CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again

Christmas Gift Guide

The reigning champ

The challenger

Hue 3.0

Better greens

Comparison time

Beyond the bulb

Lifx Z

Floodlights, too

Hue Go

Hue Beyond

Motion sensor

Switches, too

Hue's platform

Tricky bulbs

See for yourself

Let's talk apps

Scheduled lighting changes

Windows app

IFTTT compatibility

Lifx for the win

Amazon Alexa compatibility

Other integrations

Hue works with Siri

Winner: Lifx

If you're thinking of splurging on color-changing options, your top two options are Philips Hue (left) and Lifx (right). Both are well-developed product lines with multiple generations of hardware under their belts, both have the color-changing smarts you're likely looking for and both are still really expensive.

That means if you're thinking about buying in, you'll want to be sure to choose wisely. In that spirit, here's a smart home showdown between the two -- which color-changing bulb comes out on top?

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Our first color-changing contender: the Lifx Wi-Fi LED. A year ago, we called the second-gen Lifx Color 1000 LED the best color-changing bulb money can buy, but a lot's changed since then. Its new, third-gen bulbs are even brighter than before, with a starting price of $60 a piece (about £45/AU$80).

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

In the other corner: Philips Hue. It's the biggest name in color-changing bulbs, and a legitimate smart home heavyweight, complete with Siri-friendly Apple HomeKit compatibility. And, like Lifx, it now boasts new and improved third-gen bulbs.

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Those new third-gen Hue bulbs claim brighter, bolder colors than before.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

The most notable improvement? More accurate shades of green. The old Hue bulbs could barely muster anything greener than a tennis ball-looking shade of yellow. With generation three, that's fixed.

Caption by / Photo by Chris Monroe/CNET

Here are those new third-gen bulbs in a head-to-head challenge. That's Hue on the left and Lifx on the right, and at every shade we tested, Lifx was the brighter option.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

Both brands offer more than just bulbs. Take these Philips Hue Lightstrips, for instance.

Caption by / Photo by Philips

Lifx has light strips, too. You can even program them to put out multiple colors at once.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

Both brands offer floodlight options for recessed light fixtures, too.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

Philips has the wider range of offerings. Take the battery-powered, cereal bowl shaped Philips Hue Go, for instance. Lifx doesn't offer anything like it.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

The same goes for Philips' Hue Beyond light fixtures.

Caption by

Philips also offers a number of control accessories that Lifx can't match. The most recent? This Philips Hue Motion Sensor.

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Philips also offers stick-up smart switches that can pair with multiple bulbs at once. Lifx doesn't offer anything of the sort.

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

On top of that, Philips Hue is a very strong lighting platform in its own right. It works with just about anything, it can control third party Zigbee bulbs and it also offers $15 white light smart bulbs (roughly £10, AU$20), making it relatively inexpensive to build out your lighting setup.

Caption by / Photo by Ry Crist/CNET

Lifx has a few unique tricks up its sleeve, though. Its newest bulb, the Lifx Plus LED, puts out invisible infrared light when the bulb is switched off. Why would you want that? Why, to help your night vision cameras see in the dark, of course!

Caption by

The CNET Smart Apartment's night vision camera feed in the middle of the night, with and without a Lifx Plus screwed into the lamp in the back of the room. To the camera, it looks as if the lamp is on.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshots by Ry Crist/CNET

The Lifx and Philips Hue apps take different approaches to the way you select colors. The Lifx color wheels are more precise and easier to use.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshots by Ry Crist/CNET

Both apps will let you create scheduled lighting changes. Philips has a more polished look, but the Lifx controls go a little deeper.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshots by Ry Crist/CNET

Beyond the Android and iOS apps, Lifx also offers an app for Windows devices.

Caption by / Photo by Lifx

Both Lifx and Hue are compatible with the free online automation service, IFTTT. Sync up with IFTTT and you'll be able to trigger either bulb using a wide variety of compatible products as well as services.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshot by Ry Crist/CNET

Of the two IFTTT integrations, Lifx is more powerful. Just take a look at this "Turn on lights" actions for Philips Hue and Lifx LEDs: the Lifx controls go a lot deeper.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshots by Ry Crist/CNET

Both bulbs are also compatible with Amazon's Alexa for voice-activated lighting changes. Lifx gets a slight edge here, because it offers a custom Alexa skill that can change the colors of your bulbs. With Hue, you can only turn bulbs on and off or dim them up and down.

Caption by / Photo by Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Aside from the more major integrations, both bulbs do a good job of offering compatibility with a wide number of smaller smart home gadgets. They'll both work with the Beddi Smart Alarm Clock, for instance.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshots by Ry Crist/CNET

However, Hue strikes back with a huge feather in its cap: Apple HomeKit compatibility. That lets you control the bulbs -- including the colors -- using Siri commands. Lifx can't do that, at least not until February, when newly announced HomeKit-compatible Lifx bulbs will hit the market. Until then, advantage: Hue.

Caption by / Photo by Screenshot by Ry Crist/CNET

Still, our overall winner remains the same, and that's the Lifx Wi-Fi LED. It's much brighter than Philips Hue at every key setting, and the colors look fantastic. It also boasts the slightly better app, along with deeper integrations with IFTTT and Alexa. And, since the bulbs connect directly with your home network over Wi-Fi, you don't need a hub, which makes it an easier option to get started with than Philips Hue. If you can forgive the lack of HomeKit compatibility (at least until February), Lifx is the best color-changing bulb on the market.

Caption by / Photo by Chris Monroe/CNET
Published:
Up Next
The 15 coolest things you can do wi...
21