CNET has kept its finger on the pulse of the growing do-it-yourself security market for some time -- reviewing tons of. But now, thanks to the , I have the opportunity to review whole-home systems.
Of course, professionally installed security is a different animal from more modular options. Instead of assembling individual products, like a thermostat, an alarm or a lock, you sign an extended contract, get a fully integrated system, and pay a monthly fee till the contract ends. That means we have to work with companies more closely than usual. After arranging an install of one of AT&T's Digital Life packages, though, I finally got a chance to spend a week and a half testing it out at the CNET Smart Home.
Overall, Digital Life is very recommendable. The app interface is slick, the security features are market-competitive, and the home automation devices, while a little basic individually, benefit from beautiful integration. The biggest weakness of AT&T Digital Life is the price point. Between a two-year contract, monthly fees of $40, $55 or $65, initial equipment fees ($50, $150 and $200, respectively), and potential cancellation fees, consumers should be wary of jumping onboard without due consideration. But for anyone in need of professionally monitored smart-home security -- especially those trying to avoid the guesswork of installing do-it-yourself systems -- Digital Life is one of the best options out there.
What are my security options?
I wanted to approach the AT&T Digital Life install like any customer would, so I began by surveying the various security systems available to the average consumer. I knew plenty of do-it-yourself security systems, like SimpliSafe and iSmartAlarm, sell for a few hundred bucks and require no contractual obligations. Usually, these include a couple contact sensors -- devices that indicate whether doors or windows are open or closed -- a motion detector or two, a remote, an alarm, a camera or any combination of these gadgets.
And many of the base packages for professionally installed systems looked similar. AT&T Digital Life's "Smart Security" package, for instance, included six contact sensors, a motion detector, a keypad and an alarm.
As you upgrade, though, you can add cameras, flood sensors, connected outlets, smart door locks and more. For this review, AT&T installed a slightly personalized version of the "Premium Security and Automation" package. What became apparent was, whereas DIY systems will fit the needs of some smaller houses and apartments, professional systems like AT&T's will scale to the needs of almost any home.
Besides scaling, professional security has another major advantage over DIY systems: 24-7 professional monitoring. In the case of an emergency, AT&T Digital Life, like other professional systems, will contact the appropriate authorities. Many DIY systems will send you a smartphone notification or set off an alarm, but they won't call the police or fire department. (Some DIY systems are adding this feature, though it will entail a monthly monitoring fee.)
The problem with professional monitoring is the contract that's usually involved. Most security systems will cost you at least $30 a month, and they often include additional fees for installation, technology, or both. AT&T Digital Life's system, over the full two-year contract, will charge you between $1,010 and $1,760, not including any extra devices you elect to purchase beyond the packages. Plus, if you decide to cancel after the first two weeks, you'll have to pay off about $30 per month remaining in your contract.
So, professional security...
From early on, I liked Digital Life for a few reasons. First, it has the most straightforward pricing of any professional security system. On the website, you can find all the basic information for contract lengths, initial equipment fees and monthly costs. Listed alongside that information is each package's included devices. Many comparable companies require customers to call in for a quote, contract lengths and other pricing particulars.
AT&T's packages are also well designed (except for the mid-range $55 one; more on that later). The $40/mo "Smart Security" package matches the rates (plus or minus $5) of similar packages from Frontpoint, Protect America, ADT, and other leading providers. The "Premium Security and Automation" package includes loads of gadgets, and slides in at $65/mo, just under Vivint's priciest package (although Vivint's initial setup fee is lower). In addition, you can personalize your package by starting with the basics and adding individually priced packages like "cameras," "locks," "energy" "water detection" and others.
When it came time for the installation, like any customer, I waited while AT&T specialists -- all of whom receive background checks before assuming home installation duties -- placed sensors and other gadgets around the CNET Smart Home. The technicians were professional: each even donned booties when inside the home.
Post-install, the on-site manager walked me through the Digital Life system and answered my questions. AT&T clearly fulfilled all the must-haves I was looking for: wireless connection, tamper-alarms, diverse sensors, professional monitoring, and remote access. The one big difference between our setup and the typical Digital Life installations was the alarm triggers. Local police and fire departments really hate false alarms from security monitoring services, and rightly so, since those false alarms waste municipal resources. For the purpose of this review, AT&T put the monitoring service in test mode. They could see our system, but they wouldn't automatically trigger any 911 calls.
Overall, my installation experience was really positive. That said, AT&T and the installers knew they were working with CNET, so it wasn't exactly a blind test. They made sure to optimize the strength of every signal before they finished installing. They said they would do that for everyone, but, as with any national service provider with regional installation teams, your mileage may vary depending on who actually comes out to your house, how busy they are that particular day, etc.
Good technology, great integration
Essentially, our setup looks like this: we have the basic "Smart Security" gadgets like motion and contact sensors, a siren, and a keypad. But we also invested in an extra motion detector, a smoke detector, a CO sensor, a glass-break sensor, a thermostat, two smart door locks, two garage door controllers, two cameras and four smart plugs. We opted out of the water sensors since. Our personalized package would actually cost $5/mo less than the "Premium Security and Automation" package, but its install price would be much higher, especially given the extra camera and lock.