Why You Can Trust CNET Guitar Hero review: Guitar Hero
Crank it up to 11 -- Guitar Hero rocks like no other rhythm game before it. A must-have for anyone who has ever dreamed of being a guitar-playing god.
Guitar Hero is a rock fantasist's dream -- guitar glory without all those pesky years of hard practice and toil.
Guitar Hero
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
At its core a simple rhythm game, Guitar Hero muscles it way above others of its ilk thanks to its awesome guitar-shaped controller, rocking song selection and tightly-honed difficulty curve which allows newbies to rock out almost immediately, while leaving plenty of challenge for the true aficionado. The game makes you feel like you're actually playing guitar -- so much so you'll probably unconsciously find yourself doing the pogo or helicopter and wishing you could still fit into some black stovepipe jeans.
Guitar Hero's controller -- a Gibson SG replica -- is sturdily built and while a little small, is large enough for gamers not to feel self conscious while playing it. The guitar features five colour-coded fret buttons on the neck, while the body features a small lever for strumming and a whammy bar.
The mechanics of Guitar Hero are rather simple. A rolling fret board appears on your TV screen, with indicators matching the colour-coded fret buttons appearing. All you have to do to hit a note do is hold down the corresponding fret (or frets to play a chord) while strumming the Gibson SG replica. Notes with long lines attached to them require you to hold down the fret button for the duration of that line. Hit the note correctly and you'll hear it ring out sweetly -- miss it and you'll get clunking sound. A meter on the right side of the screen shows you how well you're doing -- miss too many notes and meter goes into red, with the song stopping completely if you play too badly.
It sounds easy, but Guitar Hero at its most difficult level can be truly punishing, not to mention a strain on your wrists and hands. Even some songs at medium difficulty can be downright nasty. The game encourages players introduce themselves gradually to the game, setting up a well-honed learning curve that proves addicting to play.
Guitar Hero has four difficulty levels -- easy, medium, hard and expert. At easy levels, the game only requires you to use the first three fret buttons on the guitar neck. On medium, you'll need to use four, while on hard and expert all five are used. Not all of Guitar Hero's songs are immediately available for play -- songs are bundled into groups of five, with players needing to complete at least four songs in a set before unlocking the next batch.
While it sounds contrived, Guitar Hero's gradually ramping difficulty is one the most compelling things about the game. The songs you'll start with on Easy level are just that -- easy. But as you progress through the other songs, you'll find your fingers get worked a little more. When you start off at Medium difficulty, the first few songs you'll encounter will only sparingly use the fourth fret button as a way of gradually introducing you to that new gameplay element. By the end, though, you'll have to have mastered that fourth fret to complete the hardest songs. Ditto the fifth fret for Hard Level. And don't even think about opening up Expert unless you've become Hendrix-like. You'll find yourself hooked pretty quickly as your skills increase to match the difficulty of the game.
Music-based rhythm games live and die on their song selection. Guitar Hero's selection of 30-plus songs is a standout -- there's an eclectic selection of both new and old tracks which range in genre from metal anthems, pop punk hits, hard rock titles to blues standards. The songs are all cover versions, but they're reproduced extremely faithfully. The full song list is:
- Ace of Spades -- Motorhead
- Bark at the Moon -- Ozzy Osbourne
- Cochise -- Audioslave
- Cowboys From Hell -- Pantera
- Crossroads -- Cream
- Fat Lip -- SUM 41
- Frankenstein -- Edgar Winters Project
- Godzilla -- Blue Oyster Cult
- Heart Full of Black -- Burning Brides
- Hey You -- The Exies
- Higher Ground -- The Red Hot Chili Peppers
- I Love Rock and Roll -- Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
- I Wanna Be Sedated -- The Ramones
- Infected -- Bad Religion
- Iron Man -- Black Sabbath
- Killer Queen -- Queen
- More Than a Feeling -- Boston
- No One Knows -- Queens of the Stone Age
- Sharp Dressed Man -- ZZ Top
- Smoke on the Water -- Deep Purple
- Spanish Castle Magic -- Jimi Hendrix
- Stellar -- Incubus
- Symphony of Destruction -- Megadeth
- Take it Off -- The Donnas
- Take Me Out -- Franz Ferdinand
- Texas Flood -- Stevie Ray Vaughn
- Thunderkiss 65 -- White Zombie
- Unsung -- Helmet
- You've Got Another Thing Comin' -- Judas
Priest
- Ziggy Stardust -- David Bowie
Guitar Hero features decent graphics and presentation, although you'll probably be too busy concentrating on hitting your notes to see what's happening in the background. The game's main career mode allows you to pick an avatar from up to eight different characters, while there are six locations where you can raise your goblet of rock. The characters, while all varied in looks and style, don't feature any differing abilities, so they're pretty interchangeable from one another.
What the game does nail is its sound. Apart from the excellent sound response when you hit (or don't hit) the right notes in a song, Guitar Hero features a dynamic crowd which will cheer or boo your performance, depending on how rocking it is. Trust us -- there's nothing worse than getting booed while in the middle of a tough solo.
Guitar Hero has even catered for left handers, with an option included which, when turned on, allows you to flip the guitar upside down.
Two-player modes are also insanely fun. Hook up two guitars to your PS2 and you can battle it out against a friend. Each song in Guitar Hero has been optimised for two player mayhem, with players tackling different sections of the song and occasionally joining together for some wall of sound action. Unfortunately, guitar attachments aren't being sold separately right now, so you'll need to buy two full versions of the game if you want some guitar battling fun.
Guitar Hero is, hands-down, the most fun we've had playing a rhythm game. Its rock solid song list and sweet difficulty make it a must have for anyone who's ever dreamed of rock stardom. We can't wait for the sequel! Now excuse us while we kiss the sky...