LG Infinia LV5500 review: LG Infinia LV5500
LG Infinia LV5500
We tend to give prominence to the "hero" models here at CNET, but there is an expectation that some of the technology found in high-end TVs will appear in some form in middle and lower-end sets as well. The LG LV5500 is a midrange TV that doesn't quite hit its marks. It's just slightly less expensive than the LG LW5600, which we really liked, but falls well short of its picture quality. The LV5500 is one of the least expensive LED-based LCD TVs on the market, and still manages to pack in an excellent Internet suite and a cool motion-control remote, but it's simply decent and not spectacular.
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
Series information: We performed a hands-on evaluation of the LG 47LV5500, but this review also applies to the other screen sizes in the series. All sizes have identical specs and according to the manufacturer should provide very similar picture quality.
Models in series (details) | ||||
LG 42LV5500 | 42 inches | |||
LG 47LV5500 (reviewed) | 47 inches | |||
LG 55LV5500 | 55 inches |
Design
Design highlights | ||||
Panel depth | 1 inch | Bezel width | 1.5 inches | |
Single-plane face | No | Swivel stand | Yes |
After making a splash with its striking Scarlet TVs in 2008, LG has arguably struggled to maintain a consistent level of design ever since. The company can deliver a television like the reasonably stylish LW5600 and LW9800, but it made some strange decisions with the LV5500 series.
At a quick glance the LG LV5500 series looks like any other TV with a piano-black coating and rectangular design. But don't look too closely. Both LG and Samsung currently favor transparent edges, but on the samples we received the plastic looks cheap, and fit and finish are a little underwhelming. The unusual "brushed metal" effect along the edge of the black bezel underneath looks like cheap nail glitter up close and simply looks discolored from the couch.
Remote control and menus | ||||
Remote size (LxW) | 2.5x9 inches | QWERTY keyboard | No | |
Illuminated keys | Yes | IR device control | No | |
Menu item explanations | No | Onscreen manual | No | |
Other: Includes secondary motion-based RF remote control |
A look inside the box reveals two remotes: a "standard" remote and the Magic Motion clicker included with step-up models. The standard remote is similar to most other LG remotes with a centralized directional pad and backlit keys. However, a lack of definition between the buttons on the directional pad makes it easy to press the wrong button, dumping you out of menus.
We liked the Magic Motion remote better, which works like a Nintendo Wii controller to enable you to select menu items and utilize many Smart TV functions. LG's redesigned home menu is also well-thought-out and places proper emphasis on the most-used functions. Check out the LW5600 review for more details on the remote and menu system.
Features
Key TV features | ||||
Display technology | LCD | LED backlight | Edge-lit | |
3D technology | N/A | 3D glasses included | N/A | |
Screen finish | Matte | Internet connection | ||
Refresh rate(s) | 120Hz | Dejudder (smooth) processing | Yes | |
DLNA-compliant | Photo/Music/Video | USB | Photo/Music/Video | |
Other: Includes secondary motion-based RF remote control |
This part is confusing, so forgive us in advance. Previously LG's web site claimed that the LV5500 series has the LED Plus technology, the company's name for edge lit with local dimming. We called the company to confirm and they told us that that was a mistake and that the LV5500 doesn't have local dimming (they subsequently removed said reference from the site). Nonetheless we did see some blooming in our tests, indicating that the TV does some kind of local dimming, but regardless, it doesn't seem to help the picture quality (see below).
Aside from the backlight, two notable inclusions are the bundled Wi-Fi adapter and--for the people who like their picture smoother than a silk toboggan luge--dejudder and onboard 120Hz processing. At least the smoothing can be configured and turned off.
Streaming and apps | ||||
Netflix | Yes | YouTube | Yes | |
Amazon Instant | Yes | Hulu Plus | Yes | |
Vudu | Yes | Pandora | No | |
Web browser | Yes | Skype | Yes | |
Yes | Yes | |||
Other: Additional Premium services include CinemaNow, MLB.tv, Napster, vTuner, AccuWeather, AP News, Google Maps, Picasa |
The LG LV5500 series is an LG Smart TV, and in conjunction with the Magic Motion remote this is definitely the television's best feature. While the downloadable apps and games aren't that exciting, the content offerings are quite significant, with heavy-hitters Amazon Instant Video, Hulu Plus, and Netflix all included--Pandora is the only missing link. The TV also features a (sluggish) Internet browser and DLNA compatibility for streaming your stored digital media.
Picture settings | ||||
Adjustable picture modes | 6 | Fine dejudder control | Yes | |
Color temperature presets | 3 | Fine color temperature control | 10 points | |
Gamma presets | 3 | Color management system | Yes | |
Other: No local-dimming control |
Like many LG TVs the LV5500 comes with a wealth of setup options including the picture tweaker's favourite, the 10-point calibration menu. For the less technically minded, the TV also includes a Picture Wizard that will give a much better picture than Vivid and Standard mode do, though not as good as you'd get from an inexpensive calibration DVD.
Connectivity | ||||
HDMI inputs | 4 | Component video inputs | 1 | |
Composite video input(s) | 2 | VGA-style PC input(s) | 1 | |
USB port | 2 | Ethernet (LAN) port | Yes |
The selection of connections leaves nothing to be desired, although the second component/composite jack requires a breakout cable.
Performance
The LG LV5500's picture quality was decent for the price, mainly due to color accuracy and video processing, but its black levels were lighter than those of the competition. Models like the LG LW5600 and Samsung UND6400 both offer much better picture quality as well as the option of 3D.
The LG's Cinema mode was best out of the box although still too bluish. Setup is one of LG's main strengths, and using the TV's advanced settings we were able to get extremely accurate color and gamma.
It's worth mentioning here that we received two LG LV5500 TVs but the first was faulty with a broken backlight and a woefully inaccurate 10-point system. The second TV worked fine.
Comparison models (details) | ||||
Samsung UN46D6400 | 46-inch edge-lit LED | |||
LG Infinia 47LW5600 | 47-inch edge-lit local dimming LED | |||
Sony Bravia KDL-46EX720 | 46-inch edge-lit LED | |||
Panasonic TC-P50ST30 | 50-inch plasma | |||
Pioneer PRO-111FD (reference) | 50-inch plasma |
Black level: The LV5500 showed the lightest shade of black among the models in our lineup, coming up a hair short of the Sony and looking quite a bit more washed-out than the others. Dark scenes, such as the 'solitary' sequence in "Batman Begins" appeared less realistic and punchy as a result. We also noticed that bright areas appeared a dimmer than on the Samsung and the Sony (an issue we also noticed on the LW5600), robbing more contrast from the scene.
The LV5500 exhibited the same tendency as its bigger brother LW5600 to crush shadow detail: the dark exteriors of the rebel Romulan ship in the "Star Trek" reboot looked crisp and dynamic on the competing Samsung, but washed-out on the LGs.
Despite LG's claim that the TV doesn't do local dimming we noticed signs of blooming, where stray light from bright areas illuminated darker ones. It wasn't visible in most scenes however; we only really noticed it in areas like white-on-black credits and the icons of our PS3 in the letterbox vars, for example.
Color accuracy: After calibration the TV was among the most accurate in our lineup, delivering spot-on color with natural-looking skin tones. On the flipside the LW5600 and especially the Samsung looked a good deal richer and more saturated thanks to their deeper black levels.
Video processing: The TV employs a 24p mode called Real Cinema, and we found it worked quite well, preserving the correct cadence of film in tracking shots. In addition, we found that employing the TruMotion setting's User mode--maxing out antiblur while simultaneously turning off antijudder--gave us the TV's full motion resolution without the extra smoothing or haloing artifacts associated with dejudder. That's one improvement over the LW5600, which introduced smoothing in the same User settings.
Uniformity: In addition to the minor blooming, we noticed that the left side of our LV5500's screen showed stray illumination that spilled out into darker areas. It wasn't bad enough to spoil our viewing, but it was more noticeable than any of the uniformity issues on the Samsung or especially the LW5600--albeit not as annoying as the bright spots on the Sony.
Off-axis viewing is not especially good, and it's even worse than on the Samsung UND6400, which we criticized for poor off-axis performance at the time of our review.
Bright lighting: The LG has a matte screen and we didn't experience any problems with reflections in a well-lit environment.
Power consumption: The LV5500 is a miserly consumer, using fewer watts per square inch than just about any TV we've tested this year.
Result | Score | |
---|---|---|
Black luminance (0%) | 0.004 | Good |
Avg. gamma | 2.2465 | Good |
Near-black x/y (5%) | 0.3132/0.3378 | Good |
Dark gray x/y (20%) | 0.3142/0.3324 | Good |
Bright gray x/y (70%) | 0.3127/0.3283 | Good |
Before avg. color temp. | 6944 | Poor |
After avg. color temp. | 6480 | Good |
Red lum. error (de94_L) | 0.947 | Good |
Green lum. error (de94_L) | 1.4461 | Good |
Blue lum. error (de94_L) | 1.0347 | Good |
Cyan hue x/y | 0.2312/0.3353 | Good |
Magenta hue x/y | 0.3307/0.1595 | Good |
Yellow hue x/y | 0.4262/0.5096 | Good |
1080p/24 Cadence (IAL) | Pass | Good |
1080i Deinterlacing (film) | Pass | Good |
Motion resolution (max) | 900 | Good |
Motion resolution (dejudder off) | 400 | Poor |
PC input resolution (VGA) | 1,920x1,080 | Pass |
Power consumption:
Power consumption:The 47-inch 47LV5500 we tested is a miserly consumer, using fewer watts per square inch than just about any TV we've tested this year.