
Sony and Panasonic, with their high stakes in 3D TV, are also two of the most active companies trying to generate 3D content at all levels. Panasonic now brings 3D into the entry-level professional price realm with the HDC-Z10000. (Though Panasonic won't announce the price until 30 days before it ships--also an unknown--given its size and features I'm assuming it will be comparable to the Sony HXR-NX3D1U, which was announced this past spring at the NAB Show and which has just started shipping.) Announced at the IFA show in Germany, Panasonic has also taken the opportunity to show a 3D Lumix camera prototype. That will ship this winter and will have twin 4X zoom lenses--folding optics and optical stabilization--and will do 3D video as well as stills.
The camcorder incorporates two sets of Panasonic's 3MOS triple-sensor systems, each with 2.07/2.19-megapixel resolution (3D and 2D, respectively), in what the company calls a Double 3MOS. It's also Panasonic's first model to use a 3D LCD, which displays glasses-free 3D; unlike the Sony, it has an EVF, but it's not clear whether the EVF displays 3D.
Here's a comparison of the two:
Panasonic HDC-Z10000 | Sony HXR-NX3D1U | |
Sensor (effective video resolution) | 2 x 3 x 2.07-megapixel CMOS | 2 x 3.5-megapixel Exmor R CMOS |
1/4.1 inch | 1/4-inch | |
Lenses |
Dual lens 10x (3D)/12x (2D) f1.5-2.7/2.8 2D: 29.8 - 368.8 mm 3D: 32.0 - 320.0 mm |
Dual lens 10x (3D)/12x (2D) f1.8-n/a 2D 29.8mm - 357.6mm 3D: 34.4mm - 344mm |
Minimum object distance (inches) | 3D: 17.7 inches/2D: 1.4 inches | 3D: 31.5 inches/2D: 0.4 inch |
Image stabilization | Optical | Optical |
Min illumination (lux) | standard: 1400 low light: 5 Color Night View: n/a |
recommended: n/a standard: 11 low light: 3 |
EVF | 0.5-inch 1.2 million dots | None |
LCD | 3.48-inch 1.2 million dots | 3.5-inch 1.2 million dots |
Primary media | 2 x SDXC | 96GB internal; 1 x SDXC |
HD recording | NTSC version AVCHD: 2D: 1080/60p/60i/30p/24p 3D: 1080/60i/30p/24p (30p is recorded in 1080/60i) PAL version AVCHD: 2D: 1080/50p/50i/25p/24p 3D: 1080/50i/25p/24p (25p is recorded in 1080/50i) |
AVCHD 2D: 1080/60p/50p/60i/24p 3D: 1080/60i/24p/50i |
3D format | Frame sequential | Frame packing, side-by-side |
Manual shutter speed | 1/24 - 1/8000 | 1/8 - 1/1000 sec |
Manual iris | Yes | Yes |
Accessory shoe | Yes | Yes |
Audio | 5.1 channels [(384 kbps) or 2 channels (256 kbps Dolby or 1.5Mbps Linear PCM)]; line mic, XLR x 2 and headphone jacks | 2 channels (16 bits, 48kHz); line mic, XLR x 2, and headphone jacks |
Body dimensions (WHD, inches) | n/a | 2.3 x 2.6 x 5.1 |
Operating weight (pounds) | n/a | 2.5 (est) |
Mfr. price | n/a | $3400 |
Ship date | n/a | August 2011 |
Panasonic is touting the camcorder's ability to shoot relatively close in 3D, but I'm not sure how immersive the experience would be shooting that close at a relatively narrow focal length. However, it specs pretty well for a 2D camcorder, and the lens rings look nicely done. A lot will depend on the price.
Discuss: Panasonic wants everyone to capture 3D video
Be respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read. Discussion threads can be closed at any time at our discretion.