DMCA needs drastic overhaul
In response to the Oct. 10 column by Doug Isenberg, "The 'other' DMCA":
How can Isenberg honestly defend the DMCA? Its provisions prevent everyone (including journalists) from exercising long-recognized rights of "fair use" at the whim of any publisher.
Under the DMCA: CNET cannot publish a negative benchmark of Microsoft products without permission (what are the odds of that?); I can be forbidden from making a personal copy of a CD or movie; and I can be imprisoned for breaking "copy protection" devices of such astounding strength as a ROT13.
If there are parts of the DMCA worth saving, they should be bundled together into a new law that could be passed to replace this sadly flawed example of the power of lobbying.
Eric Johnson |
|
Be respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read. Discussion threads can be closed at any time at our discretion.