Why You Can Trust CNET Oregon Scientific ATC5K review: Oregon Scientific ATC5K
Oregon Scientific ATC5K
- North American Car, Truck and SUV of the Year (NACTOY) Awards Juror
Usually extreme sports helmet cameras are ruggedly simple affairs that have to forgo complications such as LCD viewfinders in favor of compact and durable designs. The Oregon Scientific ATC5K Action Camera avoids that compromise by squeezing a small full-color LCD screen onto its smallish body, while still preserving its waterproof and shockproof design.
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
Unfortunately, it makes compromises in the one place that a camera never should: the photo sensor. While the ATC5K can take photos and video in extreme conditions, its VGA resolution and poor low light performance keeps them from being great shots.
Design
The ATC5K is a tapering tube style camera. Measuring 4.5 inches long and 3 inches thick at its thickest end, the camera is quite portable. With rubberized bumpers on both ends and solid construction, it's also quite rugged.
At the business end, the ATC5K sports a small recessed lens tucked behind a raised rubber ridge and a plastic shield. Just above the lens is an activity indicator light that shifts from green while recording to red when the device is busy writing and an infrared receiver.
Along the top edge are two rubberized buttons: one for video and one for still photography. To prevent accidental presses, the buttons must be held for 2 seconds to start or stop video recording or snap a still shot.
The rear end of the device is occupied mostly by a 1.5-inch color LCD screen that works as a digital viewfinder, as well as depicting menus and playing back recently captured media. The screen is held in place by a hinge with a locking closure along its top edge. Unlocking and swinging down the screen reveals the battery door for the two AA batteries that power the device live, as well as the SD card slot, video out port, and Mini-USB port.
The unit is designed to be handled roughly and is shock resistant and waterproof, able to be submerged up to 10 feet deep.
Included with the ATC5K is a plastic mounting ring and base grip that the camera can be inserted into to connect to any of the included mounting options. The ATC5K kit includes a handlebar grip, a Webcam stand, and a helmet grip that can be used with one of the two Velcro straps or the silicon rubber head strap the unit ships with.
Also included is a CD with Windows drivers, an IR remote control with a CR2032 coin battery that replicates the video and photo buttons, a carry bag, an AV cable with RCA connections for video and monaural audio, a USB cable to interface with a PC, and a pair of AA batteries.
Features
At the top of the ATC5K's feature set is its capability to record video at up to 640x480 pixels and 30 frames per second. Video recording can be triggered using the video button on the top of the unit or the included RF remote. Both methods require a 2 second button press to register. Users are given the choice of VGA (640x480 pixels) or QVGA (320x240 pixels) resolutions using the devices menu.
The ATC5K is also able to capture still photographs at 640x480 pixels using the still capture button. The ATC5K does not have a time-lapse feature that snaps photos at regular intervals, so you'll have to manually trigger the shutter for each photo. Still photos cannot be captured while video is being recorded.
A 32MB internal memory will hold up to 47 seconds of VGA video, 1.5 minutes of QVGA video, or 175 VGA still photos if you're in a pinch and forget your SD card. However, to get the best use of the device, you'll want to pick up an SD memory card (not included). The device will store up to 120 minutes of VGA video on a 4GB SD card (the largest readable size).
The menu system of the ATC5K lets users adjust capture resolution; preview captured media; delete unwanted files; enable/disable audible button confirmation (beeping); adjust the audio recording level between low, high, and off; and set the date and time for file time stamps.
When connected to a television or monitor using the included RCA cables, the ATC5K can playback stored media or send a live video feed. When connected to a computer via USB, the ATC5K gives the user a choice between displaying the files stored on the device and functioning as a Webcam. The Webcam function only works on machines running 32-bit versions of Windows, leaving 64-bit users and Mac users out of luck.
Performance
The ATC5K seems most stable when used with the included tube grip on, for example, bicycle handlebars. We had difficulty securing the ATC5K in any other configuration that didn't yield a good deal of vibration or shake. The 5K's bullet-shape puts its center of gravity a few inches in front of the mounting point when using the strap-based attachments, causing the lens to shake about considerably.
The ATC5K's construction dictates that this is a device that should be used outdoors and its video capture reinforces this sentiment. In sunlight, the video captured was crisp and saturated. However, using the ATC5K indoors, at dusk, or on an overcast day yielded mixed results ranging from muddy and poorly exposed to plain dark and unwatchable.
The 5K's sensors seemed to take a few seconds to adjust to changing light, resulting in 2-3 seconds of blown-out, overexposed imagery when, for example, transitioning from an indoor to an outdoor environment. While using the ATC5K as a Webcam, we could see the exposure of the captured image shifting from dark to light as the unit tried to keep up with the changing amounts of light caused by moving our head about.
Transferring 1GB of video from the device's SD card slot using the integrated USB port took a staggeringly slow 30 minutes, during which the 5K needed to be powered using its batteries. So, you may want to invest in an SD card reader to speed up file transfers and save on batteries.
In sum
With its color LCD, the ATC5K is a very easy device to pick up and start using. Its menus are well designed and easily navigated. The rugged construction and waterproof design also contribute to the 5K's design score. However, the ATC5K is considerably larger than the competing GoPro Hero and less evenly balanced, making it more difficult to stably mount and more prone to being caught on obstructions.
The ATC5K wins back points in the Features category with its Webcam and live monitor functions and the inclusion of an IR remote control, but it loses major points in the Performance category for its issues with poor image exposure and low light performance. At $229, it's also more expensive than competing models that capture better video, take higher resolution photos, and feature more mounting option. However, if you must have a live LCD viewfinder for your extreme photography, the ATC5K is one of the only ways to go.