Still, it isn't hugely inconvenient, especially compared to other robot floor cleaners we've tested. The iRobot Braava 380t may have a longer battery life, but you also have to deal with attaching and removing mop pads for cleaning. Plus, the Scooba comes with a Virtual Wall that you can use to section off your floor for cleaning. If you live in a smaller home or have minimal amounts of hardwood/vinyl/laminate, etc., the Scooba might just simplify your floor cleaning routine.
I tested the Scooba 450 on hardwood, vinyl, and tile. Each surface got dosed with a fair amount of canola oil (to mimic oil splatters, and with green food coloring added so leftover spots would show up), marinara, and a mud mixture (made from combining plain potting soil with water).
The Scooba performed the best among the $300, the $500 , and the $250 . However, none of those three models are designed to tackle floor cleaning with the same gusto as the Scooba. It's sort of like comparing a stick vacuum to a full upright -- not quite fair. Still, there aren't a lot of products in the category available for comparison. That helps Scooba to some extent because it stands out among the light-duty cleaners, but it also shows that there's a lot of room for improvement.
The Scooba's three-stage cleaning process managed to decimate most of the smudges and stains on all three surfaces. However, it also had a couple problems. As you can see in the photo above, the Scooba couldn't clean corners and had occasional trouble along edges in general. This bot could benefit from a side scrubber (similar to the Roomba's side brush) that could get closer to edges. Otherwise you have a rounded robot facing off against a 90-degree angle -- not ideal.
Most of the tile looked clean after each mopping cycle, but small bits of mud did cling stubbornly to the grout. Interestingly, I let mud sit on the hardwood floor for 24 hours to test how the Scooba handles caked-on messes and it left the floor in perfect condition. So, while it can definitely handle a significant mess, you may have to do minimal post-mopping bot spot cleaning.
I also tested the Scooba in my kitchen to see how it would navigate around obstacles. It did a pretty good job maneuvering around my kitchen table, but it definitely left inches of unmopped space between the table legs and the bot. Once again, the Scooba isn't great at getting close to corners, edges, or really any obstacles.
The Scooba 450's dual water reservoir and uniquely powerful three-step cleaning process makes it stand out from the other floor cleaners we've tested. Still, I wouldn't recommend this small space floor scrubber to everyone. If your goal is fast and efficient cleaning of large spaces, you might actually prefer the lighter-duty. It's designed for maintenance cleaning, but it can cover more ground per charge.