/> ED I T O R S C H O I C E IN N O V A T IO N A W A R D
X

CNET editors pick the products and services we write about. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

Mitsubishi WD-65831 review: Mitsubishi WD-65831

David_Katzmaier.jpg

Editors' Note 11-27-07: This product is a 2006 model that has been replced by the Mitsubishi WD-833 series

8.6

Mitsubishi WD-65831

The Good

Produces deep blacks with excellent shadow detail; greatly reduced "rainbow effect" compared to other DLPs; resolves every line of 1080-resolution sources; plenty of picture control including fine-tuning for color and tint; excellent connectivity with two 1080p-compatible HDMI inputs and a 1080p DVI input; very compact design for a 65-inch HDTV.

The Bad

Expensive; inaccurate primary colors and initial color decoding and grayscale; no grayscale controls in user menu.

The Bottom Line

The Mitsubishi WD-65831 may be expensive, but its standout picture quality, sleek design, and superb feature set make it worth the price to high-end buyers.

Big-screen rear-projection HDTVs are inexorably giving up ground to flat-panel models, and thanks to plasma and flat LCD price erosion, that process is happening more quickly than ever. Today sales of more-expensive 50-inch plasmas equal or exceed sales of cheaper 50-inch projection sets, and it's just a matter of time before even bigger, 60-inch plasmas are available for prices that challenge RPTVs. Until then, however, people who want a 60-inch-plus HDTV are generally going to go with projection.

Mitsubishi's WD-65831 is just such a 65-inch DLP-based RPTV. Despite its place among the most expensive of its breed, it's still a relative bargain compared to similarly sized plasmas, namely Panasonic's TH-65PX600U. Its principal competition comes from the likes of Sony's KDS-R60XBR2, which we had an opportunity to compare directly to the Mitsubishi. Both sets produced excellent pictures, and image quality competition was close to a wash--both sets received the same performance rating, with each having its own strengths and weaknesses (see Performance for details). Overall we liked the Mitsubishi slightly better on account of its more compact design, but of course that's more subjective than anything. The supersleek WD-65831 brings an amazingly complete feature set to the table as well, with a tremendous input selection and every extra you could want--and then some. For someone who wants a top-of-the-line 65-inch set but can't quite stomach eight grand for a plasma, the Mitsubishi WD-65831 is as good as it gets.

Design
As we mentioned, we love the WD-65831's looks, and looks aren't something big-screen HDTVs generally do well. The highlight is the set's extremely thin bezel around the screen, which allows this big HDTV to take up less room than the Sony KDS-R60XBR2. The Mitsubishi measures 58.5x40.8x19.8 inches and weighs a comparatively feathery 99 pounds. The cabinet is entirely glossy black, with a subtle strip of charcoal-gray speaker grille that runs along the bottom of the screen. Below that is a couple inches of pedestal base, rounded along the edges, with a flip-up door fronted by the Mitsubishi logo.

Opening the door reveals a set of A/V inputs with composite and S-Video; a FireWire jack that can connect to IEEE 1394 devices, such as digital recorders, as well as camcorders; a quartet of media card slots that encompasses just about every format available; and eight keys to input commands if you happen to misplace the remote. Mitsubishi's clicker has been redesigned from the flyswatter of yore. We liked the more manageable size and the red backlight behind every key, but we wish the new remote offered a few differently placed, strategically located keys. We found the staid grid of buttons difficult to get to know by feel.

Hitting the Menu button brings up a relatively friendly graphical interface that leads you through a range of setup options quite clearly. Mitsubishi's audio and video settings are accessed by pressing their respective buttons on the remote, which might initially be confusing to people who expect to find those settings in the main menu. All of the picture controls conveniently occupy little screen real estate, making adjustment much easier. The main exceptions are the control screen for Perfect Color and Perfect Tint, which take up almost the entire screen.

Features
Foremost on the WD-65831's feature list is its DLP-based light engine. The set uses the same Texas Instruments DLP chip found in competing 1080p DLP televisions, but the company has added one proprietary feature: a six-color color wheel. The wheel provides separate filters for secondary colors cyan, magenta, and yellow, which the company says improves color reproduction (see Performance). As a 1080p native-resolution display, the WD-65831 can resolve every detail of 1080i and 1080p sources, and all other sources are converted, as usual, to fit the pixels.

Mitsubishi included an excellent array of convenience features, starting with a two-tuner, split-screen picture-outside-picture feature that lets you view two shows at once. It offers a good range of combinations, including PC-with-HDMI and component-with-HDMI. In addition to the ATSC tuner and CableCard combo, Mitsubishi adds the TV Guide onscreen EPG to make the loss of your cable box's EPG sting a little less. The set can also read memory cards to play MP3 or WMA music files and display JPEG picture files.

Unique to Mitsubishi is the NetCommand system, which is designed to let the TV control a rackful of A/V gear, much like a universal remote. It uses a series of IR emitters--Mitsubishi includes enough for four devices with the WD-65831--to send remote-control commands to your stuff. Of course this necessitates telling the TV what kind of gear you have, and selecting from a list of remote codes or going through a "learning" process to input codes that aren't already in the TV's database. When you first connect a piece of equipment, the television senses it and prompts you to perform NetCommand setup, but you can easily skip that if you'd like. Once everything is set up, you can control the equipment using the TV's onscreen interface, which includes buttons such as Play, Guide, List, and Record just like the devices' remotes. We didn't test this feature on the WD-65831, but we have used it in the past and it's pretty effective, although we still prefer a well-programmed universal remote. One of the benefits of NetCommand, however, is that it lets you stash your gear out of sight.

Moving past the conveniences, the WD-65831 affords a great deal of control over the picture, although there aren't as many controls as on the Sony (where many of them are rather superfluous). There are just two aspect-ratio selections available for HD sources and a solid six for standard-def. There are three different picture modes, called Natural, Bright, and Brilliant, with Natural delivering the most accurate default settings. Changes made to any mode are saved individually in that mode and are different for each input, allowing plenty of picture setup options. There are two color-temperature presets, High and Low, with the latter coming closest to the 6,500K standard.

Another set of controls is unique to Mitsubishi. Perfect Color and Perfect Tint promise the ability to fine-tune each of the primary and secondary colors--red, green, blue, cyan, magenta, and yellow--for saturation and tint. Again these settings are independent per input. See Performance for details on the effectiveness of these controls. A few other options for picture control are available, including a four-step noise-reduction circuit, an edge enhancement control called SharpEdge that we left off for high-quality sources, and a so-called Deep-Field Imager, which alters black levels in different areas of the screen, so we left it off after setting the black level properly.

Mitsubishi has always offered excellent connectivity on its high-end big screens, and the WD-65831 is no exception. Its prodigious back panel supports two HDMI inputs, three component-video inputs (one more than normal), a DVI input that can handle digital or analog computer signals (analog may require a VGA-to-DVI adapter) or HDMI sources (again, adapter required), two A/V inputs with composite and S-Video, separate audio inputs for the HDMI and DVI connectors, a pair of RF inputs for antenna and/or cable, an optical digital audio output, a monitor A/V output, and a pair of IEEE-1394 (FireWire) ports, for use with D-VHS recorders or future digital recorders (possibly including Blu-ray and/or HD DVD recorders). As we mentioned, the WD-65831's front panel houses additional input possibilities.

Performance
The Mitsubishi WD-65831 can produce a great-looking picture, but it takes a bit of work. After setup, we appreciated its deep blacks and solid shadow detail; clean, uniform picture; and sharp images from 1080-resolution sources. We would have liked to see better color accuracy both before and after calibration, but the myriad controls helped this issue quite a bit.

Calibration: We began as always by setting up the Mitsubishi in a completely dark room and adjusting its picture controls accordingly. The WD-65831 can get extremely bright, but we found that turning down contrast did improve black levels and make the picture easier on the eyes in the dark. We ended up with a maximum light output of around 35 footlamberts. Prior to calibration, the Mitsubishi's grayscale came fairly close to the standard in the Low preset (see the geek box below), but was somewhat greenish. Afterward, grayscale tracking was very good, although we were disappointed that the set, unlike some others, didn't allow us to tweak the grayscale in the user menu.

We also spent a good deal of time adjusting the set's extensive color controls. Out of the box, the Mitsubishi's color decoding, measured against the standard blue reference, exhibited desaturated green and oversaturated red. The Perfect Color control allowed us to adjust the color balance and improve it tremendously. Perfect Tint, on the other hand, didn't work as well as we'd have liked. It promised the ability to adjust the colors with respect to others, making red more magenta or more blue, for example, which should fix the Mitsubishi's questionable primary and secondary color accuracy. Playing with these controls did improve colors somewhat, but after adjustment they were still pretty far from perfect. Part of the problem was that the colors actually changed slightly when we entered the menus, and that the control display obscured a good portion of the screen. But the simple lack of adequate control range was the main issue; no matter how much we shifted the tint control for blue, for example, we couldn't approach the HDTV standard on the Y axis; blue remained too greenish.

While all of those the controls are great, we'd rather the set have accurate primary colors out of the box. Compared to the Sony KDS-R60XBR2, the Mitsubishi's primary colors exhibited about the same degree of inaccuracy--albeit in different colors--while sets such as the Samsung HL-S5679W and HL-S5687W, for example, were much more accurate. When all of our adjustments were complete, the Mitsubishi's color was definitely better, but not exceptional compared to the competition. See the Tips & Tricks section above or click here for our complete user-menu settings.

Blu-ray testing: After setup, we chose to watch the excellent-looking Aeon Flux Blu-ray disc played from a PlayStation 3 via HDMI at 1080p and 1080i resolutions. We compared the Mitsubishi side by side with a variety of displays, including the directly competitive Sony KDS-R60XBR2 as well as the Panasonic TH-50PH9UK, the Panasonic TH-50PF9UK and the Pioneer Pro-FHD1, all 50-inch plasmas.

Black-level performance between the Sony and the Mitsubishi was just about equal. The WD-65831 delivered nice, deep blacks in darker scenes such as when Aeon infiltrates the theater. The shadows along the walls and curtains appeared quite clean, and I could discern lots of detail in her face as she peeks around the corner. There was no sign of visible gradations or contours in the transitions from shadow to darkness. We also appreciated that the color stayed true and neutral into the darkest areas, where on the Sony it tended to get tinged somewhat bluer. Note that the Mitsubishi actually changed black-level profiles when we switched between 1080i and 1080p sources, becoming somewhat lighter with 1080p. If you're setting up the display at home, we recommend choosing between 1080i and 1080p and sticking with that choice for each input, as opposed to switching between the two.

We've discussed color a lot already, so we'll be brief here. After the adjustments mentioned above, the Mitsibishi WD-65831's colors appeared fairly good, but there were still issues. During the gunfight at the end, for example, we noticed that the sky above the organic blimp appeared too greenish, and not as deep blue as on the Sony SXRD or the plasmas. Aeon's skin looked very good, on the other hand, without any reddish tinge, although it was slightly less saturated than on the plasmas--increasing the color control too much did turn her skin redder, although at moderate levels it was fine. The yellow in the tree leaves was a bit too mustard-colored and brownish, although the green of the grass looked much more lush and accurate than on the Sony. After our adjustments, color was a cut above many high-end HDTVs, but still not as good as the aforementioned Samsungs, for example.

Screen uniformity on the WD-65831 was a notch above many other rear-projection sets. The Sony exhibited slight discoloration on white and gray fields, namely a more purplish tinge toward the top and bottom edge, where the Mitsubishi's fields were very consistent in terms of color. Its brighter, middle hot spot was more noticeable than the Sony's, however. We also noticed more stationary screen grain on the WD-65831, which appeared as tiny spots that became visible primarily in white and other bright areas, especially during pans. The Sony had significantly less of that type of grain. Our Mitsubishi review sample exhibited excellent geometry with very little distortion or fringing along straight white lines, even along the extreme corners and edges of the screen.

One of the chief uniformity complaints we've had about DLP televisions is the rainbow effect. Maybe it's a result of the company's six-segment color wheel, but we barely saw any rainbows whatsoever on the WD-65831. They cropped up only during very high-contrast scenes and only when we moved our eyes across the picture--something that happens rarely if you sit an acceptable distance from the screen. Of course, Sony and JVC LCoS displays don't engender rainbows at all, but this is the first DLP we've reviewed (aside from the LED-powered Samsung HL-S5679W) where rainbows weren't an issue.

As a 1080p display, the Mitsubishi WD-65831 should be able to deliver every detail of 1080 material. It did, according to the pattern on our Sencore VP403 signal generator, with both 1080i and 1080p sources. The set accepted 1080p at both 60 and 24 frames per second. Although we've heard (from HD Guru Gary Merson) that the Mitsubishi can properly detect and implement 2:3 pull-down detection with 1080i material, we can't test that capability ourselves since we don't yet have access to the proper test material. We did notice that it exhibited moire and moving lines on the stairs at the beginning of Chapter 8 on the Mission: Impossible Blu-ray discs (artifacts that disappeared when we switched to 1080p output), but we saw the same effects on all of the TVs in our test facility. If you're keeping track, only the JVC HD-56FN97 has passed this test.

In the highly detailed sections of Aeon Flux, such as Chapter 9 when she confronts the Keeper, the high resolution of the WD-65831 came out beautifully. All of the fine vertical lines were perfectly visible, and when Aeon ascends the stairs, they remain perfectly clear and artifact-free. The Mitsubishi didn't exhibit the same level of razor-sharpness that we saw from the Pioneer Pro-FHD1, but it was very sharp--about on the level of the Panasonic TH-50PF9UK. It was also a hair sharper than the Sony next to it, delivering very slightly sharper details in wrinkles on Aeon's lips, for example, or the stubble on Trevor Goodchild's face.

Standard-def testing: Tearing ourselves from high-def discs, we checked out the WD-65831's standard-def performance using the HQV test DVD. The Mitsubishi turned in a more consistent performance than the Sony, for sure, acing the 2:3 pull-down test, although it took a long half-second to remove the moire from the bleachers. The biggest issue was some instability we saw on the resolution pattern, although the WD-65831 did resolve every line of the 480i source. It did a mediocre job of smoothing jagged diagonal lines, and there was some softness to details such as the stone bridge and the grass in the stationary city shot. On the other hand, the WD-65831 exhibited the most effective noise reduction we've seen from any HDTV we've tested recently. The three levels of noise reduction, Low, Medium, and High, offer progressively better removal of video noise with trade-offs in detail, which is par for the noise-reduction course. High mode especially virtually eliminated noise on the disc's difficult, snowy-looking cloud and sky shots.

PC testing: We tested the Mitsubishi's PC capability by connecting its DVI input to a home theater PC, and we appreciated the set's ability to handle a 1,920x1,080 source. The WD-65831 also resolved every line of the source according to DisplayMate, and text looked perfectly legible. As we've seen on other rear-projection sets connected to PCs, the WD-65831 overscanned the image significantly, so, for example, the taskbar along the bottom of the Windows desktop along with the far-left column of shortcuts were invisible. You may be able to correct this issue using your video card's drivers, at the expense of scaling the image. We appreciated the option to adjust vertical and horizontal position.

We also tried connecting the Samsung BD-P1000 Blu-ray player to the DVI input using an HDMI-to-DVI adapter and didn't have any problems playing a disc at 1080p. Other resolutions were problematic, however, including 1080i, which appeared soft, didn't fill the screen, and caused an error message. Connecting the Toshiba HD-A1's HDMI output to the Mitsubishi's DVI input at 1080i resolution didn't work at all; all we saw was a red screen. In other words, the DVI input seems to work fine as a third HDMI input (as opposed to a PC input) as long as the source is 1080p. Be aware, however, that it offers fewer picture controls than the two HDMI inputs, so we recommend using them first.

TEST RESULT SCORE
Before color temp (20/80) 6,300/6,277K Good
After color temp 6,523/6,427K Good
Before grayscale variation +/- 219K Good
After grayscale variation +/- 131K Average
Color of red (x/y) 0.663/0.327 Poor
Color of green 0.289/0.631 Average
Color of blue 0.143/0.087 Poor
Overscan 4% Average
Black-level retention All patterns stable Good
2:3 pull-down, 24fps Y Good
Defeatable edge enhancement Y Good

8.6

Mitsubishi WD-65831

Score Breakdown

Design 9Features 9Performance 8