Crossovers

BMW recalls 106,000 X1 crossovers for B-pillar problems

A remedy is still being cooked up.

Must be nice, realizing that a company you trusted to run a proper engineering analysis actually didn't.

Marc Ganley/Roadshow

There are countless regulations to which vehicles must adhere, and even something seemingly innocuous like a missing sticker could force an automaker to issue a recall. BMW's latest recall is for one such compliance issue.

BMW has issued a recall for 106,182 examples of the 2016-2019 X1 crossover in both sDrive28i and xDrive28i trims. The vehicles carry build dates between March 10, 2015 and May 2, 2019.

The issue comes from the B-pillar, which is the body pillar between the front and rear rows. According to BMW, federal regulations require these pillars to meet a specific head injury criterion (HIC) value, which measures the likelihood of a head injury from a specific impact. The automaker says one of the four target points it measured returned a HIC value above the legal limit, rendering the B-pillar out of federal compliance. That means there's a greater likelihood of injury in certain types of crashes.

BMW found this issue after running internal tests and discovering the high HIC value in the next-generation X1, even though the B-pillar is supposed to be unchanged between the current generation and its successor. As it turns out, the engineering company that ran the compliance testing in 2015 for the current X1 didn't consider "the worst-case head-form positioning," as BMW put it in NHTSA's recall documents. As a result, BMW decided to conduct a voluntary recall, since that flub meant that a whole bunch of old (and new) cars don't actually conform to that one specific federal regulation.

Thankfully, BMW has not received any reports of injuries or accidents related to the problem. As for a fix, well, BMW is still figuring out how to remedy the issue. That said, the automaker promised that owners would receive recall notifications via first-class mail in early July.