Why You Can Trust CNET Alexa, Google Assistant want to be everywhere in 2018
These voice assistants want to be on the go with you, plugging in to smart glasses, smart earbuds and even smart toilets.
Google's CES 2018 booth featured an impossible-to-ignore sign stating "Hey Google," the command to wake up your smart assistant.
At one section of Google's giant outdoor booth at CES was an impromptu, carney-style one-man show, with a guy wearing dark sunglasses and a white Google Assistant jumpsuit loudly and enthusiastically giving away free electronics one by one to a snaking line of gawking tech-show goers.
"He got a Google Home Mini ! Let's get a picture, boss!" he yelled out as I walked by on Thursday.
"Google's even giving out smart lights!" he told the crowd. "I didn't even know lights could be smart! Congratulations, dude!"
This one booth bro embodied Google's efforts at CES 2018, with the search giant making a rare and splashy appearance at the world's largest tech show. The company was working to drum up attention for its Google Assistant voice helper as it tries to catch up to Amazon's Alexa, the dominant force in voice-controlled smart speakers.
Not to be outdone, Amazon was part of dozens of partnership announcements at CES, with Alexa making its way into Toyota cars, Vuzix smart glasses and Kohler smart toilets.
That blow-for-blow fight between Amazon and Google highlights the tech industry's expectation that voice assistants will play a much bigger role in your digital life this year. Executives from both companies at CES talked about bringing their voice assistants to many more places like cars, earbuds and office meeting rooms, so your voice assistant can seamlessly be available to you anytime and anywhere -- apparently even on the toilet.
"If voice is going to be everywhere, you want to see voice transition from the home, when you get into your car. … You'd also want it at work," said Steve Rabuchin, Amazon's vice president of Alexa Voice Service and Alexa Skills. "We're going off into auto and these other places because we believe voice is a natural interface and it should be ambient."
So far, voice assistants have built up a fanbase as controllers of the smart home , helping people play music or operate their connected lights. The challenge will be whether these assistants can effectively transition into other places. That test is already playing out in phones , with Apple 's Siri, Alexa and Google Assistant already available in oodles of handsets, but results have been mixed.
Samsung is also working to bring its assistant Bixby into its TVs and appliances this year. Siri, meanwhile, was wholly overshadowed at CES and is in danger of falling well behind the pack.
Plus, some customers, concerned about privacy, may not want their assistants to travel with them. Others might be annoyed if someone is loudly chatting with his assistant out in public, requiring new guidelines for voice assistant etiquette.
What I can say?
At a posh suite in the Wynn resort, Gummi Hafsteinsson, product management director for Google Assistant, last Tuesday sat by two new Google Assistant-powered smart displays, which are essentially smart speakers with built-in touchscreens. Google teamed up with Sony, Samsung-owned JBL, LG and Lenovo to create four of these displays, which had been unveiled at CES the day before.
With so many companies working to add voice assistants into their products, Hafsteinsson said Google wanted to come to CES -- even though it's avoided a public presence at the show in past years -- to show its support for the growing Google Assistant ecosystem.
"We're here with all the partners," he said, "to make sure we're talking about the broad story, talk about the ecosystem … doing it in a way that makes sense to the user so they get the choice they want."
In 2018, he said, Google will work to make its assistant more conversational so it's easier to use, more capable and, with the help of Google's partners, more nearly ubiquitous.
"When you think about what's happening this year, we're trying to make the experience richer without making it more complicated," Hafsteinsson said while gesturing to one of the smart displays.
Amazon's Steve Rabuchin, at the company's meeting space at CES 2018, stands by a set of Alexa development kits. These kits help hardware makers create new Alexa-powered devices.
At the show Wednesday, at the Sands Expo and Convention Center, Amazon's Rabuchin discussed a similar game plan for the coming year.
"We'd love Alexa to be moving with you," he said in a corner of a large private meeting space Amazon set up at the show, which included a handful of glass displays filled with Alexa-powered gadgets .
The e-commerce heavyweight is inching closer to that goal. Rabuchin said that Alexa is integrated into over 4,000 smart-home devices from 1,200 brands and that more than 30,000 Alexa skills (Amazon's term for voice apps) are now available. He added that the Alexa economy is showing signs of strength, with some Alexa developers making "over six figures" through checks Amazon pays for the most popular skills.
He conceded that there are hurdles to bringing Alexa into more areas of your life, but added that the company is thinking about how to make Alexa useful in each of those different places. The assistant won't do the exact same things in your car as it will on your personal computer or in an office space.
One thing Rabuchin said isn't changing soon is Amazon's ads policy, which strictly limits advertising on Alexa. He batted down reports this month that Amazon was talking to brands about bringing more ads to the assistant.
"There's no change in our advertising policy," he said. "A couple stories broke in the last couple weeks that we were going to do more. There's no truth to those."
Everywhere for everybody
It might be hard to imagine why you would want a digital assistant on your face in a pair of smart glasses or inside a toilet so you can flush using your voice. Rabuchin said these integrations are all about giving customers choice. He said Amazon is also happy to have voice assistants work together -- like Alexa and Microsoft's Cortana do -- for the same reason.
Back at the Google booth, amid the one-man show, Carol Raymundo, a CES attendee, had another idea.
The 43-year-old from Albany, Oregon, manages the Center for Accessibility Resources at Linn-Benton Community College, helping students at the school that have learning, cognitive or physical disabilities.
She said she sees lots of potential for people with disabilities to use Google Assistant and Alexa to make their daily routines easier, while also making that accessibility unobtrusive and helpful for everyone.
"If you already have it into your technology naturally," she said, "it's better."
CES 2018: CNET's complete coverage of tech's biggest show.
The Smartest Stuff: Innovators are thinking up new ways to make you, and the things around you, smarter.