the area for two simple reasons. Like, how much did it rain that year? Thieves don't like to get Get wet and the property crime rate drops significantly when the weather is bad. A lot of outside factors like population size and income contributes to changes in crime rates as well. This is not to say that ring does not solve crimes or does not make neighborhoods safer. Its video doorbells have footage that have caught criminals. But there is a big difference between what ring shows off and having an impact on the overall crime rate. [MUSIC] Public safety is frequently used as a justification for surveillance and has been rings main selling point for years. And while ring has drastically ramped up how often people are being watched, it doesn't necessarily provide that safety trade off that it's promised [MUSIC]

Up Next

Nest Cam with battery is smart and unsurprising
nest-cam-review30

Up Next

Nest Cam with battery is smart and unsurprising

Nest Doorbell with battery is an impressive wireless effort from Google
nest-doorbell-battery-review-10

Nest Doorbell with battery is an impressive wireless effort from Google

The Ring 4 is competent, but it can't beat Arlo
ring-doorbell-4-10

The Ring 4 is competent, but it can't beat Arlo

How much does it cost to spy on your neighbors? Apparently, $5 a month (The Daily Charge, 1/30/2020)
dc1302020thumb

How much does it cost to spy on your neighbors? Apparently, $5 a month (The Daily Charge, 1/30/2020)

Amazon Ring adds Stick Up and indoor cameras
amazon-stickupcam

Amazon Ring adds Stick Up and indoor cameras

Police have your Ring footage. They're not the only ones looking at it
cms-clip2-00-00-54-07-still001

Police have your Ring footage. They're not the only ones looking at it

Ring's partnership with police means more false alarms
screen-shot-2019-07-31-at-1-06-29-pm

Ring's partnership with police means more false alarms

Amazon's Ring cameras are building out surveillance for police (The 3:59, Ep. 566)
359566c

Amazon's Ring cameras are building out surveillance for police (The 3:59, Ep. 566)

Your Ring camera could be a part of a police surveillance network
screen-shot-2019-06-05-at-12-29-07-pm

Your Ring camera could be a part of a police surveillance network

Tech Shows

The Apple Core
apple-core-w

The Apple Core

Alphabet City
alphabet-city-w

Alphabet City

CNET Top 5
cnet-top-5-w

CNET Top 5

The Daily Charge
dc-site-1color-logo.png

The Daily Charge

What the Future
what-the-future-w

What the Future

Tech Today
tech-today-w

Tech Today

Latest News All latest news

Google's Monk Skin Tone Scale: What Is It?
inclusive-schema-0509-anuyk5h-max-1000x1000.png

Google's Monk Skin Tone Scale: What Is It?

The Revolution R270 Is a Smart Toaster With a Screen
revolution-toaster-orange-promo

The Revolution R270 Is a Smart Toaster With a Screen

2023 Nissan Z First Drive: A Hotter Performer With Newfound Tech Smarts
nissan-z-2023-first-drive-holdingstill-cms

2023 Nissan Z First Drive: A Hotter Performer With Newfound Tech Smarts

Driving Porsche's Top-Secret Prototype Electric Race Car!
gt4-e-perf-still

Driving Porsche's Top-Secret Prototype Electric Race Car!

How an EV Works
how-evs-work-00-04-48-14-still089

How an EV Works

Facebook Accused of Blocking News in Australia, Plants Can Grow in Lunar Soil
facebook.png

Facebook Accused of Blocking News in Australia, Plants Can Grow in Lunar Soil

Most Popular All most popular

Apple Killed the Last iPod
1202263987086163-e66zgtdhxmkf0nentynj-height640.png

Apple Killed the Last iPod

The Best Way to Charge Your EV Is at Your House
home-chargers-copy-01-00-05-49-18-still089

The Best Way to Charge Your EV Is at Your House

Black Hole Image Revealed, Meta's Next Headset Teased
tt-051322-00-00-20-12-still020

Black Hole Image Revealed, Meta's Next Headset Teased

2023 Nissan Z First Drive: A Hotter Performer With Newfound Tech Smarts
nissan-z-2023-first-drive-holdingstill-cms

2023 Nissan Z First Drive: A Hotter Performer With Newfound Tech Smarts

Do You Know What It Really Costs to Drive an Electric Car?
hidden-costs-of-evs-00-11-54-12-still088

Do You Know What It Really Costs to Drive an Electric Car?

TikTok Creators Will Love the DJI Mini 3 Pro
dji-5

TikTok Creators Will Love the DJI Mini 3 Pro

Latest Products All latest products

Hands-On: We Got to Try the Sony Xperia 1 IV and Its Zoom Lens
xperiafinalpicsite

Hands-On: We Got to Try the Sony Xperia 1 IV and Its Zoom Lens

Lenovo Legion 7 Gaming Laptops Combine Great Power With Simple, Slim Designs
lenovolegion-00-00-45-13-still003

Lenovo Legion 7 Gaming Laptops Combine Great Power With Simple, Slim Designs

Exploring Meta Store: Facebook Parent Meta's First Physical Retail Space
metastore

Exploring Meta Store: Facebook Parent Meta's First Physical Retail Space

Lenovo's Torrent of Slim-Series Laptops Has Almost Too Many Options
lenovoslim-00-00-03-10-still001.png

Lenovo's Torrent of Slim-Series Laptops Has Almost Too Many Options

Disney's New Wristband Brings Games to Theme Parks
magic-band-plus-1-copy

Disney's New Wristband Brings Games to Theme Parks

Amazon Astro Review: An Echo of the Future
astro-review-still-10

Amazon Astro Review: An Echo of the Future

Latest How To All how to videos

Google Pay: How to Set Up and Use
googlepay-inhand

Google Pay: How to Set Up and Use

Clean Your AirPods and EarPods Without Damaging Them
yt-howto-clean-airpods-v3

Clean Your AirPods and EarPods Without Damaging Them

How to Control Your Computer With Your Feet
yt-learn-guitar-foot-controls-v2

How to Control Your Computer With Your Feet

How to Download YouTube Videos
yt-howto-download-yt-videos-v3

How to Download YouTube Videos

Find Forgotten Wi-Fi Passwords for Previously Used Networks
how-to-find-a-wi-fi-password-on-any-network-1

Find Forgotten Wi-Fi Passwords for Previously Used Networks

Get the Most Out of Multitouch on Your Trackpad
mac-tips-multitouch-on-mac-7

Get the Most Out of Multitouch on Your Trackpad