CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again

Christmas Gift Guide
Services

Taking Web services in stride

A News.com reader says he knows the practical problems inherent in Web services implementation, and it's too early to count the chickens before they hatch.

 

  
Taking Web services in stride

In response to the March 21 Perspectives column by Ravi Razdan, "Web services: Security nightmare?":

I couldn't agree with Razdan more. I represented UDDI (Universal Description, Discovery and Integration)/Web services standards for a Fortune 100 company for a year, and I know the practical problems inherent in Web services implementation.

First, there are no sample business registrations at the service-offering level (called green pages) in UDDI yet. Most registrations are white- and yellow-page level. Second, security is a neglected aspect of Web services. There is no true interoperability in Web services yet, because propagating security context and transaction context across Web services is only a dream today. In addition, secure and reliable messaging is not an agreed-upon standard among ebXML, RosettaNet and W3C standards bodies, and many flavors are possible, which leads to confusion.

Most people think that SOAP solves interoperability problems. It doesn't. Interoperability is about contextual propagation of transaction, security, semantics and so on. SOAP is just a messaging protocol in XML-RPC flavor providing communication across heterogeneous systems.

Web services also do not address the "connect and transact" phase of service-to-service interactions. It is today only about registering and discovering Web services. The last mile--connect and transact--is a big step and is loaded with challenges. So let us not count the chickens so soon.

Ravi Balakrishnan
Sunnyvale, Calif.

 

 

    
Latest Headlines
display on desktop
Sonicblue taps Amazon to sell new DVR
Proposed anti-piracy bill draws fire
eBay antitrust probe closed
Travelocity levies fee on United tickets
Cisco may cash in on spending rebound
Intel unrolls Blueprints program
IBM, Mayo to diagnose medical data
Techs turbulent over stock-option bill
Start-up adds depth to 3D imaging
Java brewers to stir Web services pot
McAfee.com spurns buyout bid
Sun's Java jigsaw
The goal: Sun looks for payoff to Java addiction
Gamers helping specialty PCs thrive
The brains behind the DVD
Court to hear Net filtering challenge
Show time for new video compression
NEC plans to raise PC prices
Game creators tackle ethical issues
This week's headlines