Melatonin Content in Gummy Form Could be a Gamble, Study Suggests

Supplements, including melatonin, aren't strictly regulated like medicine is, but a new study found many gaps in melatonin content compared to what the label says.

Jessica Rendall Wellness Reporter
Jessica is a writer on the Wellness team with a focus on health technology, eye care, nutrition and finding new approaches to chronic health problems. When she's not reporting on health facts, she makes things up in screenplays and short fiction.
Expertise Public health, new wellness technology and health hacks that don't cost money Credentials
  • Added coconut oil to cheap coffee before keto made it cool.
Jessica Rendall
2 min read
A person holds four orange and red melatonin gummies in the palm of their hand
Grace Cary/Getty Images

A study published Tuesday in the medical journal JAMA suggests some melatonin supplements, a popular sleep aid, may contain misleading amounts of the ingredient. 

Of the 25 brands included in the gummy study, 22 were inaccurately labeled and actually contained 74% to 347% of the amount of melatonin advertised on the label. Only three out of 25 supplements matched the label within about 10% of the amount advertised, and one supplement actually contained CBD instead of melatonin.

While the study only included melatonin that comes in gummy form, not capsules or pills, and it tested only one sample per brand, the study highlights the precariousness of the supplements industry. Supplements are not regulated as medicine or subject to the same rules by the US Food and Drug Administration. The JAMA study's findings are also not completely out of left field: A Canadian study on melatonin supplements published in 2017 had similar findings.

In addition to being a popular supplement for adults, melatonin is used by some children, who as the authors of the study point out, increased their use of melatonin during the pandemic. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics' blog, melatonin may be a short-term solution for certain children, but parents should always consult their pediatrician before beginning melatonin supplements and start with the lowest possible dosage. Adults, too, should always start with the lowest perceived dose of melatonin and err on the side of less rather than more. 

What melatonin is, and signs you've taken too much 

Melatonin is a hormone that our bodies produce that helps us become tired and fall asleep at night. Melatonin supplements mimic that effect. 

In 2020, melatonin was the most frequently ingested substance children took reported to poison control, according to a 2022 report from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Most children in the study had no symptoms, and the majority of those who were hospitalized were teenagers with intentional ingestions, according to the report. 

Still, there's a potential for more serious side effects, as is true for any supplement or medicine. 

According to the Cleveland Clinic, signs of a melatonin overdose in children include upset stomach, vomiting, diarrhea and tiredness. Other side effects may include trouble breathing. If you're concerned you or your child may have taken too much melatonin, reach out to your doctor or call 911.

As a blog post by Boston's Children Hospital points out, there's been a potential for variability in labeling with what you're really getting in terms of melatonin. But you may be able to feel more certain in some supplement brands if they have "USP Verified"
on the label, as the AAP notes, which means they contain the ingredient as listed on the label. 

Read more: 3 Signs You've Built Up a Sleep-Aid Tolerance and What to Do Instead 

The information contained in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as health or medical advice. Always consult a physician or other qualified health provider regarding any questions you may have about a medical condition or health objectives.