CNET logo Why You Can Trust CNET

Our expert, award-winning staff selects the products we cover and rigorously researches and tests our top picks. If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Reviews ethics statement

Asus DRW-1604P Internal IDE DVD+/-RW (+R DL) review: Asus DRW-1604P Internal IDE DVD+/-RW (+R DL)

This drive handles double-layer media with aplomb, but its shortcomings make it a questionable choice.

Stephanie Bruzzese
4 min read
Asus DRW-1604P
The Asus DRW-1604P covers the full spectrum of double-layer drive performance. This internal drive showed fast double-layer burn times, but it also delivered some of the slowest speeds we've seen when writing to single-layer discs and ripping content off of DVDs. Unless your obsession is speedy double-layer burning, skip the Asus DRW-1604P in favor of an overall faster double-layer burner, such as the Pioneer DVR-A08XL. If you can live without double-layer support and simply seek a well-rounded drive, check out the Plextor PX-712A.

There's nothing remarkable about the Asus DRW-1604P's appearance or external features: its face is putty-colored, and it houses only an eject button, an emergency-eject pinhole, and a logo. The DRW-1604P is an internal drive, which means you'll have to delve into your computer's innards to install it. The process is cumbersome compared to the simple plug-and-play installation of a USB or FireWire drive, but internal drives are generally faster than their external counterparts. Asus provides a basic, illustrated installation guide with the drive, but you can also check out CNET's handy how-to guide.


Asus DRW-1604P Internal IDE DVD+/-RW (+R DL)

The Good

Supports double-layer and multiformat discs; quick double-layer burning.

The Bad

Extraslow single-layer ripping and burning; toll-based phone support.

The Bottom Line

The Asus DRW-1604P's generally slow performance scores overshadow its fast double-layer burning.

Where speed ratings are concerned, the Asus DRW-1604P falls short only with its slightly slow 32X CD-R write speed. Otherwise, the drive offers the highest ratings available in its categories. Its most impressive spec of note is its 4X double-layer DVD burn speed. Though specs for double-layer discs currently top out at 2.4X, the drive writes to this media at 4X anyway. The DRW-1604P also includes quick 16X, 4X, and 24X speeds for DVD+/-Rs, DVD+/-RWs, and CD-RWs, respectively. Finally, it reads DVDs and CDs at a satisfying 16X and 40X.

Asus adhered to the status quo with the DRW-1604P's burning software. The company includes a pared-down version of the helpful Nero 6.0 Ultra Edition Suite. Asus also reaches out to amateur artists by including the capable Ulead DVD MovieFactory 3.0 Disc Creator.

In CNET Labs' benchmarks, the Asus DRW-1604P excelled in some tests and flopped in others. It clocked one of the best double-layer burn times we've seen, tying with the top-scoring Pioneer DVR-A08XL. (We used 2.4X DL media, which the Asus and Pioneer drives write to at 4X speed.) However, the Pioneer ripped our Labs' 7.9GB movie an embarrassing 15 minutes faster than the Asus. The DRW-1604P also took quite a while to rip our 4.4GB DVD movie and burn it to a single-layer DVD. The drive's CD rip and burn times proved better--but not by much. The DRW-1604P achieved its best performance in DVD+/-RW reading, which isn't too impressive considering most internal drives we've tested have scored within a 15-second range of each other. To its credit, the discs we burned with the DRW-1604P played in all six of the drives we tried.

The Asus DRW-1604P ships with the same one-year warranty as most of its competitors. The company's tech-support line is a disappointing toll-based number, so you're stuck with the long-distance charges. Worse, the line is open only during limited hours (5:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. PT). The Asus support Web site offers FAQs and a discussion forum.

DVD movie rip/burn tests (min:sec)
(Shorter bars indicate faster performance)
4.4GB DVD Video burn test  
4.4GB DVD Video rip test (from DVD Video)  
BenQ DW-1620 (16X DVD+R)
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (16X DVD+R)
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (8X DVD-R)
Note: * As 16X DVD-R media was not available, the Asus and Pioneer drives were tested using 8X DVD-R, which both drives write to at 12X. ** The BenQ drive was tested with 16X DVD-R media supplied by BenQ.

Double-layer DVD movie rip/burn tests (min:sec)
(Shorter bars indicate faster performance)
7.9GB DVD Video burn test  
7.9GB DVD Video rip test (from DVD Video)  
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (2.4X double-layer DVD+R)
Note: * The Pioneer and Asus drives write to 2.4X double-layer DVD+R media at 4X.

CD Audio rip/burn tests (min:sec)
(Shorter bars indicate faster performance)
74:35 CD Audio burn test  
74:35 CD Audio rip test  
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (48X CD-R)
BenQ DW-1620 (48X CD-R)

RW read/write tests (min:sec)
(Shorter bars indicate faster performance)
4.22GB RW write test  
4.22GB RW read test  
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (4X DVD+RW)
BenQ DW-1620 (4X DVD+RW)
Memorex DVD+/-DLKWL-1F161 (4X DVD-RW)
BenQ DW-1620 (4X DVD-RW)

Unless otherwise mentioned, all write tests are run with Verbatim media, rated at the drive's maximum speed. Find out more about how we test optical drives.


Asus DRW-1604P Internal IDE DVD+/-RW (+R DL)

Score Breakdown

Setup 7Features 7Performance 6Support 5