New iPhone SE, 3 Apple Watch models coming? Moderna booster shot and omicron Popeye's meme kid now state football champ Squid Game: Most trending TV show in 2021 Best Christmas gifts 2021 PS5 restock tracker

Fake Dan Lyons loves Linux after all

Dan Lyons is revising his position on open source. Or is he?

Dan Lyons, the erstwhile Fake Steve Jobs, has told Robin Miller that he doesn't hate Linux, after all. As Robin reports:

He told me that people who say he dislikes Linux are not being fair to him; that out of 70 articles he's written about Linux, 67 have been positive, and he absolutely denies that he is paid by Microsoft to write what he does about Linux, Apple, or anything else.

I think it's all in how he means "positive." "Positive" for Dan is somewhat different from positive for, say, 99% of the human race. :-)

To be fair to Dan, sometimes his snarky negativity on Linux/open source had little to do with Linux/open source and everything to do with poor partner choices, weak arguments, weak-kneed execution, ironic capitulation, and sometimes overzealous enthusiasm for a fallible (though excellent) development methodology.

Let's be honest: sometimes Dan was right. As I've told him, I actually appreciate the criticism, even when I felt it was misplaced, because I think open source gets better by fixing its problems, not by overlooking them. Yes, Dan sometimes overstated his case, but I'd be a very dark pot to be calling the Dan Lyons kettle black on that one....

So, while it's fun to see Dan backtrack on the caricature the open-source community (myself included) has of him, I think it's fair to let him revise his position. Revise history? No. But re-position his future? Absolutely.