Live: Amazon Event Wednesday Probe Crashes Into Asteroid Prime Day 2: Oct. 11-12 Tesla AI Day Hurricane Ian Satellite Images Save on iPad Pro Refurbs Apple Watch Ultra Review EarthLink Internet Review
Want CNET to notify you of price drops and the latest stories?
No, thank you

White House pulls e-mail for 'fishy' reports

Say good-bye to ""--it's been deactivated and messages bounce back, a win for critics comparing it to an "enemies list" and surveillance program.

On August 4, White House aide Macon Phillips announced the launch of, which encouraged Americans to report "fishy" information related to the Obama health care proposal. Phillips' announcement was titled "Facts Are Stubborn Things."

Well, so is public opinion, as the White House acknowledged on Monday by quietly pulling the plug on the e-mail address.

Messages sent there are now bounced back with this response:

<>: host[] said: 550 5.2.1 <>... The email address you just sent a message to is no longer in service.We are now accepting your feedback about health insurance reform via: (in reply to RCPT TO command

The "Reality Check" Web page on doesn't encourage reporting misinformation to Washington, D.C.; instead, it features some videos about President Obama's proposal. There is an option to submit comments, but the Web form stresses "Please refrain from submitting any individual's personal information, including their e-mail address, without their permission."

That's almost the opposite of the original program, which had no obvious privacy safeguards--and which became the focus of spirited criticism over the last two weeks.

Sen. John Cornyn, a Texas Republican, wrote in a letter to the president that: "I am not aware of any precedent for a president asking American citizens to report their fellow citizens to the White House for pure political speech that is deemed 'fishy' or otherwise inimical to the White House's political interests."

Cornyn wasn't alone. On his radio program, Glenn Beck dubbed an "enemies list," and talk show host Rush Limbaugh characterized it as "Obama's own exclusive private domestic spying program." A t-shirt saying "REPORT ME" has appeared, and some conservatives mocked it by reporting themselves to the White House on grounds they were spreading "disinformation" by criticizing the Democratic health care legislation.

This hasn't been a very good month for the White House and its attempts to use e-mail communications. Earlier on Monday, the White House changed its e-mail sign-up procedures so make sure that people won't get spammed.