Hands-on with iTunes 8 Genius: Einstein with dementia?

iTunes 8's Genius playlist feature is impressive, but if you listen to music containing nothing but opera singers screaming and giggling, you're not going to have as much fun as we did

Nate Lanxon Special to CNET News
3 min read

For us, the most interesting part of iTunes 8 is the Genius feature. Not because it's essentially a new way of selling you stuff from the iTunes Store. But because if you have a massive library of music, it seems to be a fun way of rediscovering music you already have, even if it is pretty similar to what Last.fm has been doing for ages.

One way we've achieved this before is by using the Smart Playlist feature of iTunes. It's easy to tell iTunes to create a playlist of, say, 25 rock songs that you've heard at least five times (so you must at least enjoy each track), but that haven't been played for at least two months. Click OK and boom -- automatic playlist created.

Genius takes this one step further in a different direction, adds automation, and allows you to create these custom playlists on the new iPods. And in our tests it appeared to work fairly well -- you select a track you like, click the Genius button, and you're given a playlist of songs similar to your source track.

We started off our test with Adenosine Buildup by Blotted Science -- an extremely complex experimental metal song, full of changing time signatures, unpredictable tempo changes and an erratic song structure. The Genius playlist generated from this included songs from Dream Theater, The Dillinger Escape Plan, Necrophagist and Meshuggah -- all metal bands with songs containing fast, extremely technical songwriting, frantic time-signature changes and unusual composition.

Next we chose as our source track a song by Japanese pop artist Ai Otsuka. Not only did Genius build a playlist of similar songs, but it also pulled in other Japanese pop songs from the likes of Bonnie Pink, Do As Infinity, Tokyo Jihen and Hitomi Yaida.

A playlist based on a Will Smith track contained Black Eyed Peas, 50 Cent and The Streets; based on punk band NOFX we got a playlist of punk from The Offspring, Blink 182 and The Distillers, among others; and based on Puncture Wound Massacre by Cannibal Corpse we got 25 songs from the likes of Decapitated, Deicide, The Black Dahlia Murder and Nile.

All very impressive. But Genius isn't idiot-proof, and we did manage to break it...

Trying to create a playlist of music based on any track from Shakira's 1998 album Dónde Están los Ladrones? resulted in an error message. This is probably a teething issue, but it's not as if Shakira's a niche selection, is it?

Moving on from this, we succeeded at deliberately confusing Genius. We took as our source track a song by the modern Italian composer Luciano Berio. His 1965 track Sequenza III For Woman's Voice involved giving a trained female opera singer music written not with musical notes, but with squiggles, random words, giggles and screams, all written on musical manuscript paper.

It's an incredibly interesting piece of music (although it actually contains no music other than one female voice), but one that the iTunes Genius failed to suggest compatible songs for. So if you like bizarre, experimental modern operatics, expect to experience a rather stupid Genius.

We'll be keeping regular checks on how well Genius performs as more people use it. But for now it's being marked as useful, intuitive and fun, but understandably underwhelming for anyone who doesn't have much music, or who has lots of music from only a small selection of genres or styles.

Try it yourself by downloading it for free from Apple.com. -Nate Lanxon