CNET logo Why You Can Trust CNET

Our expert, award-winning staff selects the products we cover and rigorously researches and tests our top picks. If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. How we test computers

HP Media Center PC m300y review: HP Media Center PC m300y

HP Media Center PC m300y

John Morris

Review summary


HP Media Center PC m300y

The Good

Serious specs; huge 200GB hard drive; wireless keyboard and mouse; fully configurable; easy-to-use digital video recorder.

The Bad

PC-based design won't fit in home theater; no room for upgrades; cables all over the place; LCD is too small for TV viewing.

The Bottom Line

The HP Media Center PC m300y benefits from OS and hardware improvements, but it's more a high-end home PC than a media-convergence device.

HP was one of the first to unwrap a Windows Media Center PC for the holidays last year. That rush job left room for improvement in both the operating system and the hardware. A year later, Microsoft has spiffed up the software, but the HP Media Center PC looks virtually identical. Sure, the m300y model we tested has a faster processor, a larger hard drive, and more-advanced graphics, but on the outside, it's the same, conventional tower case at a time when competitors are experimenting with bolder designs. There's nothing wrong with that if you want a high-end home PC that can moonlight as a TV and a digital video recorder, but the home-theater crowd will likely prefer a more stylish design.

Exactly how you feel about the design of the HP Media Center PC m300y depends on whether you want a PC or a convergence device for your home theater. Aside from a few miscues, the HP Media Center PC is an attractive, highly functional PC for a home office or a dorm room. But like other PC-based Media Center designs, it won't be welcome in most living rooms or entertainment centers because it still looks the part of a PC rather than a home-theater component.

"="" --="">/sc/30557444-2-200-DT1.gif" width="200" height="150" border="0" /> "="" --="">/sc/30557444-2-200-DT2.gif" width="200" height="150" border="0" />
The sleek front panel includes handy shortcut keys, a media-card reader, and home theater-friendly A/V ports.

The first thing you'll notice about the m300y is the shiny, black-plastic front panel, which is crammed with conveniently located features. Below a pair of optical drives sits the Media Center PC's row of mode buttons for controlling Windows XP Media Center functions, a six-in-one media-card reader, and a floppy drive. A flip-down cover hides ports for FireWire, USB 2.0, composite video, and S-Video, plus a headphone jack. On the top of the case is a hatch for HP's dockable Photosmart cameras.

"="" --="">/sc/30557444-2-200-DT5.gif" width="200" height="150" border="0" />

The m300y's feature-packed interior leaves no room to upgrade, let alone maneuver.
"="" --="">/sc/30557444-2-200-DT7.gif" width="200" height="150" border="0" />

At least the wireless keyboard and mouse help cut down on cable clutter.

Beneath this slick facade, however, the m300y's design can be more problematic. The case opens easily enough--you undo two thumbscrews and yank the side off--but the squat minitower is so loaded with drives and PCI cards that there's virtually no room inside to maneuver. The DVR card (with coaxial cable input), Creative Labs Audigy 2 sound card, and the modem occupy all three PCI slots. The manufacturers will tell you that Media Center PCs aren't really designed for upgrades anyway, but we don't know many people with an Ethernet jack next to their TV. If you want to install a PCI adapter for wireless networking, as we did during testing, you'll need to deal with this cramped case and sacrifice one of the installed cards (the most likely candidate is the modem).

There's another downside to all these features. By the time you hook up the power, VGA, speaker, and coaxial cables, as well as the infrared receiver for the Media Center remote and attached IR blaster (if you have a separate set-top box), you have a tangle of cables. At least HP has ditched the old-fashioned keyboard and mouse for an excellent wireless tandem that reduces cable clutter somewhat and is also far more usable.

"="" --="">/sc/30557444-2-200-DT6.gif" width="200" height="150" border="0" />

Couch potatoes will want more screen real estate than a 17-inch LCD provides.

This year, Media Center PCs, including HP's 300 series, will be available in a much wider range of configurations and prices. The m300y model we tested is, in all respects, a high-end system that is fully configurable and available online and at retail kiosks. HP also plans to offer three retail models that are not configurable: the m370n, m380n, and m390n, with prices starting at $999. (The HP Media Center PC 800 series we reviewed last year is being phased out.)

Though it has many entertainment features, at heart the m300y that we tested is still a serious PC with a 3.2GHz Pentium 4 chip, 512MB of memory, and a 200GB hard drive that should leave plenty of room for both Microsoft Office and BBC America's The Office. The version we tested included the Nvidia GeForce FX 5200 with 128MB of memory, but HP will also offer the m300y with the FX 5600 for $50 more.

If you do somehow run short on drive space, you can burn recorded TV shows to DVD using the 4X/2.4X DVD+R/RW drive. The second optical drive is a 16X DVD-ROM.

The long list of entertainment features includes both ones you might find on any high-end PC, such as a Creative Labs Audigy 2 sound card and Klipsch ProMedia 2.1 speakers, and others designed specifically for Media Center, including the TV tuner/DVR card and a nice remote control with a USB receiver and an IR blaster. The wireless keyboard also includes controls for Windows Media Center.

Our m300y test system included a matching 17-inch LCD, the HP f1703, whose height-adjustable screen also tilts easily on a sturdy hinge. It's a beautiful PC monitor, but it is simply too small for TV or other Windows Media Center applications, which are designed to be used from 10 feet away. The video quality seems vastly improved, thanks to a lot of work on Microsoft's part, but live and recorded TV still exhibited noticeable flaws on our test system, especially with fast-moving scenes such as flapping wings or fine-detail images such as hair.

In addition to Microsoft Works, HP's Media Center PC package includes a variety of programs for video editing and DVD authoring and playback, including ArcSoft Creator, ArcSoft ShowBiz DVD, Stomp's RecordNow, and WinDVD SE.

Application performance
Because of the intensive demands of Media Center tasks such as displaying and recording TV, burning DVDs, and video editing, Microsoft has set some strict guidelines for its hardware partners. Accordingly, our HP Media Center PC m300y test system had a high-end configuration with a 3.2GHz Pentium 4, 512MB of 333MHz DDR SDRAM, and a roomy 200GB hard drive. Though it trailed other 3.2GHz P4 systems we've tested and fell a hair behind Dell's 2.8GHz Media Center PC on SysMark2002, the m300y still has enough oomph for Media Center apps. The most likely culprit for the m300y's somewhat disappointing application performance is the 333MHz memory (PC2700). The other 3.2GHz systems we've tested featured suitably high-end 400MHz DDR memory (PC3200). For $40 more, you can upgrade the m300y's memory from PC2700 to PC3200; you should see a big performance boost.

Application performance (Longer bars indicate better performance)
BAPCo SysMark2002 rating
SysMark2002 Internet content creation
SysMark2002 office productivity
Gateway 700XL (3.2GHz Intel P4, 1,024MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)
ZT Home Theatre PC A5071 (2.2GHz AMD Athlon 64 FX-51, 1,024MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)
Dell Dimension 4600C with Media Center (2.8GHz Intel P4, 512MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)
HP Media Center PC m300y (3.2GHz Intel P4, 512MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz)
ViewSonic NextVision M2100 Digital Media Center (2.8GHz Intel P4, 512MB DDR SDRAM 266MHz)

To measure application performance, CNET Labs uses BAPCo's SysMark2002, an industry-standard benchmark. Using off-the-shelf applications, SysMark measures a desktop's performance using office-productivity applications (such as Microsoft Office and McAfee VirusScan) and Internet-content-creation applications (such as Adobe Photoshop and Macromedia Dreamweaver).

3D graphics performance
A true home-entertainment platform should also include capabilities for powerful 3D gaming. With its Nvidia GeForce FX 5200 graphics card, the m300y gets you at least halfway there. The system's 3D graphics performance is capable, especially if you keep your game's screen-resolution setting low, but it lacks the zest of a more powerful graphics engine, such as Nvidia's GeForce FX 5900 line. The bottom line: Most games will play on the Media Center just fine, but high screen resolutions and advanced graphics features will slow it noticeably.

3D graphics performance (Longer bars indicate better performance)
Futuremark's 3DMark2001 Second Edition Build 330 (16-bit color)
Futuremark's 3DMark2001 Second Edition Build 330 (32-bit color)
ZT Home Theatre PC A5071 (ATI Radeon 9800 Pro)
Gateway 700XL (ATI Radeon 9800 Pro)
ViewSonic NextVision M2100 Digital Media Center (Nvidia GeForce FX 5600)
Dell Dimension 4600C with Media Center (ATI All-in-Wonder 9000 Pro)
HP Media Center PC m300y (Nvidia GeForce FX 5200)

To measure 3D graphics performance, CNET Labs uses Futuremark's 3DMark2001 Pro. We use 3DMark to measure a desktop's performance with the DirectX 8.0 (DX8) interface at both 16-bit and 32-bit color settings at a resolution of 1,024x768. A system that does not have DX8 hardware support will typically generate a lower score than one that has DX8 hardware support.

3D gaming performance (in fps) (Longer bars indicate better performance)
Quake III Arena
ZT Home Theatre PC A5071 (ATI Radeon 9800 Pro)
Gateway 700XL (ATI Radeon 9800 Pro)
ViewSonic NextVision M2100 Digital Media Center (Nvidia GeForce FX 5600)
HP Media Center PC m300y (Nvidia GeForce FX 5200)
Dell Dimension 4600C with Media Center (ATI All-in-Wonder 9000 Pro)

To measure 3D gaming performance, CNET Labs uses Quake III Arena. Although Quake III is an older game, it is still widely used as an industry-standard tool. Quake III does not require DX8 hardware support--as 3DMark2001 does--and is therefore an excellent means of comparing the performance of low-end to high-end graphics subsystems. Quake III performance is reported in frames per second (fps).

Performance analysis written by CNET Labs technician David Gussman.

Find out more about how we test desktop systems.

System configurations:

Dell Dimension 4600C with Media Center
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2004; 2.8GHz Intel P4; Intel 865G chipset; 512MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz; ATI All-in-Wonder 9000 Pro 64MB; Seagate ST3120026A 120GB 7,200rpm

Gateway 700XL
Windows XP Home; 3.2GHz Intel P4; Intel 875P chipset; 1,024MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz; ATI Radeon 9800 Pro 128MB; two Seagate ST3160023AS 160GB 7,200rpm Serial ATA; integrated Intel 82801ER Serial ATA RAID controller

HP Media Center PC m300y
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2004; 3.2GHz Intel P4; Intel 865PE chipset; 512MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz; Nvidia GeForce FX 5200 128MB; Maxtor 6Y200P0 200GB 7,200rpm

ViewSonic NextVision M2100 Digital Media Center
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2004; 2.8GHz Intel P4; Intel 845GV chipset; 512MB DDR SDRAM 266MHz; Nvidia GeForce FX 5600 128MB; Maxtor 4R160L0 160GB 5,400rpm

ZT Group Home Theatre PC A5071
Windows XP Media Center Edition 2004; 2.2GHz AMD Athlon 64 FX-51; Nvidia Nforce-3 Pro 150 chipset; 1,024MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz; ATI Radeon 9800 Pro 256MB; Seagate ST3160023AS 160GB 7,200rpm Serial ATA

The Media Center PC 300 series includes a standard one-year warranty on parts and labor. HP doesn't offer onsite service, though some resellers do if you purchase one of the retail models. Alternatively, HP will cover the cost of shipping both ways should you need to return the system for service. Depot service is always available at an authorized repair center.

HP provides toll-free telephone, e-mail, and live online chat support for the life of the product. Phone support is available 24/7 for the duration of the warranty; afterward, you pay a per-incident fee. Our test system did not include the final printed documentation, but we remember liking the thorough, straightforward documentation in previous versions of the HP Media Center. Useful online resources include FAQs and software updates. Finally, we were very impressed with the Windows Media Center 2004 setup process, which simplified complex tasks, such as programming the remote, and should cut down on the need for support.


HP Media Center PC m300y

Score Breakdown

Design 7Features 9Performance 7Support 7