2014 Maserati Ghibli S Q4 review:

Maserati sport sedan is good, but only if you're already craving Italian

Autoplay: ON Autoplay: OFF
  • 1
View full gallery

Roadshow Editors' Rating

7.6 Overall
  • Performance 8
  • Features 6
  • Design 9
  • Media & Connectivity 7

The Good The Maserati Touch Control system in the 2014 Ghibli S Q4 is easy to use and features a wide range of digital audio sources. The twin-turbo V-6 engine makes a great, almost exotic sound while delivering great acceleration. The Ghibli is a gorgeous, low slung sedan.

The Bad The Bowers and Wilkins premium stereo is hampered by rattling door panels. Over rough roads, the suspension can feel a bit darty. The Maser's available tech pales in comparison to that of its rivals.

The Bottom Line The 2014 Maserati Ghibli S Q4 is a more approachable, affordable Maserati, but at this price point it both loses a bit of its mystique, and faces some very stiff competition.

Maserati are a mystery to many; not quite sports cars, not quite luxo barges. They match Ferrari engineering with plush amenities and a ride better suited for city streets than the racetrack. You don't see Masers every day and when you do see a Gran Turismo S prowling the boulevard, it's a treat.

The Ghibli is the lowest priced model in Maserati's lineup and, as the entry point into the brand, has a broader appeal than other Maserati models. The 2014 Maserati S Q4 is the most powerful example of the model. However, after a couple hundred miles behind the wheel, the approachable nature of the Ghibli reveals itself as, well, just another luxury sport sedan, albeit a $100,000 sport sedan, and that sort of ruins the mystique for me.

For some drivers, the trident badge is desirable because it's so mysterious. Antuan Goodwin/CNET

Maserati Touch Control

The Maserati Touch Control (MTC) navigation and infotainment system is clearly a reskinned Chrysler Uconnect system -- thanks to the Fiat Chrysler Automotive merger -- which was at first glance a disappointment. However, not all Uconnect systems are created equally and this is one of the good ones. This example uses a large 8.4-inch screen and the latest generation of Garmin's mapping and routing software. The touchscreen is responsive and with so much real estate, the virtual buttons are easy to hit without devoting too much attention. Glare, however, can be a bit of an issue.

The turn-by-turn navigation system takes traffic data into account when choosing routes and rerouting, and every now and then you'll hear the slightly robotic voice chime in to let you know that there's, for example, a 15-minute delay or that it's potentially saving you 10 minutes by routing around traffic. The navigation menus are simple and have been redesigned with gorgeous new graphics and the maps are crisply and colorfully rendered on the large screen. Single-step voice-activated address input allows the driver to state the full address from street number to state rather than slogging through multiple prompts, which is a good thing.

The MTC infotainment system is clearly a reskin of Chysler's Uconnect system, but that's not a bad thing. Antuan Goodwin/CNET

Along the bottom of the screen are large virtual button shortcuts to hands-free phone controls (which also reads SMS text messages via text-to-speech), climate controls, seat heat and cooling controls, and the audio sources.

The source list includes a single-slot CD player, Bluetooth audio streaming, USB connectivity, a 3.5mm analog auxiliary input, and satellite and terrestrial radio. Though using the Uconnect underpinnings, MTC does not feature any Uconnect app integration. It does, however, support in-car Wi-Fi hotspot, but that's an optional feature that was not present on our tester.

Audio plays through a an optional $5,100 Bowers and Wilkins sound system with 15 speakers made of lightweight and strong kevlar and aluminum and 1,280 watts of amplification. I'm sure that the system sounds great if you don't listen to anything with strong bass. If you do, the Ghibli's door panels quickly reveal themselves as a weak point, distorting the sound with panel rattle and annoying buzzing which at best sucks all of the magic out of owning an audiophile system and at worst makes the audio sound just terrible. Lowering the bass levels doesn't really do much to help, so I ended up adjusting the kind of music that I played while motoring to avoid electronica, pop, and hip-hop. I shouldn't have to do that with a $5,100 stereo.

Engine by Ferrari

Under the hood, you won't find some exotic V-10 engine; this is the inexpensive Maser, remember. Instead you'll find a Ferrari-built 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged V-6 engine. The engine is available in two tunes: our Ghibli S Q4 model is the most powerful of the two at 404 horsepower and 406 pound-feet of torque, but there's also the 345 horsepower, 369 pound-foot base Ghibli model to consider. Both vehicles put power through an eight-speed ZF automatic transmission (one of the best examples of a torque converter automatic on the road).

The S Q4 distinguishes itself from the base model with its all-wheel-drive system versus the standard rear-drive setup. The system is a power-on-demand type that sends 100 percent of available torque to the rear wheels when cruising, but can shift up to 50 percent to the front axle when needed (for example, when launching). This on-demand setup and the differential's programming allows the Maser to keep a slightly sporty rear-bias under most cornering situations, but kept it from hanging the tail out around bends. It's a gripper not a drifter.

The Ghibli features paddle shifters mounted to the steering column like a Ferrari's -- not on the wheel, like many sport sedans -- and which engage with a satisfying ka-chink at every flick of a gear change. The power train can be manually shifted at any time, but also features a full Manual mode that will prevent it from reverting to its automatic program. Speaking of programs, the Ghibli has three drive settings. There's the Normal setting, but you can also choose a more aggressive Sport mode that tweaks the transmission for crisper shifts higher in the power band, remaps the throttle to be more twitchy, and opens an exhaust valve for more engine noise when accelerating.

Maserati's 3.0-liter twin-turbo V-6 was built by Ferrari and outputs over 400 ponies. Antuan Goodwin/CNET

The exhaust note is slightly hollow and raspy when in its sportiest setting. Hold the revs high and slap for a shift and the not goes just a bit raw for a moment while the revs drop. It's almost the opposite of a Jaguar's characteristic deep snarl, but no less impressive or aggressive.

The third power train setting is called I.C.E. which stands for Increased Control and Efficiency mode, which is much catchier than calling it the, more accurate, Reduced Throttle Sensitivity mode. Basically, it operates like every other car's ECO mode, adjusting the engine and transmission for quieter performance and more efficiency. This mode sucks almost all of the fun out of the Ghibli S Q4's performance, making the car feel more hesitant, heavy, and lazy, but should help the driver do better than the 12.5 mpg that we averaged during our testing.

Part sports, part luxe

The Ghibli's performance sits somewhere between a darty sports coupe and a heavy luxury sedan, which ends up making your first few trips feeling a bit weird. Not bad, just weird.

This week on Roadshow


Discuss: 2014 Maserati Ghibli 4dr Sdn

Conversation powered by Livefyre