Mundie's analogy has some holes

A News.com reader writes that the viewpoint of Microsoft Senior Vice President Craig Mundie ignores two basic issues his analogy to electrical distribution helps illustrate.

2 min read
Mundie's analogy has some holes

In response to the Jan. 18 Perspectives column by Craig Mundie, "Computing you can rely on":

Mundie's perspective on reliable and trustworthy computing ignores two basic issues his analogy to electrical distribution helps illustrate. General public acceptance of safe and reliable electrical power emerged when:

1. Uniform electrical-power distribution was overseen by quasi-governmental regulators to promote fair, stable pricing and to prevent unfettered profiteering by monopolistic commercial pioneers.

2. Professionally licensed engineers and trade craftsmen assumed responsibility, and the corresponding liability, for the production and delivery of uniformly available electricity.

Mundie, and Microsoft, cannot be faulted for acting in their own self-interest. And while Mundie's short essay understandably avoids these issues, his company's record for truly supporting the development of trustworthy, reliable computing casts a dark and puzzling irony on his words.

The tone of his essay implies that to "build trust into these systems from the ground up" is primarily a technological challenge. To look past even cursory mention of the critical business, legal, regulatory and academic factors in achieving trustworthy computing that swirl around the realm controlled by Microsoft, Mundie's viewpoint is difficult to take more seriously than a statement of the nearly obvious.

George L. Carroll
Arlington Heights, Ill.



Latest Headlines
display on desktop
Nokia beats Street despite weak market
Greenspan remarks strengthen stocks
More layoffs for Gateway
E*Trade eyes prospects in China, Taiwan
Sony finds glitch in Vaio PCs
EU talks on HP-Compaq deal continue
Microsoft fires back at AOL
EarthLink lands deals with PC makers
EMC posts loss, sees more cuts
Lexmark misses the earnings spot
HP claims big step in tiny chips
Alleged eBay hacker wants lawyer back
Airline industry grounds high-speed Net
Chip-equips on road back?
Commerce One shifts to old territory
Tech firms pitch politicians on security
City restricts cybercafes after killing
Microsoft, government share the hot seat
Napster settlement delayed
Siebel's fourth-quarter net income falls
This week's headlines