Why You Can Trust CNET Barnes & Noble Nook HD review: A media tablet for non-techies
The Nook HD feels like a successful attempt at an e-reader doing its best impression of a full-featured tablet. It excels at books, movies, and magazines, but some typical tablet features are missing.
- Once wrote 50 articles in one month.
Editors' note, November 25, 2013: Due to increasingly stronger competition in the tablet space, CNET has lowered the score of the Nook HD.
Barnes & Noble Nook HD
The Good
The Bad
The Bottom Line
The Nook HD is light, comfortable, and has the sharpest screen of any current 7-inch tablet. With full access to the Google Play store, "limited app availability" can now be crossed off as its major caveat.
The Nook HD's higher resolution screen makes movies and games look sharper than on any other small tablet. The OS still feels like a walled garden, but with access to now tons of apps and media content, that doesn't matter as much as it did when the tablet first launched.
While the Nexus 7 is still the best small tablet, the Nook HD's low price (especially now), sharp screen, expandable memory, and great app selection significantly increases its appeal.
Starting at only $129, the Nook HD is one of the best small tablets you can buy.
Design
I spent days comparing the Nook HD to the top 7-inch tablets available and if there's anything I've learned in that time it's this: the devil's in the details. From a cursory glance, the average consumer might have a difficult time distinguishing one black, gray, or white slate from the next, but it's the little things that set them apart. Stuff like weight, corner design, bezel width, and texture are small things that play a big part in comfort and feel.
The Nook HD comes in both smoke (medium gray) and snow (kind of like ivory) and has a soft, rubberized back with a volume rocker on the top-right edge and a power/sleep button opposite it on the left. On the bottom edge are a custom 30-pin charging connector and a microSD card slot covered with a door. The tablet includes a 30-pin to USB cable that plugs into the included AC adapter. Dual speakers sit on the lower back and the top edge of the tablet seat a headphone jack and microphone.
In middle of the bottom border, right above the bezel, is the hardware home button, last seen on the Nook Tablet. Like on the iPad, the home button is a great "just press this if things get confusing" solution for the ever-evolving tablet interface. Unfortunately, there's no built-in camera, no ambient light sensor, no Micro-USB, and no HDMI port.
The Nook HD's corners are smoothly rounded and at only 0.69 pound, it's the lightest 7-inch tablet available and feels perfectly comfortable when held. The device is as thick (depth-wise) as the Nexus 7 and a bit thicker than the Fire HD and though it's wider than the Nexus 7, it's noticeably narrower than the almost-too-wide Fire HD. Held vertically, the side bezel's width just about matches the Nexus 7; however you get a little extra space due to the black borders surrounding the Nook's screen.
| Barnes & Noble Nook HD | Amazon Kindle Fire HD | Google Nexus 7 | Apple iPad Mini | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weight in pounds | 0.68 | 0.86 | 0.74 | 0.68 |
| Width in inches (landscape) | 7.65 | 7.7 | 7.8 | 7.87 |
| Height in inches | 5 | 5.4 | 4.7 | 5.3 |
| Depth in inches | 0.43 | 0.4 | 0.4 | 0.28 |
| Side bezel width in inches (landscape) | .3/.5 | 0.9 | 0.8 | 0.8 |
Even with its light weight, the Nook HD's build feels solid and durable; however, it proves susceptible to screen warping with enough pressure in the right place. Applying pressure to the back or along the right bezel yields a visible screen warping effect on the tablet' screen. Now, screen warping occurs to some extent on nearly every tablet; however, if you're just holding the Nook HD while reading a book or watching a movie, you'll likely have no cause to apply enough pressure to your Nook HD for this to be a problem.
The interface
The Nook HD's operating system uses Ice Cream Sandwich as its base, with a custom-designed skin that feels like an evolution of the original Nook Tablet's OS. The home screen sports a light gray, slightly textured aesthetic that permeates through all native apps and menus. The home screen shows Library, Apps, Web, Email, and Shop options near the bottom with a global search bar underneath. Directly above is a space to organize your content shortcut icons, and near the top of the screen sits your content carousel.
In the top-right edge of the screen is Your Nook Today, which shows the current weather as well as book and movie recommendations based on recent additions to your library. Also, if the opt-out-of-ads kerfuffle for the Fire HD turned you off, you'll be pleased to know that Barnes & Noble has no such ads on its tablets.
Settings can be accessed by tapping the gear at the very top right of the screen and includes options too many to name. If you've ever used a tablet before however, there's nothing included in the settings that will surprise you. The default software keyboard, thankfully, includes a tab, but typing didn't feel as as accurate as it does on the Nexus 7.
Nook Profiles can be accessed from the upper left-hand corner and allows users to set up multiple profiles on a single tablet. With a simple tap of the profile photo at the top of the screen, you can choose to switch to a new profile almost instantly. Once in the new profile, that user's content (and only that user's content) will be displayed and accessible. Lock-screen switching is also possible. Both adult and child profiles can be accessed and passwords can be added to adult profiles, ensuring that not just anyone can access your content. Nook profiles are simple to implement and feel secure and useful, likely appealing to families on a budget.
Overall, the interface is much cleaner and intuitive than the Nook Tablet's; however, I still have a few problems with navigation. As much as I like the Home button, I feel the interface relies on it a bit too much. If looking at a magazine for example, there's no built-in navigation to view all magazines and you're forced to use the home button and then navigate to another piece of content if you want to switch. Not a huge deal, but it's annoying in the moment.
Now PLAYing: Google!
As of version 2.1.0 of the Nook OS, both the Nook HD and Nook HD+ include full Google Play support. All apps, music, videos, books, and magazines available on Google Play can now be downloaded directly to the Nook HD tablets. The Nook Store and its content is still available.
The chief criticism of the Nook HD tablets when they launched was the severely limited apps and media content ecosystem. With the additional of Google Play however, this effectively becomes an non-issue. Google Play is second only to iOS in terms of available content.
Chrome is now the default Web browser and all (aside from Google now) Google service apps -- Gmail, Magazines, and Books, etc. -- are automatically downloaded to the tablet once the update is installed.
If you have an Ultraviolet account, any movies added to your digital UltraViolet library will show up in your Nook HD+ library as well. A Netflix app is also available, but there are no plans to bring HBO Go just yet. The tablet supports MP4, 3GP, WEBM, and AVI video files, and MKV files.
Thanks to its high-resolution screen, text in books is crisp and clean whether in Google Books or the Nook's own book app. On the Kindle Fire HD, reading options like X-Ray, the percentage-read counter, and immersion reading may give Amazon's tablet the slight edge here. For a pure reading experience on a large tablet, though, the Nook HD+ the best current solution thanks to its lightweight and comfortable build.
Like pure Android tablets, the Nook HD does not have access to the Amazon Instant Video app. Right now, the app is only available on Kindle Fire tablets and iOS devices. Something to consider if, like myself, you're an Amazon Prime member with a heavy Amazon video streaming habit.
The Nook's magazine app is still the preferred way to view your favorite periodicals. I includes a smooth page-turning effect and the option to easily cut any page and include it in a virtual scrapbook. So, depending on your magazine(s) of choice, you could easily make a workout or recipes scrapbook, which is a lot less cumbersome than taking screenshots. Unfortunately, your clippings are only stored locally and (probably thanks to copyright laws) there's no way to share them online. You can, however, share them with other profiles on your Nook HD+.
Catalog support is not something I ever thought I'd begin a sentence with in a tablet review, but here we are and the Nook HD+ has it. Catalogs can be downloaded through the Nook store and function much in the same way that magazines do. However, certain items (predetermined by the catalog's publisher) will have a distinct visual cue next to them called a hot spot. Tapping on the hot spot takes you to a page with more information about that particular item at which point you can add it to your scrapbook and be seamlessly directed to the company's Web page for that item. If thumbing through catalogs is your thing, it makes for a fairly convenient and entertaining way to shop.
Hardware features
The Nook HD houses a 1.3GHz Texas Instruments OMAP 4470 CPU with a PowerVR SGX544 GPU bringing up the rear. It comes in both 8GB and 16GB varieties and its microSD card slot supports up to 64GB cards. The tablet includes 1GB of RAM, has 802.11 b/g/n Wi-Fi support, and Bluetooth 4.0. There's no gyroscope, compass, or GPS inside the tablet. There is however an accelerometer.
Performance
The Nook HD delivers images through a high 1,440x900-pixel resolution -- the highest yet for a 7-inch tablet. Evidence of its superior clarity can be seen in HD movies, in text in books, magazines, and Web pages, and pictures in magazines and and Web pages. There's a slight clarity advantage in games as well.
The Nook HD's screen is clearly more impressive than the Nexus 7's 1,280x800-pixel screen; however, it's not as cut and dry compared to the Kindle Fire HD. Most of the time, the Nook HD exudes superior quality to the Kindle Fire HD's 1,280x800-pixel screen, with a higher brightness and clearer, well, everything. However, the Kindle Fire HD's interface takes better advantage of its lower (but still high for a 7-inch tablet) resolution and glossier screen.
On the Fire HD, thumbnail images and fonts just look sharper, aided no doubt by the white text on black design of its interface, compared with the Nook HD's less contrasted black on gray design aesthetic. Also, while colors don't appear to be as accurate on the Fire HD, again, thanks to the screen's glossy coating, they pop from the screen much more vibrantly, especially on Web pages with white backgrounds like Collider.com.
As I mentioned before, HD movies are noticeably sharper on the Nook HD and colors look more accurate as well, compared with the Kindle Fire HD. The Nook HD also displays less backlight bleeding on dark screens. Both the Nook HD and Kindle Fire HD deal with glare equally well and viewing angles on each screen are wide. However, the Nook HD's screen is much more susceptible to moisture, so oily fingerprints tend to create a moire effect on the screen, blurring certain assets, especially text. Honestly, it can sometimes ruin the effect having more pixels provides. This is mostly a problem with text, however. Overall, I prefer the Nook HD's screen when viewing video, games, books, and magazines. It displays sharper text and images, and more accurate color. The Kindle Fire HD's glossy screen however gives it a higher perceived contrast when viewing the Web and is much less susceptible to fingerprint sullying.
| Tested spec | Barnes & Noble Nook HD | Amazon Kindle Fire HD | Google Nexus 7 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum brightness | 455 cd/m2 | 394 cd/m2 | 288 cd/m2 |
| Default brightness | 94.1 cd/m2 | 394 cd/m2 | 190 cd/m2 |
| Maximum black level | 0.53 cd/m2 | 0.41 cd/m2 | 0.28 cd/m2 |
| Default black level | 0.11 cd/m2 | 0.41 cd/m2 | 0.18 cd/m2 |
| Default contrast ratio | 855:1 | 960:1 | 1055:1 |
| Maximum contrast ratio | 858:1 | 960:1 | 1028:1 |
The Nook HD's speaker volume was consistently low when watching movies, but output at a decent volume for narrated kid's books.
I used Riptide GP to test the Nook HD's gaming performance and came away impressed. The 1.3GHz TI OMAP 4470 delivers frame rates higher than any other 7-inch tablet running the game so far at what looked to be a constant 60 frames per second refresh rate. Unfortunately, the game can't be played using tilt (Barnes & Noble says a fix is coming), but luckily tap controls work just fine. It's a shame the app store isn't full of more games that show off the Nook HD's superior 3D graphics hardware. Also, as of yet, there's no known way to sideload apps, although I'm sure that will have changed by the time you read this. Hopefully.
In 3DMark, the Nook HD performs about as well as the Nexus 7, meaning that overall gaming performance is smooth and playable, but not outstanding in any way. Check here for more information on how 3DMark determines its scores.
| Device | CPU | GPU | RAM | OS tested |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barnes & Noble Nook HD+ | 1.5GHz TI OMAP 4470 | PowerVR SGX544 (single-core) | 1GB | Nook OS 2.1.0 |
| Barnes & Noble Nook HD | 1.3GHz TI OMAP 4470 | PowerVR SGX544 (single-core) | 1GB | Nook OS 2.1.0 |
| Google Nexus 7 | 1.2GHz quad-core Nvidia Tegra 3 | ULP GeFOrce (12-core) | 1GB | Android 4.2.2 |
| Google Nexus 10 | 1.7GHz Dual-core Samsung Exynos 5 Dual (5250) | Mali-T604 (quad-core) | 2GB | Android 4.2.2 |
(In Frames-per-second; Longer bars indicate better performance)
 | 3DMark (Normal) |
(In frames-per-second; longer bars indicate better performance)
| Graphics Test 1, 720p (GPU) |
(In frames-per-second; longer bars indicate better performance)
| Graphics Test 2, 720p (GPU) |
(In frames-per-second; longer bars indicate better performance)
| Physics Test, 720p (CPU) |
As of yet, there's still no known way to sideload apps, but hopefully that changes soon.
Screen rotation is noticeably slower than on the Kindle Fire HD 8.9 and can't compare with how fast the iPad rotates its screen. Navigating the OS however does feel a bit sluggish as apps take their time to load. There's also a delay when bringing up recent apps, and the carousel has a frame-y, rough look when browsing through apps.
(In seconds; shorter bars indicate better performance)
| N.O.V.A. 3 Level 1 load time |
Screen rotation is noticeably slower than on both the Kindle Fire HD and Nexus 7 and navigating the OS feels a bit sluggish as apps take their time to load. There's also a delay when bringing up recent apps, and the carousel has a frame-y, rough look when browsing through apps.
Here are our official CNET Labs-tested battery life results. More tablet testing results can be found here.
| Video battery life (in hours) | |
|---|---|
| Barnes & Nobles Nook HD | 7.3 |
Conclusion
The addition of Google Play changes everything. With access to every app and piece of content on the store, there are now few major caveats to buying a Nook HD.
To be sure, the Nook HD has no cameras, lacks micro USB, and Micro-HDMI. And there's there's no GPS or gyroscope. Also performance can be lagging when navigating the interface.
However, the Nook HD is light, comfortable, great for pure books and magazine reading, and its scrapbook feature is well-implemented. Also, it's the sharpest movie player of any small tablet.
Profiles is a great solution for families on a budget and the microSD slot goes a long way toward dulling the sting of its low initial storage capacity and is something the other top 7-inch tablets don't support.
The Nook HD won't do every tablet-y thing you can think of, but with full Google Play access, it is dramatically more appealing than it was when it launched last year.