Olympus OM-D E-M1 review: A prosumer camera that, with some effort, delivers
An excellent prosumer mirrorless interchangeable-lens camera that requires a read through the manual before you use it.
Olympus pulls out all the stops for its latest top-of-the-line Micro Four Thirds camera, the OM-D E-M1. Designed to woo Four Thirds-lens aficianados from its dSLRs -- this is the model that for all intents and purposes signs the death warrant on the E series -- the E-M1 incorporates a new antialiasing-filter-free 16-megapixel sensor, a hybrid phase-detection and contrast autofocus system, and fast continuous shooting in a cold-and-weather-sealed body. The result is a serious Micro Four Thirds camera that delivers some real advantages over dSLR alternatives, but not without some work before you use it for the first time.
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
The dual autofocus system, which the company dubs "Dual Fast AF," is an essential move for Olympus; Four Thirds lenses will, of course, work with Micro Four Thirds cameras, as long as you have a mount adapter, but Olympus' lenses are phase-detection optimized like most dSLR lenses. And Olympus, unlike its MFT buddy Panasonic, has a large base of Four Thirds lenses, with some very nice glass. To use them on the E-M1 you need to buy the $180 MMF-3 adapter, which is weather-sealed to match the body; the slightly cheaper $170 MMF-2 adapter will also work, just don't expect it to stand up to the elements.
Image quality
In the E-P5, Olympus decreased the intensity of the antialiasing filter with good results. Here, the optical low-pass (OLPF) filter is gone entirely and it's correcting moire in-camera. The company also claims the camera's performing more intelligent sharpening, using the MTF data from the lens to determine the correct amount of sharpening to apply, plus it theoretically offers better chromatic aberration correction, via the TruePic VII version of its image-processing engine. (That's one TruePic more than the E-P5.)
Note: I think Olympus should be whacked upside the head for its image-processing defaults. In order to select the best quality JPEG, you have to first enable it in a custom menu, then select it in the image-quality settings; it defaults to Fine JPEG rather than Super Fine. If you don't read the manual carefully you would never know this setting existed. It's the same in the E-M5. Olympus says that the difference between Fine and Super Fine is negligible and that only a subset of people will benefit from using it, but nowhere are the use cases explained.
Overall the image quality out of the E-M1 is excellent; certainly better than the E-M5, as good or better than the E-P5 and really competitive with the D7100. The default Fine JPEGs look clean through ISO 800 and remain relatively usable through ISO 1600; shooting raw buys you at least another stop of detail over theses JPEGs, however, and even as low as ISO 100 you can get better results with raw than over the default JPEG settings. The color noise remains fairly fine-grained until about ISO 3200, which means that converting night shots to monochrome produces a nicer grain than you might otherwise see.
The color defaults to Natural, and JPEGs render with excellent, accurate color reproduction without looking flat. The dynamic range isn't exceptional -- it doesn't preserve much recoverable detail in clipped highlights or shadows -- but for relatively contrasty images you can pull back the highlight and shadows without much contouring or introduction of color noise.
Click to download (note: all shot at Fine JPEG) | ISO 200 | ISO 800 | ISO 3200 |
I was pleasantly surprised by the video quality. Normally, I find Olympus' video full of artifacts, but the E-M1's looks pretty well resolved, with no gratuitous moire (I did see some on high-frequency lines) or edge artifacts. There's also some wobbling on quick camera movements. It could use some grading -- right out of the camera it looks a bit flat, though not seriously washed out -- but otherwise it's quite nice. The audio sounds good, though there isn't much in the way of adjustments if you need more control. As with the E-P5, Windows 7 Media Player can't play Olympus' QuickTime movies, though oddly Windows 8's can.
In addition to testing with some my favorite MFT lenses, the 75mm f1.8 and 45mm f1.8, I was able to test the new 12-40mm f2.8 lens that Olympus might offer as part of a kit at some point but for now is only offering rebates for a simultaneous purchase. I really like the photo quality of the lens. It seems to have excellent light transmission and edge-to-edge sharpness, with a round aperture, and to me looks relatively sharp from f1.8 up through about f20.
Performance
The E-M1 is fast, but not without one caveat. It powers on, focuses, and shoots in just under 0.8 second. Time to focus and shoot in either bright or dim conditions runs about 0.2 second, and time for two sequential nonburst shots, either raw or fine JPEG, also runs about 0.2 second. Adding flash to that bumps to a reasonable 1.7 seconds.
Enter the caveat. During performance testing, we test in shutter-priority with the shutter speed at 1/125 second and set the lens to its widest, usually resulting in the the aperture open to f4 or f3.5 in our bright condition test. At that aperture with the new 12-40mm f2.8 lens at 12mm, the E-M1's AF would not lock on the center of the scene, though it would pretend to do so and shoot anyway. After discovering this, I moved the focus point up one step to ensure focus lock. Interestingly, performance is the same regardless of whether it lcoks focus. I don't know whether it was a problem with the lens or the AF system -- I suspect it's a result of the wide angle, the widest we've tested with our current methodology and will keep it in mind in the future -- but moving the AF point seems like a reasonable solution.
Continuous-shooting speed also zips along nicely. In high-speed mode, which sets the focus, exposure, and white balance on the first frame it achieved its rated 10fps for at least 105 fine-quality JPEGs. (Normally I don't test that mode, but since I did it by accident I figured I'd report the results.) Switching to the low-speed burst setting of 6.5fps, It delivered that for both Fine JPEG and raw files; raw doesn't slow until at about 40 shots (using a 95MB/sec card), which is quite good.
On the imaging sensor, one out of every 16 pixels -- one out of every eight of the green pixels in the Bayer array, to be precise -- is replaced with a phase-detection sensor. The missing image value is then interpolated. Like the system in the Canon EOS 70D it's measuring directly off the focal plane, which helps drive the lens directly toward the correct focus point, the biggest problem when using phase-detection-optimized lenses with contrast-detection-based systems.
The autofocus generally works very well, though it's not as decisive as the 70D's. With Four Thirds lenses, such as the 12-60mm f2.8-4 and the 35-100mm f2I tried, the response is certainly a lot better than with just contrast AF, but the lenses (at least the good ones) have heavy glass that slow down their movement compared to the more compact Micro Four Thirds versions. Tracking autofocus operates relatively well during burst shooting, although it jumps to another object a little more frequently than I'd like; for instance, if you have two runners with one coming from behind, it might jump to the second runner for a few shots and then jump back. It does provide nice feedback, changing the color of the tracking box, so it obviously knows it's made an incorrect decision.
Its excellent EVF and LCD, in combination with magnification and focus peaking, works extremely well for manual focus. I never once wished I'd brought a loupe for shooting video. Ditto for the image stabilization, which I was able to handhold down to 1/6 second for stills.
The one not-inconsiderable drawback of the E-M1, and indeed advanced mirrorless ILCs in general, is that they don't deliver the battery life you expect of a camera in its price class. Among other things, the EVFs and LCDs they require consumer a lot of power, and unlike a dSLR don't have an optical viewfinder to fall back on.
Design and features
Overall, I like the design of the E-M1. The magnesium-alloy body is freeze-resistant down to 14 degrees, in addition to moisture-and-dust-sealed like the E-M5. It has a substantially bigger and more comfortable grip -- it's a substantially bigger camera -- which gives you plenty of leverage when using moderately large Four Thirds lenses. My one complaint about the controls: they all feel mushy.
Given how many physical controls Olympus has crammed onto the body of the E-M1, it's pretty well designed -- "overdesigned" frequently flitted through my brain while shooting, as I tried to remember what was mapped to what, and trying to figure out why I couldn't find some functions because I'd changed the defaults. You really have to read the manual for this model. (Download a PDF here.)
I also want to note how much I like the design of the new 12-40mm f2.8 lens, the first in Olympus' M.Zuiko Pro line. It feels sturdy, with great action on the zoom ring. The manual focus ring feels a little too loose for my taste, but I got used to it. It's weather resistant to match the camera, with a programmable function button.
Canon EOS 70D | Nikon D7100 | Olympus PEN E-P5 | Olympus OM-D E-M1 | Olympus OM-D E-M5 | Panasonic Lumix DMC-GH3 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sensor (effective resolution) | 20.2MP CMOS n/a | 24.1MP CMOS 14 bits | 16.1MP Live MOS 12 bits | 16.3MP Live MOS 12 bits | 16.1MP Live MOS 12 bits | 16.1mp Live MOS 12 bits |
22.5 x 15mm | 23.5mm x 15.6mm | 17.3mm x 13mm | 17.3mm x 13mm | 17.3mm x 13mm | 17.3mm x 13mm | |
Focal- length multiplier | 1.6x | 1.5x | 2.0x | 2.0x | 2.0x | 2.0x |
Sensitivity range | ISO 100 - ISO 12800/25600 (exp) | ISO 100 - ISO 6400/ 25600 (exp) | ISO 100 (exp)/200 - ISO 25600 | ISO 100 (exp)/200 - ISO 25600 | ISO 200 - ISO 25600 | ISO 180 (expanded)/ |
Burst shooting | 7fps 16 raw/65 JPEG | 6fps (7fps in 1.3x crop mode) n/a | 4.5-5fps (lens dependent, IS off) 70 JPEG/20 raw (9fps with fixed AE/AF, no IS) | 6.5fps (with IS off) unlimited JPEG/60 raw (10fps with fixed focus and exposure, IS off) | 9fps 17 JPEG/11 raw | 6fps 29 raw+JPEG |
Viewfinder | 98% coverage 0.95x/0.59x | Optical 100% coverage 0.94x/0.63x | Optional EVF n/a-inch 2.36m dots 100% coverage 1.48x/ 0.74x | OLED EVF n/a-inch 2.36m dots 100% coverage 1.3x - 1.48x/ 0.65x- 0.74x | EVF n/a-inch 1.44m dots 100% coverage 1.15x/0.58x | OLED EVF n/a-inch 1.7 million dots 100% coverage 1.42x/0.71x |
Autofocus | Dual Pixel CMOS 19-pt phase-detection AF all cross-type; center cross to f2.8 | 51-pt phase- detection AF 15 cross- type; center to f8 or faster (Multi-CAM 3500DX) | 35-area contrast AF | 27-point phase detection, 81-point contrast | 35-area contrast AF | 23-area contrast AF |
AF sensitivity range | -0.5 to 18 EV | -2 to 19 EV | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Shutter speed | 1/8,000 to 30 secs; bulb; 1/250 x-sync | 1/8,000 to 30 secs; bulb; 1/250 sec x-sync | 60 - 1/8000 sec; bulb to 30 minutes; 1/250 sec x-sync (FP to 1/4000 sec) | 60 - 1/8000 sec; bulb to 30 minutes; 1/320 sec x-sync (Super FP to 1/8000) | 60 - 1/4,000 sec.; bulb to 8 minutes; 1/250 sec x-sync (flash-dependent) | 60-1/4,000 sec.; bulb |
Metering | 63-zone iFCL | 2,016-pixel 3D color matrix metering II | 324 area | 324 area | 324 area | 144 zone |
Metering range | 1 to 18 EV | 0 to 20 EV | 0 - 20 EV | -2 - 20 EV | 0 - 20 EV | n/a |
Flash | Yes | Yes | Yes | Included add-on | Included add-on | Yes |
Wireless flash | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Image stabilization | Optical | Optical | Sensor shift | Sensor shift | Sensor shift | Optical |
Best video | H.264 QuickTime MOV 1080/30p/ 25p/24p; 720/ 60p/50p | 1080/60i/ 50i/30p/ 25p/24p; 720/60p/ 50p H.264 QuickTime MOV (60i/50i only in 1.3x crop mode) | 1080/30p @ 20Mbps H.264 QuickTime MOV | 1080/30p QuickTime MOV @ 24 Mbps | 1080/60i QuickTime MOV @ 20, 17Mbps | H.264 QuickTime MOV 1080/60p/50p @ 50Mbps; 1080/30p/ AVCHD 1080/60p/50p @ 28Mbps; 1080/24p @ 24Mbps |
Audio | Stereo; mic input | Stereo; mic input; headphone jack | Stereo; mic input | Stereo; mic input | Stereo; mic input | Stereo; mic input; headphone jack |
LCD size | 3 inches inches articulated touch screen 1.04m dots | 3.2 inches fixed 1,228,800 dots | 3-inch tilting touch-screen LCD 1.04m dots | 3-inch tilting touch-screen 1.04m dots | 3-inch tilting touch-screen OLED 614,000 dots | 3-inch tilting touch-screen OLED 610,000 dots |
Wireless | Wi-Fi | Optional via WU-1a adapter | Wi-Fi | Wi-Fi | None | Wi-Fi |
Battery life (CIPA rating) | 920 shots (210 Live View) | 950 shots | 330 shots | 350 shots | 330 shots | 500 shots (est) |
Dimensions (inches, WHD) | 5.5 x 4.1 x 3.1 | 5.3 x 4.2 x 3.0 | 4.8 x 2.7 x 1.5 | 5.1 x 3.7 x 2.5 | 4.8 x 3.5 x 1.7 | 5.2 x 3.7 x 3.2 |
Body operating weight (ounces) | 27.2 | 27.3 | 15.1 | 17.5 (est) | 15.1 | 19.4 (est) |
Mfr. price | $1,119.00 (body only) | $1,199.95 (body only) | $999.99 (body only) | $1,399 (body only) | $949.99 (body only) | $1,299.99 (body only) |
$1,349.00 (with 18-55mm STM lens) | $1,599.95 (with 18-105mm lens) | n/a | n/a | $1,199.99 (with 12-50mm lens) | n/a | |
$1,549.00 (with 18-135mm STM lens) | $1,799.95 (with 18-140mm kit) | $1,449.99 (with 17mm f1.8 lens and VF-4 EVF) | n/a | $1,099.99 (with 14-42mm lens) | n/a | |
Ship date | September 2013 | March 2013 | July 2013 | October 2013 | April 2012 | September 2012 |
I'd expect a camera like this to have built in GPS -- you can geotag images via the phone app -- and possibly a headphone jack and second card slot, but otherwise it's got a cornucopia of useful features.
These include automatic HDR compositing of four shots with strong or subtle options, which delivers really nice results even handheld at slow shutter speeds, as well as traditional exposure bracketing (which Olympus calls HDR bracketing) of up to seven frames and up to three EV. The camera also adds a time-lapse mode of up to 999 shots at 1-second to 24-hour intervals, from which it can automatically create a 100-second movie.
Olympus offers one of the more robust Wi-Fi connection solutions. It uses QR codes for quick Wi-Fi setup rather than�NFC. When you bring up the connection on the camera it presents a QR code that you capture with the OI.Share app on your device, and the app automatically configures the connection. It's a clever, inexpensive solution to setup on devices without NFC. The app provides a larger-than-usual set of remote control capabilities, though it oddly won't let you change the white balance. It also has an edit module for applying filters, scribbles, signatures and so on to photos on the camera, but no way to do basic exposure adjustments.
Conclusion
While it's a really great camera for the money, with excellent raw photo quality, a host of useful features, and speedy performance, I ended up docking the OM-D E-M1 a point in design for its needlessly overcomplicated configuration options and its opaque choices for defaults.