X

Top evidence in Apple v. Samsung according to juror (pictures)

Review some of the evidence and other trial highlights that stuck out in the minds of the Apple v. Samsung jury.

Josh Lowensohn
Josh Lowensohn joined CNET in 2006 and now covers Apple. Before that, Josh wrote about everything from new Web start-ups, to remote-controlled robots that watch your house. Prior to joining CNET, Josh covered breaking video game news, as well as reviewing game software. His current console favorite is the Xbox 360.
Josh Lowensohn
apple-samsung-court-drawings-13_2.jpg
1 of 6 Vicki Behringer

Juror highlights strongpoints of Apple's case

Just what stood out as some of the strongest evidence in the minds of the jury in Apple vs. Samsung? CNET spoke with one of the jurors, who told us about what went on during the group's deliberations. Click through to find out.

Screen_Shot_2012-08-25_at_10.27.31_AM.png
2 of 6 Apple

Before and after

According to Manuel Ilagan, one of the nine jurors who decided the case, the group found Apple's chart depicting the phones Samsung was doing before and after the iPhone compelling. Samsung's counterargument against that had been to point to a number of devices it was working on internally before the iPhone became public.

Screen_Shot_2012-08-25_at_10.23.09_AM.png
3 of 6 Apple

Crisis of design e-mail thread

Internal discussions didn't save Samsung in the instance of an e-mail thread from the company's top brass saying how Samsung was having a "crisis of design." Ilagan called the thread "damning."

Screen_Shot_2012-08-25_at_10.32.47_AM.png
4 of 6 Apple

Bouncing back

One of Apple's clean sweeps in the verdict was that all Samsung's smartphones were found to infringe on Apple's patent covering bounce-back. In short, this is what lets a user scroll beyond the edge of an image, Web page, or list, and have it bounce back onto the screen.

"We were thinking Apple filed a patent for bounce-back, (and) that's where we got stuck...because (of) prior art," Ilagan said. He added that the group eventually found some of Samsung's prior art "significantly different" from the technology outlined in Apple's bounce-back patent.

Screen_Shot_2012-08-25_at_10.25.12_AM.png
5 of 6 Apple

Intel's chips, Apple's problem

In its case against Apple, Samsung said Apple infringed on two of its 3G patents covered in a baseband chip used on the iPhone and iPad with 3G. Apple fired back, saying Samsung was wrongfully suing, since Apple had a licensing agreement with Intel -- the company that made the chips in question -- and that the deal protected Apple from lawsuits.

According to Ilagan, the jury found this issue to be one of the more exceedingly technical aspects of the case, but that he and the jury foreman were savvy enough to help the rest of the group understand it based on the evidence.

Screen_Shot_2012-08-25_at_10.30.50_AM.png
6 of 6 Apple

Question dodging

Last but not least, Ilagan said the group was turned off by some of the answers provided by Samsung's executives during depositions.

"Some of the Samsung executives they presented on video from Korea -- I thought they were dodging the questions," Ilagan said. "They didn't answer one of them; they didn’t help their cause."

Seen here: one of the inventors of a Samsung patent used in the case, effectively refusing to read a patent his name is on.

Full coverage of Apple vs. Samsung is here.

More Galleries

My Favorite Shots From the Galaxy S24 Ultra's Camera
A houseplant

My Favorite Shots From the Galaxy S24 Ultra's Camera

20 Photos
Honor's Magic V2 Foldable Is Lighter Than Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra
magic-v2-2024-foldable-1383

Honor's Magic V2 Foldable Is Lighter Than Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra

10 Photos
The Samsung Galaxy S24 and S24 Plus Looks Sweet in Aluminum
Samsung Galaxy S24

The Samsung Galaxy S24 and S24 Plus Looks Sweet in Aluminum

23 Photos
Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra Now Has a Titanium Design
The Galaxy S24 Ultra in multiple colors

Samsung's Galaxy S24 Ultra Now Has a Titanium Design

23 Photos
I Took 600+ Photos With the iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max. Look at My Favorites
img-0368.jpg

I Took 600+ Photos With the iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max. Look at My Favorites

34 Photos
17 Hidden iOS 17 Features You Should Definitely Know About
Invitation for the Apple September iPhone 15 event

17 Hidden iOS 17 Features You Should Definitely Know About

18 Photos
AI or Not AI: Can You Spot the Real Photos?
img-1599-2.jpg

AI or Not AI: Can You Spot the Real Photos?

17 Photos